Miller Samuel Inventory Figures
Started by angler7
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 193
Member since: Oct 2007
Discussion about
I've used the Miller Samuel (distributed by Elliman) numbers religiously, as they provide good historical marketplace data. Elliman has no sway. They just slap their name on the report. However, J. Miller is expert at sussing the numbers for interpretations the broker community can hang their hats on. But the numbers have always been the numbers. Until now. Did anyone else notice the tremendous uptick in listing inventory, historically anyway, going back to Fourth Quarter 2000? I'm sure there is a rationale behind this and I trust Miller will explain his shift in methodology, however his inventory figures now look a lot closer to StreetEasy's.
http://ny.therealdeal.com/articles/fourth-quarter-drop-in-manhattan-home-prices-breaks-10-year-streak
"Another grim indicator of the health of the real estate market was listing inventory, which leaped 39.3 percent to 9,081 from 6,518 last year, according to Elliman's report. That's the greatest inventory level since 1998, except for two quarters in 2006, Miller said. The absorption rate is now 11.9 months, up from 7.8 months a year ago."
Until recently his 4Q07 figure was 5,133 and now he is indicating it is 6,518. Where did the additional 1,385 units come from? And, his 2Q06 and 3Q06 inventory figures used to be 7,640 and 7,623 respectively. Now he indicates they were north of 9,000 units.
You're right, angler7, Miller Samuel has changed its number. If you go to their 4th quarter 2007 report:
http://millersamuel.com/reports/pdf-reports/MMO4Q07.pdf
It shows inventories at 5,133. Suddenly they are up to 6,518. That's a 27% jump in the reported inventory figures.
Seems they were massaging the numbers, got outed by streeteasy.
Sales in Manhattan
We found 9,174 listings
Median price: $1,199,000 Median size: 1,148 ft² Median price per ft²: $1,135
At the current absorption level, however, that's more than a 12-month supply. It's a 12-month supply based on the historical values of the last 10 years (8,500 apartments per year according to Miller Samuel). Lots of the sales reported today went into contract over a year ago.
What matters is new contracts:
"He estimated that the number of signed contracts, which show current activity and which are not counted in the quarterly reports, has declined anywhere between 35 and 75 percent from the same period last year."
If his margin is from 35% to 75%, then he has no idea. But let's say new contracts are down 50%, somewhere in the middle. That makes today's inventory 24 months, with plenty of new construction coming on line in the next year.
angler7, sorry about the simultaneous post saying the same thing!
stevejhx - no worries on the simul-post. I agree with you on the absorption, though am not quite ready to infer sinister motives with the inventory. Let's see how he speaks to the change in methodology.
I always see evil in real estate brokers.