Is this a good deal?
Started by afmarino
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 29
Member since: Feb 2008
Discussion about
418 East 59th Street. http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/building/418-east-59-street-manhattan
If you like the building and the location, yes - #16A is slightly ahead of the price-cutting curve. But that doesn't mean it won't go lower.
West 81st, Thank you for your input.
This is not a prime area; as such, I don't think it should be commanding over $1000/sf. Anything over $700/sf in this market is overpriced.
hejiranyc - I am not sure that kind of blanket statement can be made.
That said, this apartment is very east, near a lot of traffic, has very high maintenance and looks a bit smaller than 1400'. I would guess more like $1 million would be fair....but that is just me.
Wow, except for the traffic issue, 16A looks like a great place. They do need to throw in some city windows to keep the sound at bay though.
Agree on traffic and high maintenance. What's going on with the taxes? Are taxes included in maintenance (not sure how it works in condops), or does the $1 mean some sort of abatement that will eventually expire?
The original asking price was out of whack, so I would not use that as a reference point. This apartment looks to be about 1,200 ft and is in an area that is not highly desirable given bridge/traffic and how far East it is (particularly in a bear market). Hard to tell condition, but priced at 700-800/ft, would imply a price of $850-950k is reasonable. In this new world we live in, run of the mill 2 BR apartments aren't worth $1.2-1.5M, they will be worth 700-900k.
It is interesting that 26A ($1.825M) and 24A ($1.495M) have not adjusted to the new reality. Watch those prices come down by at least 500k and 300k, respectively. Crazy that 26A was asking $1,800/ft originally for a run of the mill 2 BR on 59/1st by the bridge. Where did this world go???