Skip Navigation

State of Manhattan Residential Real Estate

Started by RE_Economist
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Jul 2008
Discussion about
First time post from a long time reader and active student of the Manhatten RE market for over two decades. I propose my assessment of the Manhattan RE at the macro level. 1. Rental market bottoms during Q3 '09 as turnover hits a peak and stable price points are reached. I expect a further 10% general correction as condo rentals continue to reprice rental buildings, with stronger corrections of... [more]
Response by hofo
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 453
Member since: Sep 2008

Thanks for the insight.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

"3. As a typical contrarian, my instincts want to find a positive in the market to believe we are closing in on a bottom. Despite this, there is not a single indicator that exists which could even point to an imminent turnaround, and while the resiliency of Manhattan is hard to dispute, the reality of the wider economy prevails over time. Unemployment and taxes are on the rise, which makes a currently unaffordable market even more unaffordable."

Well said.

NYC isn't falling of a cliff, it will be fine. But note that we were also "fine" in 1996 (Yankees won, no one died) and prices were a lot less than they are now.

This isn't about the death of manhattan, its just about the realities of its life.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by reddog2669
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 121
Member since: May 2007

One of the most informative posts I've read. These boards get filled up with "Bears" and "Bulls" constantly bickering like children. I think it's safe to say that NY real estate sustained a boom thanks to the subprime mortgage stuff that allowed everyone to buy and created tremendous wealth amoungst the finance industry. This popped and NY will come down because of it. However, I'm not sure we are looking at the end of NYC... just a correction. I hope to buy my first place towards the end of this year or early 2010.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by divvie
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 456
Member since: Mar 2007

Excellent post. Well thought out and presented.

I hate to quibble but you did hit on a pet peeve on mine though.

People often mix up "the elephant in the room" (something so big and obvious that you cannot avoid it yet people still try to avoid talking about it) with "the 800lb gorilla" (the dominant player in a particular market who is so dominant it can basically crush the competition at will - microsoft were a classic example - google may be a better one now). The Axa financial TV ads particularly grate.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by UES_Buyer
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 212
Member since: Dec 2008

Like this post, especially number 4. I was ready to make the jump as a first time buyer about a year ago. Now, irrespective really of price, I'm no longer willing to do so.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by mjmsmith
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 16
Member since: Jan 2008

Re #5: what did terrorism do to Manhattan RE in 2001?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by october
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 145
Member since: Mar 2008

Wonderful post - thank you!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by RE_Economist
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Jul 2008

"Re #5: what did terrorism do to Manhattan RE in 2001?"

Good question and I'm glad I can clarify. I distinctly remember the immediate aftermath of 9/11 being a general fear to buy in marketplace, however, the impact in the financial district was drastic, to put it mildly. Bear in mind that in 2001, lower manhattan was not as residential and the impact was much more to commercial space than residential. Admittedly, the general market of Manhattan outside of lower manhattan was somewhat insulated given the remarkable bounce in the equity markets following 9/11 and the maintenance of paper wealth. If it wasn't for an aggressive tax abatement program and excess government incentives to build in lower manhattan, the situation would have remained worse for a much longer period of time. Many people to this day still refuse to even consider Tribeca given it's proximity to those terrible events. More importantly, 9/11 sustainably changed the value of 'trophy' buildings given their new reputations as targets.

Most importantly, terrorism raises uncertainty and doubts which creates an irrational downward pressure, if even for a short term event. In these times we face currently, given the sensitivity of the equity and RE markets, the impact of a devastating terrorist attack on Manhattan would create far more turmoil in short to mid term pricing than what we saw in 2002, and this is what I meant when I added this to my post.

All the best.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by RE_Economist
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Jul 2008

"People often mix up "the elephant in the room" (something so big and obvious that you cannot avoid it yet people still try to avoid talking about it) with "the 800lb gorilla" (the dominant player in a particular market who is so dominant it can basically crush the competition at will - microsoft were a classic example - google may be a better one now). The Axa financial TV ads particularly grate."

You are correct. I apologize for the improper use of 800lb gorilla.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment