Unions Add 25% to Affordable Housing Costs with No Benefit
Started by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008
Discussion about
Unions Make Affording Housing Cost 25% More with 0 Benefit.... or, we just get 25% less housing for the $$$. Thanks unions! http://www.chpcny.org/Prevailing_wage.html Briefly, our review indicates that: • Imposing prevailing wages for affordable housing construction could increase the cost of labor, increasing total development costs by about 25%, resulting in the need for higher government... [more]
Unions Make Affording Housing Cost 25% More with 0 Benefit.... or, we just get 25% less housing for the $$$. Thanks unions! http://www.chpcny.org/Prevailing_wage.html Briefly, our review indicates that: • Imposing prevailing wages for affordable housing construction could increase the cost of labor, increasing total development costs by about 25%, resulting in the need for higher government subsidies or, in their absence the construction of fewer affordable units. In a typical apartment, rents might increase by about $400 per month, thereby increasing the amount of annual income a household would need to afford the rent by $16,000. Conversely, to keep the rent affordable to the same household, government subsidies would have to double or production of units would be cut in half. • There is no evidence that imposing prevailing wages would improve construction quality. • Construction fatality data in New York City does not indicate that imposing prevailing wages on affordable housing construction would result in fewer construction-related fatalities. • The higher wages that would result from imposing prevailing wages on affordable housing would be less likely to benefit black and Latino construction workers, and may well cost many of them their jobs. These workers are already disproportionately under-represented in the construction industry and in the unionized construction trades, and they are disproportionately found in the lower wage sectors of the construction trades. • Most non-prevailing wages as reported in government data, while lower than union wages, are not unreasonable. Even the lowest wages are, for the most part, not unreasonable for entry-level construction workers. To the extent that there are inadequate wages and working conditions, these result more from the undocumented status of workers, who might find themselves without a construction job if prevailing wage laws were instituted. Regardless of wage level, some workers are not receiving fringe benefits. [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
17 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
8 Comments
-
9 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
I expect the Obama "stimulus" to have some kind of prevailing wage clause for unions for any construction projects built with the stimulus/bailout money. If so, God help us... the pigs are at the trough
The unions helped buy Obama's election. $500 million of contributions. More in registration drives and calls.
They are now coming to collect...
Payment #1, the Employee "Free Choice" Act... which Obama wrote, and has is biggest lie in the title. It removes choice from the employees, it gets rid of the secret ballot.
We will be paying the bill for decades.
When did union bashing become the norm in this country? The unions built the middle class, and collective representation of workers is a key component of functioning democracies. Do you want contruction and building workers who cannot support their families and have no benefits? Who have no protection against the whims of mercurial supervisors? The Free Choice Act is on the horizon only because the Bush administration and years of union-busting mentality at the NLRB have kept employees from being able to exercise their choice for unions in proper elections. Unscrupulous employers and the complicit NLRB have created a system that keeps rightfully elected unions from taking their place at the bargaining table. Employers and the NLRB tie up the process for years and years, causing employees to lose hope and faith in the system. Check out the book Big Squeeze by Greenhouse, the NYTimes labor-management reporter. Ironic, nyc10022 that you speak of paying the bill for the Employee Free Choice Act when the REAL bill you and your grandchildren will be paying for a century is for the hideous excesses of the Bush adminstration and deregulation. I expected more insight and judgment from you.
> The unions built the middle class
What happened a half century ago doesn't excuse what they are doing today.
> collective representation of workers is a key component of functioning democracies
That combined with fair and honest bargaining. When legislated, that is no longer the case.
> Do you want contruction and building workers who cannot support their families and have no benefits?
Now sure how that excuses some from making 2 or 3x what they need to support their families (while other families make NOTHING) because it was legislated.
Or how about everything costing more, fewer families having HOUSING because the union needs to fund its corruption.
> The Free Choice Act is on the horizon only because the Bush administration and years of union-
> busting mentality at the NLRB have kept employees from being able to exercise their choice for
> unions in proper elections.
Let me get this straight... because there haven't been proper secret ballots in elections... the best response is to GET RID OF ELECTIONS?
> Check out the book Big Squeeze by Greenhouse, the NYTimes labor-management reporter.
Check out the book "While America Aged", by the WSJ employer.
> the REAL bill you and your grandchildren will be paying for a century is for the hideous excesses of
> the Bush adminstration and deregulation
One scum doesn't excuse another...
> When did union bashing become the norm in this country?
When did unions become the most corrupt part of government?
The Fair Choice Act is necessary to level the playing field and to make up for years and years and years of abuse by employers and the NLRB. It's not the best scenario, I agree, but there are many points in which we voice our choices without a secret ballot. This is a petition process, not an election or open vote in a room, but even that is what all of our legislative bodies do, so it's not so bad. The law provides protection against intimindation, etc., but until now, the only entity with the power to intimidate has been the employers, and they have succeeded.
As to corruption, the LMRDA has gone a long way to correct corruption in unions, and enforcement has been tough (while insufficient resources, we now see in grand form, were not going into other areas of enforcement, such as the SEC). On this one, you are the one living in the past. Organized labor must still have a place in our society as it does in all other advanced policitcal states. When it doesn't, we see what happens -- China, for example. You suggest there is not need for collective repretation today, ut surely you grasp now that, without protections for workers who wish to collectively bargain, there will be abuses. The single hourly paid employee has no voice and no power without a union. Without a union contract, for example, emploees work "at will" and can be fired just becuase the supervisor didn't like them. So it's more than wages. In any event, where on earth did you get the idea that the working class is making two or three times what they need to live? Have you been listening to right wing radio? Sounds like the old welfare queen gambit. Get the facts, 10022, and look a little beyond your UES existence. Talk to the clerks at Walmart, if you dare.
I agree that one scum doesn't excuse the other, but just because a union is given a place at the table doesn't mean that they will be allowed to run away with the fisc. There is absolutely no indication that anything you will "pay for" for decades, as you asserted, will result from the Free Choice Act. It didn't during the days of union strength. Indeed, these tough times are replete with examples of unions working with employers to deal with the economic challenges ahead. Sure, some employers are not tough or persuasive enough to take a strong economic stand with the unions at the table. Pataki was a grand example of that. But the result STILL was not the two to three times that you cite. What's your source for that little gem?
unions idealogically are good, but implemented poorly. reform is needed and unions should not exist as they do today.
> but even that is what all of our legislative bodies do, so it's not so bad
Yeah, I don't know if "its what our government does, so its not bad" really works for me as a rationale...
> On this one, you are the one living in the past.
If you think corruption is a thing of the past, then I have a bridge to sell you.
> Organized labor must still have a place in our society as it does in all other advanced policitcal
> states.
Interesting... because unions have been losing power in most advanced political states (including ours). That they have started trying to get legislated what they can't do in terms of organizing just shows how desperate (but no less dangerous) they have become.
> When it doesn't, we see what happens -- China, for example.
And then democracies progress, and we get... laws. Welcome to the future.
If your validation for unions is "China needs them", then you are doing an awful good job of proving my case.
> You suggest there is not need for collective repretation today, ut surely you grasp now that,
> without protections for workers who wish to collectively bargain, there will be abuses.
There is more abuse in the systems WITH collective bargaining - see the MTA, the SEIU, etc. - than there are without.
> In any event, where on earth did you get the idea that the working class is making two or three
> times what they need to live?
1) Check out the wage rates for the auto unions.
or 2) I can see what my parents make (both union members for quite some time) or my grandparents, or much of my family. All union members who have a large problem with the unions.
> Get the facts, 10022
Careful with the hypocrisy.
> Talk to the clerks at Walmart, if you dare.
I actually have. What's your point?
Only that we pay more for pretty much everything in this city because of the union tax... god knows the poor people of this city could use some cheap drillbits.
Protectionism is just protectionism. it costs us all money.
> but just because a union is given a place at the table doesn't mean that they will be allowed to run
> away with the fisc.
Except that has been the case. When the government becomes the other party, and the government can't get elected without those members, we get the run-away stupidity.
As we have with the MTA, the teachers union, the SEIU, go down the line.
The state legislature is right in with the union corruption. They were bought and paid by it.
> It didn't during the days of union strength.
Care to back that up?
"unions idealogically are good, but implemented poorly. reform is needed and unions should not exist as they do today."
right on...
Private sector almost got that done, but they the unions went for the government corruption angle, and have been legislating their own existence for some time.