Great Site that proves RE BUBBLE in Manhattan
Started by anonymous
almost 20 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006
Discussion about
This is a site that actually lets you do REAL calcluations for buying a place. Showed me that the apt I was considering buying was about 80% overpriced (and so was most of the rest of Manhattan RE): http://www.housemath.us/
you can't afford Manhattan, so get real
shows the place I rent for 2400/month is about 100% overpriced (probably would go for about 7-800k)...wow...
Manhattan is overpriced..... really??
So offer 100% lass than asking and let us know how you did.
100% overpriced means it should be half the price.
Thankfully my deal tells me buying was a more prudent situation than renting
hope you are not factoring in the standard 4.5% real estate appreciation - prices are going down, you should do at most 2-3% over 10 years.
no not that high - it's just that my purchase price is not too high.
can I ask what you bought, what your Purchae Price was, what you rent currently and how much you pay in rent? Just curious as I'm trying to do the analysis myself. Thanks!
well i rent in a place which i feel is cramped - it is a alcove studio which has a wall up and i feel just cramped. It is 2300 in rent and they want to raise it to over 2400 with my renewal. I bought a 1 bedroom (between 625 - 650 sq ft) for 625k. It is a condo facing 58th between 8th/9th, full service building. It is a good deal versus area and building comps.
I posted above. For me the decision was for a one bedroom (which i wanted), should i find another place (which might include broker's fee) or buy an affordable one bedroom. . . and I was able to find this decent deal.
I guess you have to take into consideration what you'd pay for your new place, but when I did the math (I pay 2400/month) it came out that the apt. should really cost only about 370...
well it doesn't work like that if you say you are buying. I put in my purchase metrics and then it told me the true cost of my montly payments is 1600 and i could rent an equivalent at 1400. Anyway - it is a blackbox. I did analysis before buying and am happy to hold this for a long time and collect rent payments until a really great selling opportunity returns, if/when i move out.
original poster - although this is one of the best rent vs. buy calcuations out there...it's only a TOOL and doesn't prove one way or another that there's a bubble. It all depends on the assumptions you put in and how you interpret the results.
It showed me that I gat get a classic 6 on Fifth Ave for 425K
ha ha. . .yeah it is a tool - when it comes to black boxes - do your own work. it also doesn't let you deselect that you are married or not. At least that was what happened on my computer.
the only real assumptions are how many years you'll sell it in, rate of return on RE and portfolio return. I assumed 3% return on real estate over 10 years (which I think is generous) and 10% in portfolio (below average return for equities)...funny thought if you do the caluculations you find that if 3% return and 4% inflation and 10% return assumed, you are almost the same amount of worse off if you sell in 5 or 20 years - slightly less worse off if you sell in 10! I do think this shows that things are pretty overpriced compared to renting.
Well if you can a good deal - then the classic way to make money is buy low sell high. So if you can negotiate a decent price and sell at a high point in the market - you will do ok as a rule.
I really hope that this is a joke. The orginal poster doesn't
really believe that does he? Does he know where Manhattan is located?
Does the above poster know anything about math? Run the calculations and see for yourself.
"10% in portfolio (below average return for equities)..."
I love this website. You have idiots that write stupid stuff like what was written above. The poster is talking about the real estate prices being overpriced, and then writes about 10% plus return on equities. I figure this poster forgot about the stock market bubble in the late 90s that came crashing after 2000.
true you'd get burned if you invested in 2000 - everyone was screaming "bubble" b/c stocks were overpriced just like everyone is screaming "bubble" today with respect to real estate which is currently overpriced - so by your logic (and I do agree with you that investing in a bubble market is idiotic), the idiots today would be those investing in real estate
I think the first guy shoud move to mmmmm Kentuky. Georgia, South Dakota or any other place.
I hope There you can find a cheapper apt.:)
I don't think the first buyer said he couldn't afford real estate in manhattan, simply that it was overpriced. Not sure why you think he should move for having a rational opinion actually based on numbers and facts as opposed to NAR fantasy....
I think all of you are missing the point. The point of the website calculations is to tell you whether buying a specific apartment is a better way to spend your money than renting a specific apartment. Granted there are a lot of intangibles that we don't neccessarily know (like appreciation) but it does give a general snap shot of the best way to use your money.
i dont work for nar
I agree with poster who posted comment 2 posts ago re "missing the point". This is a tool best used to compare identical properties that are offered for sale or rent.
I agree - I just think that it clearly shows that properties are severly overpriced compared to what they are renting for - things have to line back up eventually and the average rent will never be 7k/month b/c not enough people can afford it
How does it clearly show that?
If you put in a price for a place in Manhattan it will show you how much it should cost you equivalently in rent to come out even if you sell in say 10 years - therefore, the place you buy should COST that much to RENT. Clearly most of these places can only command about half of the rent as the program shows therefore, the prices should drop by at least 50% to be back in sync.
I don't think thats gonna happen.... lols
maybe when the price of gas is 45 cents again!
Most people that have had to prove liquid and high net worth through the unique
coop board process can afford to leave their apts vacant & many do. Why would
someone sell their property for 1/2 of todays value? If your apt is paid off,
then any rent is gravy.
"I agree – I just think that it clearly shows that properties are severly overpriced compared to what they are renting for" actually in my case I am buying a place in queens and I did the math and the place I am buying is cheaper than what I would pay renting.
Ditto for place I am buying in Manhattan. I am not sure what the naysayers posting here are looking at. Maybe they all live in rent controlled apartments?
Thats why some people buy in Queens, Brooklyn & the Bronx and others buy in Manhattan.
Its what they can afford. Severly overpriced probably means they are a good investment
for some people and others cannot afford the game. Its a VERY SMALL piece of land.
Think musical chairs!
We've overpaid for several of our properties, bottom line is they are all worth much more now and we get great monthly cash flow. If we didn't pay top dollar we would not have ever owned them.
That calculator reminds me of the "Seinfeld" cheap knockoff tip calculator.
Look how much good it did them, probably best to delete that website.
broker alert above!!! broker alert above!!
The calculator is a great tool - would you buy a stock that was overpriced? Why buy RE that is way overpriced? It must come down to line up with rents as it has historically - what you paid for your house should come out in that calculator to be almost the same or slightly, but only slightly higher than the rent it calculates. 99% of properties in Manhattan don't fit this, but did about 4 years ago - this is called a bubble and things will come back in line over time.
To the poster above (#39), assuming for the moment that you are correct, then would it not be true that the values would be in line if rent rates increased as opposed to sales prices dropping? Are we not currently seeing a rather precipitous increase in rents?
there is a cap on rents though b/c most renters simply cannot afford 8k/month. Rents will probably increase a bit, and prices will probably fall steeply to get things back in line.
"probably" ;)
when it cost's 300K down + 10K a month to buy vs $6500 a month to rent a BETTER apartment, I think there's a correction due.
Then find a less expensive apt to buy or keep renting, You can't afford it.
I'm #43 and Yes, I can definitely afford a 1.5MM apartment right now, I made an informed decision to rent instead. Why are you so adamant that there will be no correction? I'm not saying that there will be one, but you seem hostile... perhaps your mortgage payments are putting the squeeze on? Did you get an ARM?
Actually you are way off. I'm a landlord that has actually helped one
renter buy their own place, because I felt bad about the length of
time they rented from me. I know what buying has done for us and
like to see others do well.
Never had an ARM and most properties I have bought I put 30% down on.
Started with 75 dollars, 30 years ago... today have 29 properties.
Just got back from the bank and deposited almost 20K in late rent payments.
I've just seen so many people piss away cash, that they could have invested in
real estate. Now besides great cash flow, lets talk high dollar real estate appreciation...
Look people, if you are happy renting then rent. No one who is buying gives a crap about your feelings on the market, or needs your advice. It is their decision. If you feel renting is a better option than buying; homeowners shouldn't say anything to you.
just don't want people to make a stupid mistake and buy - the calculator lays it all out for buyers so use it!!
To post 43. Have you considered your after tax cost? $10,000 per month pre tax is essentially equal to $6,500 in rent. Further, based on my experience as a renter what you are saying is not true. $10000 per month would cover interest expense on a $2MM loan - there is no way a $6500 apartment would be nicer than a $2.3MM purchase. You have everything so wrong that I am confident you will not even understand this post. And no I am not a broker - hate the useless ticks.
post 49, but he wouldn't have 10k per month to cover a $2MM loan, he would have 6.5k after tax on his paycheck and he'd have to cover the mortgage out of that. He'd only get the tax benefits end of year on his tax return. What are the tax strategies you use?
I can't comment on his cash flow. He was comparing renting at $6500 to buying at $10000. I assumed the issue was in what one could get for their after tax dollars not what he could afford. As usual people can't help but try to compare apples with oranges.
here is another one
http://patrick.net/housing/crash.html#links
i'm waiting for $200 a s foot, which i project will be in early 2009
then i'll buy
Why not wait for $100 per foot, which I project will happen in 2010?
To poster number 48... Why do you care if he makes a stupid mistake and buys?
Boy, I am so stupid. I wish I had known that prices were going to drop to $100/SFT by 2010 making Manhattan less expensive than Columbus, Ohio and Macon, Georgia. I really overestimated the importance of the New York economy. I am so happy I found this thread and can now comfortably wait for these brilliantly forecasted events to unfold. Bravo!
To post #52 - I checked out that site. The links are all over the map (literally and figuratively). For instance, one site projected that the natioanl market would be down 4.7% but Manhattan would be up 1.7%
http://www.housingpredictor.com/newyork.html
anyone know why the original link is not working?
think it is working now
And actually, to #43 and #49 above, as a buyer you do see the tax savings every month. You just increase the amount of your withholdings to match your projected taxes at the end of the year and bingo, your paychecks go up. That's what things like the Cost of Ownership tool on the Corcoran site are trying to reflect.
http://www.irs.gov/individuals/article/0,,id=96196,00.html
I ran some numbers through that web site calculator and found some of the analysis dubious if not downright wrong. It is not rational to assume an investment return greater than the mortgage rate of interest. If it were, no one would ever give you a mortgage; instead, they'd just go and invest the money themselves. The cost of owning is simply equal to the cost of the money used to buy and/or finance the home/condo/co-op added to the cost of maintainance/common charges and, and in the case of a condo, the cost of real estate taxes. That is your monthly cost and in a world without taxes that would be the end of the story. However, in our world, there are taxes and you should adjust accordingly because there are generally fairly substantial tax advantages inherent in ownership. Seems to me, as a general matter, the after-tax rate of return for ownership is generally somewhere in the range of 3.5%-4.0% which is roughly the rate of interest on NYC municipal bonds. Not a great deal; but not a horrible deal either. Trying to project the future rate of inflation, the future rate of price appreciation and how much you would earn if you had taken that money and invested it elsewhere is all just guesswork. No one really knows the answers to any of those questions though I do note that the population in NYC keeps seeming to increase with wage levels showing no signs of slowing down and interest rates looking like that they will stay at relatively low levels for a while all suggest that the market is likely (though hardly assured) to stay strong for the near term.
Also, what the website calculator can not take into account are the psychic rewards of owning and not being subject to the whim of what might turn out to be either a greedy or irrational landlord. Its just hard to put a price on some things.