Brooklyn prices down 7.5% in Q4
Started by Junkman
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 288
Member since: Jun 2008
Discussion about
http://www.reuters.com/article/bondsNews/idUSN1333H66620090113 North Brooklyn (Greenpoint and Williamsburg) an exception.
"North Brooklyn was the borough's only region to show a gain with a 3.7 percent increase in the median sales price, but that number is not reflective of the current market, Miller said.
Almost three-quarters of all sales in North Brooklyn were condominiums, many of whose prices were set as long as 18 months ago when the market was stronger."
"Cheaper, outlying sections of the city like Brooklyn are at relatively more risk than is the commercial and cultural center of Manhattan during such times, said Jonathan Miller, CEO of appraisal firm Miller Samuel..."
Interesting quote. What about the alternative argument that the decline in Brooklyn may be less, on a percentage basis, than that seen in Manhattan because the Brooklyn RE bubble didn't get as big as that in Manhattan? Thoughts?
Slope11217, I don't know if that argument really tells you much, even if it is right (and there is some evidence it is). Brooklyn is so much larger and arguably more diverse than Manhattan, that it's tough to pull useful conclusions from any borough-to-borough comparison.
My totally unscientific predictions:
Once Manhattan becomes more affordable, a percentage of new Brooklynites - those who preferred Manhattan but couldn't afford it - will defect. The schools and low taxes will keep some families here, but empty nesters will take their profits back to "the city", as we call it.
By the end of 2009, most prime neighborhoods will return to 2003 - 2004 prices, with some dropping to pre-2001 prices.
Places like Prospect Park South, with unique homes and good public transit, may revert only as far as 2006 prices (the beginning of their recent boom).
Red Hook (my neighborhood) will decline a bit, then stay static, as there is very little new inventory planned.
New construction along Fourth Avenue will cease, leaving those homeowners to complete the transformation of the neighborhood themselves. Some recent buyers will gladly sell at a loss if they see a chance to move to PS 321.
Williamsburg new development will be split - much will convert to rental property, and will do okay as such. The developers who can't afford to pull that switch will sell (at a loss) to other developers, which will drive down the ppsf in the area. The Edge will elect not to build the third tower (I have no basis for this whatsoever). The resulting unrestricted views in the other towers will make the property more appealing to buyers, and it will sell out the current inventory.
Anyone else care to make some unsubstantiated guesses?
I think thats a pretty decent overall review.