Limitations on Itemized Deductions
Started by jjh3d
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 63
Member since: Nov 2007
Discussion about
Why is there never a mention of the Limitations on Itemized Deductions? (Sorry if I missed it). From what I understand, at a certain income level one begins to lose the benefit of deducting that mortgage interest many of you are so fond of. Am I missing something?
You're dead-on. This was an unpleasant surprise for us last year, doing 2007 taxes (first one we filed jointly). I don't follow all the details, but you only get a percentage of your total deductions past a certain income level, and I think there's a sliding scale.
I think that is the AMT, alternative minimum tax. Unless Congress takes it away, which looks unlikely given the deficit, we are all screwed.
Are you sure? I thought mortgage interest and depreciating properties were some of the few things you could deduct around AMT.
*depreciation on properties not depreciating properties
Mortgage interest is not phased out under AMT. State & local tax deductions are.
I think charitable contributions escape the AMT. The way I understand it, which may be wrong, the AMT caps the total amount of itemized deductions a person/couple may claim. In New York, if you own, you're odds of getting nailed by the AMT are very high, as it is triggered by the amount of state/local/real estate taxes you pay. As your income goes up, at some point there is a greater allowance for those tax amounts, reducing the likelihood that you'll pay the AMT. This is one of the reasons that the properties in Harlem with the 25 year tax deduction were so appealing to me. It wasn't just the cost and no taxes, but it would have gotten me out of the AMT much earlier (we own a house upstate so I already have real estate tax amounts contributing to my AMT trigger).
Mortgage interest deductions are not phased out by income, and are not subject to AMT. You get the full tax savings on them at your marginal tax rate.
I think that you can only deduct interest on the first million of mortgage debt. Nothing to do with AMT.
How about the depreciation on properties if its an investment?
Rich investors must be hit by AMT also
Investment properties are treated differently from owner-occupied residential real estate.
"You get the full tax savings on them at your marginal tax rate."
Again, the last part not true. Do the calculation with AMT & you will see how untrue it is. The deduction is at your effective rate. You drank the real-estate Kool-Aid.
There is another limitation of itemized deductions that is based on income and multipliers, etc. It applies to all itemized deductions, including mortgage interest. For the AMT I was incorrect, both mortgage interest and charitable contributions are excluded from the determination of AMT obligations.
Yes, you can only deduct interest on $1M of mortgage debt.
modern, OP here. It appears that you are mistaken based on the replies and what I found snooping around the web. It appears that mortgage interest deductions ARE phased out by income, though not completely phased out (and this has nothing to do with AMT). I hope that you are correct but I think not. Do we agree on this? Anyone care to confirm?
Sorry, steve, I see that you have confirmed already. What really baffled me is why I never saw this taken into account in the million or so "rent v. buy" threads. They "buy" folks are always raving about that big tax break but often it's not as big as they think.
jjh3d, yes, I again agree with you. The limitation has nothing to do with AMT.
The way to take it into account when doing rent vs. buy is to use a lower tax rate when calculating the tax advantage. I adjusted my rent vs. buy math this way after our painful tax preparation for 2007 taxes.