To Purchase In 2009: Buying with your head or your heart...
Started by thetraveler
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 10
Member since: Sep 2008
Discussion about
Since selling my apartment in early 2008, and now coming up on a financial deadline to purchase a new one, I have become a bit OCD with the apartment search and selection process. Specifically, I continuously find myself looking at units with an internal battle between "head" decision factors like price per sq foot, building financials, ownership flexibility, etc... and attractions of the "heart" that I really want such as a decent city view, a terrace or roof deck, and not having to settle for a building I won't enjoy outside my space for the next 5+ years. So I pose this question to the masses: If forced to decide, and not able to have both completely satisfied, which wins in the battle between your head and your heart?
Response by manhattanfox
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1275
Member since: Sep 2007
Why the deadline? 2 yr irs grace to rollover no longer exists.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by newbuyer99
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Member since: Jul 2008
Pretty simple answer for me. Heart wins if you can easily afford it. Head wins otherwise.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by thetraveler
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 10
Member since: Sep 2008
My "deadline" is due to currently renting in an expensive sublet that will not be renewed as of July 1, and not wanting to move twice. Plus renting is basically like throwing money out the window since there is zero tax or investment benefit... Sorry, that's my parent's upbringing speaking not me...
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by tina24hour
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 720
Member since: Jun 2008
It sounds as if your heart is aligned with your head. Views, outdoor space, good common areas - these add to the value your property. It's not just about price per square foot. If you are planning on living there for the next five years or more (which you should, otherwise keep renting!), make sure you love where you live. If you do, the vicissitudes of the market will bother you less.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by sniper
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1069
Member since: Dec 2008
where are you looking?
go with a lists approach: list the deal breakers then cross reference them with apartments in your price range. see if what you want even exists in your range. take it from there.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by thetraveler
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 10
Member since: Sep 2008
Union Square, Flatiron, Gramercy, Noho-ish area. I have done the list thing and I know the required range, the must-haves, like to haves, but it just seems that the drop off of new inventory in the past 90 days and the lack of movement of existing inventory is limiting the options more and more. Compound that with so many legacy units failing to budge below their first reduced price, it's keeping co-op units in my area at $950 per sq foot, and condos around $1100 per on average. It's not to say many sellers or realtors are in "denial" but quite frankly I think more people who are selling to upgrade are not under any time pressure, and most are now content with six to nine month sell cycles. In the end, it's probably a waiting game, and I just need to keep my patience for these last three months of the search.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by vanderveen
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 63
Member since: Jan 2009
My comment will be limited to new constructions/conversions. The areas you mention do not have good/notable developments. The ones I have seen (and I think I have seen everything) in those areas have all been grossly over-priced cookie-cutters--with low ceilings.
Would you consider FiDi? I recently saw a unit @ 90 William. If I were to purchase right now, I would go for that development in a heartbeat. Very smart pricing, solid financials, unique layouts, attractive finishes, and the units are HUGE. I mean, where else can you have a 1,100 sq w/ 2 full baths in the $800k range?
Sure, Manhattan real estate WILL inevitably suffer, but at $800/SF (which is approx. 25% lower than comps) and good layouts/finishes, I'd be tempted to say it is among the best I have seen around. Also, no matter what your opinion on FiDi, with a significant (guaranteed) Federal money going into the area re-development, the property value MUST, MUST go up. They also cover all closing costs because they're looking to close up their sales office soon. The only catch: No vented dryer in the unit, so you must get one of those ventless washer/dryer combo units (which, by the way, is supposed to be greener than the conventional vented units, if you care).
Also, if you have kids, your kids go to one of the best schools in Manhattan. I know many people here won't give FiDi a chance, but go and visit. There are others, too, in the area that may be in your price range. I personally liked 88 Greenwich, but the units were much smaller. 99 John provides a "5-year buy back guarantee," that your purchased unit will appraised at 110% in 5 years (or something like that).
Good luck, and please keep us posted on your search.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by front_porch
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 5325
Member since: Mar 2008
It sort of depends on what you want your exit to look like.
If you buy with your head, you might like living in the place a drop less, but when you resell, you will find many buyers who are attracted by the same good numbers that attracted you.
On the other hand, if you buy a "delighter" -- for me it's a fireplace -- you will love living there. On resale, however, to get your top price, or sometimes even to resell at all, you have to wait for the buyer to whom that's also a delighter. So your exit will take longer.
If you can for a moment envision what will make you sell again -- a growing family? retirement? a new job? -- that will help you envision how long you can take to exit, and that will help you make the head vs. heart call.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by aboutready
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 16354
Member since: Oct 2007
thetraveler, prices have been very sticky in these areas. Not a lot have closed recently, but I've seen some movement. There were a lot of units sold to finance types, some of whom may be running low on severance soon. Hate to sound like a vulture, but the possibilities may get quite a bit better, but quite possibly not in the next three months. I'd take the hassle of moving twice in this market.
My parents told me the same thing about renting, but with a lot of hard work I've been able to overcome their lessons.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by divvie
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 456
Member since: Mar 2007
Don't bank on FiDi staying in the ps234 school district.
The new school in the Beekman tower is slated to open in 2010 and the kindergarten only incubator school in the Tweed couthouse building is opening this year for the sole purpose of ensuring that ps234 and p289 are not overcrowded this September. The zoning for the new Beekman tower school and the new one in BPC has not been decided yet but it would be logical to zone the South Street Seaport and FiDi areas for the new school.
Whatever is decided, anyone with kindergarten aged kids moving into the ps234 zone or ps89 zone from now on will likely be sending them to this new incubator school.
Thanks for the info on school zones. I quickly read the report. Still, the areas covered seem to draw similar demographics PS234 does. The FiDi area has no projects, and that'll greatly help the "consistency" in the quality of schools, it seems.
Later reports in the Tribeca Trib or Downtown Express (can't remember which) quoted parents that live in FiDi who were optimistic about the new schools for similar reasons.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by Admiral
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 393
Member since: Aug 2008
To Purchase In 2009: Buying with your head or your heart...
To Date In 2009: Thinking with your big head or your little head...
traveler - if u have enough money to buy with your heart and not worry about it, you will end up much happier than buying with your head.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by newbuyer99
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Member since: Jul 2008
Moving twice is a huge pain. We seriously considered buying in mid/late 2008 for that reason - has a lease expiring 12/31/08 and needed a bigger place. In the end, we decided to bite the bullet and rent, i.e. move twice. The economic difference for us was just too great. With your July deadline, you have the benefit of the extra 6 months for prices to drop and become more negotiable.
There might be a middle position - seriously look to buy for the next 3-4 months. Pull the trigger if you find an apartment you absolutely love, and/or an amazing deal. Otherwise, rent.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by thetraveler
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 10
Member since: Sep 2008
Agreed. In summary, in the next 6 months, if I find "the" place, buy. If not, then wait. I also met last night a 10 year Manhattan real estate broker and spent some time discussing the current market and she said three very interesting things:
1. If you you are a seller and don't have to sell right now then don't. But if you are ready to buy wait until April / May when new inventory will be on the market.
2. Look at the quarterly average prices in Manhattan over 10 years in the Q4 PDE report at http://www.prudentialelliman.com/NYCPhotos/retail_reports/mmo4q08.pdf Her quote: "I am not a chart person, but no one ever lost money not buying at the north slope of Mt. Everest"
3. Mortgage rates falling and staying below 4.5% and tax changes are the only thing that will "ease the decline" or support any inventory reduction.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by front_porch
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 5325
Member since: Mar 2008
I disagree with your broker friend about timing. If you want to wait 1-2 years that's one thing, but if it's just a matter of a couple of months, traditionally spring is a high season when lots of shoppers come out and poor timing for buyers. I doubt that there will be much inventory on in April that's not on in February, but you will be facing other shoppers.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by patient09
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1571
Member since: Nov 2008
"I doubt that there will be much inventory on in April that's not on in February, but you will be facing other shoppers."
Ali...tell that to the 4,000 folks who are in the process of losing their jobs at BAC/MER right now and the rest of the week. Not to mention the ones at BNP that lost their jobs on Monday and it didn't even make the news. Inventory will continue to rise every week, right through the "once" busy Spring season. This much hyped time of year is when the first shovel load of shit will hit the fan. Imagine, the price cuts that will occur when you don't get ANY bids on your apt halfway through Spring.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by front_porch
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 5325
Member since: Mar 2008
patient, I feel sorry for those people (I've been laid off before, and it stinks) but I have lived in New York for 20 years, and my sponsoring broker has been doing this for 25, and unless this suddenly turns into the 1930s we have seen this kind of recession in the city before. A quarter of Wall Streeters lost their jobs in previous cycles too.(And I was on the Street in '88, I remember that one).
Past performance no predictor of future performance blah blah blah, but generally -- even in the dark days of the late '80s -- there's been a spring upturn.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by hejiranyc
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 255
Member since: Jan 2009
yes, ali r., but you didn't mention that during the last major RE crash in the early 90s, coop studios on lower 5th Ave. could be had for $40K.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by front_porch
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 5325
Member since: Mar 2008
I bought my first apartment in '96 (Chelsea doorman alcove studio) for $65K, nine years after the stock market crash. However among other things, you sure you couldn't get 5% money.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by madamminna
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12
Member since: Feb 2008
Has the city seen this kind of aggressive appreciation before? Was the rent/buy ratio as out of whack in the late '80s as it is today?
I'm sure this has been posted and discussed here (and I missed it) but I stumbled across this (relatively) recent Urban Digs post and the numbers are staggering:
It's not to say that I believe the playbook has to be completely thrown out this year because of the unique situation we are in. And I am in no way a broker or expert on this matter, but all things that are bought in frenzies up or down from stocks and bonds, to homes and cars (including the HDTV crazy people at Union Sq. Circuit City this past Saturday) must eventually counter react, if even moderately, to stabilize. In no way can it be "normal" to have such high compounded year over year growth for a decade with only an only increasing curve, without having some reversion to the mean. But then again, I am a buyer and in this case bias.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by manhattanfox
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1275
Member since: Sep 2007
You really need to challenge your concept of paying rent is throwing money out the window. After doing really well on two prior properties -- i am a renter for the first time in 10 years. i also rent and aprtment that would cost more than twice as much to own. and prices willc ome down by a lot. So unless something absoltely grabs you and you are madly in love. try to be patient. Cash is lovely.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by ss400k
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 405
Member since: Nov 2008
i always buy with my man clit, for those that know..know
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by duvravcic
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 78
Member since: Jan 2009
manhattanfox, some people like to lease their cars because of its lower monthly cost. Others would never lease their vehicles because their lives aren't just about saving money and they just want to own their cars.
The same argument applies here. Some people don't like to rent, FULLY AWARE that it can be significantly cheaper to rent. I want to live in an apt I own, without ANY possibility of having to move out without wanting to. It's not cheap, but it is what I want.
Prom dresses are cheaper to rent... Wedding gowns are cheaper to rent... Vacation homes are cheaper to rent... Cheaper... Cheaper... Cheaper... That's not how some of us choose to live!!!
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by nyc212
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 484
Member since: Jul 2008
>some people like to lease their cars because of its lower monthly cost. Others would never lease their vehicles
I could lease a Lexus GS430 for less $/month than purchasing an ES350, but I'd never lease. It's probably a poor financial decision but leasing a vehicle just doesn't appeal to me. I feel the same way about renting an apartment. Heck, living in Manhattan, renting or owning, is a poor financial decision anyhow!
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by newbuyer99
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Member since: Jul 2008
Goes back to the head vs. heart debate.
I choose to have a car in NYC, because I like the convenience, even though it doesn't make a ton of financial sense. But it's a decision that in the aggregate, over the life of the car, will only cost me maybe $10K vs. renting whenever I want one (got a good deal on the car, and good deal on garage).
By contrast, if I chose to buy an apartment in 2007-2008, rather than renting, that decision, over the time I'd live in that apartment, would likely cost me hundreds of thousands. Not something I was willing to do, even though I am all for the non-financial benefits of owning.
I feel a lot better about a $10K "heart" decision than about a $500K "heart" decision. Maybe if I had a ton of $$, I'd feel differently.
Why the deadline? 2 yr irs grace to rollover no longer exists.
Pretty simple answer for me. Heart wins if you can easily afford it. Head wins otherwise.
My "deadline" is due to currently renting in an expensive sublet that will not be renewed as of July 1, and not wanting to move twice. Plus renting is basically like throwing money out the window since there is zero tax or investment benefit... Sorry, that's my parent's upbringing speaking not me...
It sounds as if your heart is aligned with your head. Views, outdoor space, good common areas - these add to the value your property. It's not just about price per square foot. If you are planning on living there for the next five years or more (which you should, otherwise keep renting!), make sure you love where you live. If you do, the vicissitudes of the market will bother you less.
where are you looking?
go with a lists approach: list the deal breakers then cross reference them with apartments in your price range. see if what you want even exists in your range. take it from there.
Union Square, Flatiron, Gramercy, Noho-ish area. I have done the list thing and I know the required range, the must-haves, like to haves, but it just seems that the drop off of new inventory in the past 90 days and the lack of movement of existing inventory is limiting the options more and more. Compound that with so many legacy units failing to budge below their first reduced price, it's keeping co-op units in my area at $950 per sq foot, and condos around $1100 per on average. It's not to say many sellers or realtors are in "denial" but quite frankly I think more people who are selling to upgrade are not under any time pressure, and most are now content with six to nine month sell cycles. In the end, it's probably a waiting game, and I just need to keep my patience for these last three months of the search.
My comment will be limited to new constructions/conversions. The areas you mention do not have good/notable developments. The ones I have seen (and I think I have seen everything) in those areas have all been grossly over-priced cookie-cutters--with low ceilings.
Would you consider FiDi? I recently saw a unit @ 90 William. If I were to purchase right now, I would go for that development in a heartbeat. Very smart pricing, solid financials, unique layouts, attractive finishes, and the units are HUGE. I mean, where else can you have a 1,100 sq w/ 2 full baths in the $800k range?
Sure, Manhattan real estate WILL inevitably suffer, but at $800/SF (which is approx. 25% lower than comps) and good layouts/finishes, I'd be tempted to say it is among the best I have seen around. Also, no matter what your opinion on FiDi, with a significant (guaranteed) Federal money going into the area re-development, the property value MUST, MUST go up. They also cover all closing costs because they're looking to close up their sales office soon. The only catch: No vented dryer in the unit, so you must get one of those ventless washer/dryer combo units (which, by the way, is supposed to be greener than the conventional vented units, if you care).
Also, if you have kids, your kids go to one of the best schools in Manhattan. I know many people here won't give FiDi a chance, but go and visit. There are others, too, in the area that may be in your price range. I personally liked 88 Greenwich, but the units were much smaller. 99 John provides a "5-year buy back guarantee," that your purchased unit will appraised at 110% in 5 years (or something like that).
Good luck, and please keep us posted on your search.
It sort of depends on what you want your exit to look like.
If you buy with your head, you might like living in the place a drop less, but when you resell, you will find many buyers who are attracted by the same good numbers that attracted you.
On the other hand, if you buy a "delighter" -- for me it's a fireplace -- you will love living there. On resale, however, to get your top price, or sometimes even to resell at all, you have to wait for the buyer to whom that's also a delighter. So your exit will take longer.
If you can for a moment envision what will make you sell again -- a growing family? retirement? a new job? -- that will help you envision how long you can take to exit, and that will help you make the head vs. heart call.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
thetraveler, prices have been very sticky in these areas. Not a lot have closed recently, but I've seen some movement. There were a lot of units sold to finance types, some of whom may be running low on severance soon. Hate to sound like a vulture, but the possibilities may get quite a bit better, but quite possibly not in the next three months. I'd take the hassle of moving twice in this market.
My parents told me the same thing about renting, but with a lot of hard work I've been able to overcome their lessons.
Don't bank on FiDi staying in the ps234 school district.
The new school in the Beekman tower is slated to open in 2010 and the kindergarten only incubator school in the Tweed couthouse building is opening this year for the sole purpose of ensuring that ps234 and p289 are not overcrowded this September. The zoning for the new Beekman tower school and the new one in BPC has not been decided yet but it would be logical to zone the South Street Seaport and FiDi areas for the new school.
Whatever is decided, anyone with kindergarten aged kids moving into the ps234 zone or ps89 zone from now on will likely be sending them to this new incubator school.
Some info here but do some more research based on some keywords in this article:
http://www.downtownexpress.com/de_290/cityfinds.html
Thanks for the info on school zones. I quickly read the report. Still, the areas covered seem to draw similar demographics PS234 does. The FiDi area has no projects, and that'll greatly help the "consistency" in the quality of schools, it seems.
Agreed. I said something similar here
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/talk/discussion/7314-building-at-50-franklin-street
Later reports in the Tribeca Trib or Downtown Express (can't remember which) quoted parents that live in FiDi who were optimistic about the new schools for similar reasons.
To Purchase In 2009: Buying with your head or your heart...
To Date In 2009: Thinking with your big head or your little head...
traveler - if u have enough money to buy with your heart and not worry about it, you will end up much happier than buying with your head.
Moving twice is a huge pain. We seriously considered buying in mid/late 2008 for that reason - has a lease expiring 12/31/08 and needed a bigger place. In the end, we decided to bite the bullet and rent, i.e. move twice. The economic difference for us was just too great. With your July deadline, you have the benefit of the extra 6 months for prices to drop and become more negotiable.
There might be a middle position - seriously look to buy for the next 3-4 months. Pull the trigger if you find an apartment you absolutely love, and/or an amazing deal. Otherwise, rent.
Agreed. In summary, in the next 6 months, if I find "the" place, buy. If not, then wait. I also met last night a 10 year Manhattan real estate broker and spent some time discussing the current market and she said three very interesting things:
1. If you you are a seller and don't have to sell right now then don't. But if you are ready to buy wait until April / May when new inventory will be on the market.
2. Look at the quarterly average prices in Manhattan over 10 years in the Q4 PDE report at http://www.prudentialelliman.com/NYCPhotos/retail_reports/mmo4q08.pdf
Her quote: "I am not a chart person, but no one ever lost money not buying at the north slope of Mt. Everest"
3. Mortgage rates falling and staying below 4.5% and tax changes are the only thing that will "ease the decline" or support any inventory reduction.
I disagree with your broker friend about timing. If you want to wait 1-2 years that's one thing, but if it's just a matter of a couple of months, traditionally spring is a high season when lots of shoppers come out and poor timing for buyers. I doubt that there will be much inventory on in April that's not on in February, but you will be facing other shoppers.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
"I doubt that there will be much inventory on in April that's not on in February, but you will be facing other shoppers."
Ali...tell that to the 4,000 folks who are in the process of losing their jobs at BAC/MER right now and the rest of the week. Not to mention the ones at BNP that lost their jobs on Monday and it didn't even make the news. Inventory will continue to rise every week, right through the "once" busy Spring season. This much hyped time of year is when the first shovel load of shit will hit the fan. Imagine, the price cuts that will occur when you don't get ANY bids on your apt halfway through Spring.
patient, I feel sorry for those people (I've been laid off before, and it stinks) but I have lived in New York for 20 years, and my sponsoring broker has been doing this for 25, and unless this suddenly turns into the 1930s we have seen this kind of recession in the city before. A quarter of Wall Streeters lost their jobs in previous cycles too.(And I was on the Street in '88, I remember that one).
Past performance no predictor of future performance blah blah blah, but generally -- even in the dark days of the late '80s -- there's been a spring upturn.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
yes, ali r., but you didn't mention that during the last major RE crash in the early 90s, coop studios on lower 5th Ave. could be had for $40K.
I bought my first apartment in '96 (Chelsea doorman alcove studio) for $65K, nine years after the stock market crash. However among other things, you sure you couldn't get 5% money.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Has the city seen this kind of aggressive appreciation before? Was the rent/buy ratio as out of whack in the late '80s as it is today?
I'm sure this has been posted and discussed here (and I missed it) but I stumbled across this (relatively) recent Urban Digs post and the numbers are staggering:
http://www.urbandigs.com/2009/01/manhattan_inventory_stagnates.html
It's not to say that I believe the playbook has to be completely thrown out this year because of the unique situation we are in. And I am in no way a broker or expert on this matter, but all things that are bought in frenzies up or down from stocks and bonds, to homes and cars (including the HDTV crazy people at Union Sq. Circuit City this past Saturday) must eventually counter react, if even moderately, to stabilize. In no way can it be "normal" to have such high compounded year over year growth for a decade with only an only increasing curve, without having some reversion to the mean. But then again, I am a buyer and in this case bias.
You really need to challenge your concept of paying rent is throwing money out the window. After doing really well on two prior properties -- i am a renter for the first time in 10 years. i also rent and aprtment that would cost more than twice as much to own. and prices willc ome down by a lot. So unless something absoltely grabs you and you are madly in love. try to be patient. Cash is lovely.
i always buy with my man clit, for those that know..know
manhattanfox, some people like to lease their cars because of its lower monthly cost. Others would never lease their vehicles because their lives aren't just about saving money and they just want to own their cars.
The same argument applies here. Some people don't like to rent, FULLY AWARE that it can be significantly cheaper to rent. I want to live in an apt I own, without ANY possibility of having to move out without wanting to. It's not cheap, but it is what I want.
Prom dresses are cheaper to rent... Wedding gowns are cheaper to rent... Vacation homes are cheaper to rent... Cheaper... Cheaper... Cheaper... That's not how some of us choose to live!!!
>some people like to lease their cars because of its lower monthly cost. Others would never lease their vehicles
I could lease a Lexus GS430 for less $/month than purchasing an ES350, but I'd never lease. It's probably a poor financial decision but leasing a vehicle just doesn't appeal to me. I feel the same way about renting an apartment. Heck, living in Manhattan, renting or owning, is a poor financial decision anyhow!
Goes back to the head vs. heart debate.
I choose to have a car in NYC, because I like the convenience, even though it doesn't make a ton of financial sense. But it's a decision that in the aggregate, over the life of the car, will only cost me maybe $10K vs. renting whenever I want one (got a good deal on the car, and good deal on garage).
By contrast, if I chose to buy an apartment in 2007-2008, rather than renting, that decision, over the time I'd live in that apartment, would likely cost me hundreds of thousands. Not something I was willing to do, even though I am all for the non-financial benefits of owning.
I feel a lot better about a $10K "heart" decision than about a $500K "heart" decision. Maybe if I had a ton of $$, I'd feel differently.