maintenance increases for 2009
Started by marcyf64
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2
Member since: Jun 2008
Discussion about
Will the new year ring in increases in maintenance charges in most coops?
Energy is down, of course not
but city taxes should be rising and energy costs aren't down from last winter just the summer
Many coops levied increases in anticipation of tax increases. However, the RE tax increases the city will be imposing will take effect sooner than the next city's next fiscal year it seems, and this was not anticipated. Essentially, this creates a six month period coming up when taxes will be higher but coops did not account for this in their budgets. As a result, some have already begun to revise upward their maintenance increases. For example, having announced a 7% increase at a November town hall meeting, a coop may well now have to send out letters that the increase will actually be 9.5% effective 1/1/09. The alternative is to run a deficit for 6 months and try to make it up later, but that is a dangerous game that most coop boards would not want to play.
YES, taxes are up so that will translate into higher maintenances.
Are condos with a 421a, or awaiting a 421a, absolutely immune from property tax increases
for the first 10 years? Are the rules for the 421a and the 41j carved in stone, or can the city
change it's mind?
Good question JMGJAG. I'm not sure that anyone knows how that's going to go for sure now (a few people have asked the question on this board without any insights).
I received my statement from NYC Department of Finance today. My building has a 25 year 421-A tax abatement and my statement reflects a little under a 5% increase in my annual tax bill. Considering how ridiculously low my property taxes are (it was $41/year)- I am fine with the increase. The abatement still holds- just at a higher rate. I know this doesn't answer JMGJAG's question, but it starts heading down that path. Many buildings that hold longer term abatements such as mine are in areas that needed stimulus, so I think it would be a difficult path to revoke. The areas that received the shorter 7 and 10 year abatements were questionable,frequently in areas that did not need stimulus, which is why they changed the laws recently anyway.
"Are condos with a 421a, or awaiting a 421a, absolutely immune from property tax increases
for the first 10 years? Are the rules for the 421a and the 41j carved in stone, or can the city
change it's mind?"
I believe the 421s work of partial assessments. So they'll still go up by the %. The discount is there, but a discount on a larger amount. Still the taxes are SO low generally it shouldn't matter. But, as the 20 years end, its going to be rough when future buyers see the anticipated taxes (especially compared to older co-ops, which are SO much lower). Thats the dilemma here... the 421 abatements are generally on apartments that will get some fairly high taxes later...