CPW Flat Sale
Started by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008
Discussion about
Well, if CPW is supposed to be the exception, what does it say when they're now selling flat from peak? More importantly, if it just closed, when was contract? http://cityfile.com/dailyfile/3793 "Marquis Jets co-founder Jesse Itzler and his wife, Spanx CEO Sara Blakely, have closed on the sale of their 14th-floor pad at 15 Central Park West for $8.7 million. That's a million less than their asking price, but $200,000 more than what they paid for it last March."
wow, no comment on this... I am awfully surprised...
nyc10022: I find this post rather misleading. Itzler and Blakely didn't buy #14K on the initial offering. They paid $8.5MM in Feb.08 for a resale that had closed for $4.775MM two months earlier.
Whoops.
wow. so nyc, having no shame, responds to his own post, expressing surprise that no one is interested in the topic he started, and then West81 undresses him. And now comes the obligatory response explaining why his point is still completely valid. Ahh, streeteasy.
just because you're snarky doesn't mean I'm not right..
> Itzler and Blakely didn't buy #14K on the initial offering
Who said that?
"what does it say when they're now selling flat from peak"
How is that misleading? I specifically noted from peak, not from original price. Its in my first sentence! And, hell, its in the QUOTE.
"That's a million less than their asking price, but $200,000 more than what they paid for it last March."
I was talking about prices flatenning out on the "hot" building.
BTW, ccdevi, you spend an awful lot of time telling folks what they should and shouldn't care about...
I do find it interesting.... more people concerned with finding an error that wasn't there than looking at the actual comp...
> Whoops.
Ironically, that describes your own post perfectly.
;-)
nyc10022,
there are so many examples of prices actually declining. this is an example of a price RISING. they sold the apartment for more than they bought it for. if you want to show examples of real estate declining in price, go find them. they are everywhere. if you use this example, fine, but what exactly is it supposed to tell us?
We've had the decline comps already, there is an entire thread... I've followed that one for a while.
I just thought it interesting that the one building thought to be the hot exception - and which frequently gets talked about - might have turned as well. I at no point tried to use this as an indication of where the medians are at...
15 CPW is certainly a talked about building, I thought it would be interesting discussion.
sorry 10022.. taking a long poop... what was in that rib roast?
15 CPW... is one of the "top" bldgs and if these f'ers can't come up with a measly $1MM add'l just to say I paid more... then the markets going to hell in a prada bag... Peace out.... hope there's more toilet paper....
Oh please, nyc10022, you're so obsessed with the same tune that you don't even bother with the research sometimes (this is what happens when you repost Curbed items here). West81st and happyrenter are right - this is a misleading post and a clear example of an INCREASE in sales price.
boy that was a tough call. what a tool, couldn't just say "oops, yeah my bad"
"you spend an awful lot of time telling folks what they should and shouldn't care about"
am i in the right thread?
"Oh please, nyc10022, you're so obsessed with the same tune that you don't even bother with the research sometimes "
You're so obsessed you responded without actually reading my post... now you are backtracking.
> boy that was a tough call. what a tool, couldn't just say "oops, yeah my bad"
Yes, I'm still waiting for you and bjw and W81 to admit the mistake...
Any time, tool...
How exactly am I backtracking? ccdevi is right - this is a slight "oops," and it's a bit petty to keep it up. I clearly read your posts, and for someone who loves to browbeat about the "crash," one would think you could find a better example than an apartment that sold for over 82% more than it did a year ago.
simple, W81 made the mistake of me thinking I was talking initial sale, when I clearly pointed out the more recent sale (in the quote and again separately).
You "whoops"ed the mistake because you didn't read carefully. Whoops.
> one would think you could find a better example than an apartment that sold for over 82% more than
> it did a year ago
and again for 2% more (less than inflation) 10 months later....
That was the point you missed.
> I clearly read your posts
that makes it worse for you.
whoops.
> and it's a bit petty to keep it up.
Exactly what I was thinking of you. but, at least you're not as bad as ccdevi, who has resorted to even more childish insults.
i'm just sitting here laughing, he actually thinks he's right...this board scares the shit out of me
this wouldn't be the first thread you were delusional on, so that doesn't mean much to me...
"That was the point you missed."
No, the point you missed was that your initial post was terribly misleading because you made no mention of this being a resale, so either you conveniently left off the initial sales price, or you didn't do the research. Either way, you were called on it. Hence, the "whoops." I mean, people you would undoubtedly qualify as "bears" called you on this too! Let's just move on...
i got it, get in your last comments... and THEN its ok to move on. ;-)
Just be careful when you call *me* childish...
10022: I initially inferred from your post that Itzler had purchased from the sponsor. I only found the original sale because I was trying to check comps.
Maybe the inference was dumb, but in any case that's why I found the post misleading - not intentionally deceitful, just misleading. It's simply my opinion, and you're welcome to disagree.
I hear you...
I assumed (mistakenly) that everyone would have gotten that it was a resale (well, resale of a resale) given the dates... Saying "resale" wouldn't have been meaningful because its a resale in either case.
Its also why I specifically said "from peak".
Had I been talking about a sponsor sale, I would CERTAINLY not have called that peak.