NYT article "Striking Declines Seen in Manhattan Real Estate Market"
Started by westie
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 41
Member since: Nov 2008
Discussion about
finally a times article that actually reports what is going on in nyc real estate.
“came to a grinding halt on Sept. 15"
How often have I been laughed at when I said that the cause of this severe recession was letting Lehman go bankrupt?
Very often.
Every chart shows it.
Dogma dictated the decision - "no government money." And now look what it's cost.
This decline has not yet begun to show its effects here. 50% down from the peak.
Where's spunky?
“When the market solidifies itself and everyone feels confident that we are on solid ground, you are going to have hordes of buyers,” said Diane M. Ramirez, the president of Halstead.
And when the sun comes up in the morning, there will be daylight.
Steve, why do you continue to insist that Lehman caused this, rather than that Lehman was a casualty of something that was already in motion? Its a reasonable opinion, but to insist its fact because the charts took a turn after it implies you don't understand coincidence isn't nec equal to causation. You do understand that don't you?
steve - you are so spot on w/ your lehman comment. in retrospect, it was definitely the turning point by almost any measure.
as a side note, i'm surprised that there isn't a better case schiller type of like for like comparison for nyc apartments. everything is based off of mean/median calculations which we all know are subject to heavy distortions.
Here we go again. And the first house destroyed by Katrina is clearly the cause of all the destruction that followed. Every single chart shows this.
that's how dominoes fall. there is little question in my mind that the fall of lehman was directly responsible for the rapid destabilization of virtually every credit market (and they were shaky to begin with). this in turn led to the subsequent failure of AIG, etc. which only further exacerbated the credit markets and concurrently led to the collapse of the global equity markets. again, further stressing global economies which led to even less confidence and even greater declines in credit and equity mkts.
Is that how dominoes fall, or when a storm comes is it just the weakest houses that get torn apart. Listen, I am not even saying it is not possible... but to offer charts as 'proof' of causality, that is just silly. Didn't AIG fail on account of the CDS insurance it wrote? Did Lehman hold enough of AIGs CDS to call it the cause of AIGs demise? The 'cause' was the fact that the CDS were triggered and AIG didn't have enough money to meet its obligationt to pay.
"rather than that Lehman was a casualty of something that was already in motion?"
Had Lehman been rescued and unwound (which is what they did with AIG) the credit markets would not have frozen. It had two impacts: first, market confidence was lost, and banking operates on confidence. Bear gets rescued, Fannie and Freddie get rescued, but Lehman doesn't. Why?
If you're a bank you think, "I'm not giving anyone money if there's a chance they go under and I won't get it back."
The second impact was that Lehman's assets are and were frozen. There are billions of dollars in assets that no one can gain access to as the company is unwound.
I admit that I, like so many, got burned because a) I didn't think they would let it go bankrupt, and b) I didn't predict that the effect would be so devastating. I knew it was stupid, just not how stupid it was.
And Paulson still won't admit that it was a mistake. And Bush says that the changes on Wall Street occurred during the Clinton Administration. And Gonzales says that he was a victim of the war on terror.
Can these people not take responsibility for anything?
Rhino, AIG is not the same as Lehman. Lehman collapsed because mark-to-market accounting required them to mark MBS's to $0. AIG collapsed because it sold CDS's which are illiquid, and don't require capital to back them up.
My point is the failure is what caused the credit market to collapse, not the cause of the failure.
"finally a times article that actually reports what is going on in nyc real estate"
Note that it's not in the Realtor, pardon, Real Estate section.
Of course they won't take responsibility...and to partisan dismay, Reagan, Greenspan, Clinton, Bush, Frank all have a hand in it. Why take responsibility for such a long developing phenomenon? In some sense, if credit needs to contract, how much should/can the government fight it? How many times can you send the message to take risk and you will be saved? According to game theory, the government should make it uncertain, or else create huge moral hazard. At least now, bankers can be sure haha, they actually need to consider risk.
Why did you get burned? Did you buy the stock? Who is responsible for that? :)
Here's my take on Lehman: It was a mistake, and no one in government can admit it was a mistake. Therefore, watch for ass-covering in the form of distinguishing Lehman from all others by criminalizing Fuld.
I can't tell you if the sharp market downturn was caused by what happened with Lehman, or if the timing was correlation but not causation. But there is a strong relationship between the two.
rhino, agree that the storm torn down the weakest house first. but leh had a $650bn balance sheet. it's the largest bankrupcy in global history. the fear/chaos it caused on virtually every level threw things from a nose dive into an all-out tailspin. from frozen assets, to counterparty panic, to skyrocketing effective overnight rates, to the collapse of the corporate CP market, and so on... put another way, if Hank had stepped in to save Leh the way they saved every single major player afterwards I believe things would still be bad, but not nearly as bad as they turned out to be
Isn't credit contracting because banks are stupid and real estate is cyclical? I'm not sure I beleive the government can control that. I also think there is long term value to the government seeding a little uncertainty in industry players as to whether or not they can take ridiculous risks and be bailed out. If there were no exceptions, that would be a scary set of incentives.
"Did you buy the stock?"
I owned stock, sold it, but then got back in too soon.
Alas. But I kept lots of cash.
Rhino, methinks Paulson can easily admit that letting Lehman go under was a mistake.
Special_K, I believe your analysis to be correct. And stating that the government had no authority to do anything is backpedaling: the Fed, under exigent circumstances, can literally do anything it wants except declare war.
Oh, and no, I never owned LEH. I owned MER at one point but sold it at $75 for a nice profit. It went up to $90, and then down to almost nothing.
"finally a times article that actually reports what is going on in nyc real estate"
Its not reporting, thats one of the advertiser sections, if you couldn't tell.
Go to nytimes.com.
JOBS
AUTOS
REAL ESTATE
are separate from the news sections...