Era of big bonuses in NYC is over
Started by JohnAnthony
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 44
Member since: Dec 2008
Discussion about
With the financial crisis and increasing government regulation, the days of people making seven and eight figures is over. They will now be lucky to make $500K/year. As a result, real estate will further plummet, crime will go up, and the wealthy will leave NYC. It will no longer be seen as a city for affluent and upscale people. NYC will simply become a bigger version of Detroit or Baltimore.
Or even worse, Chicago.
The horror.
JohnAnthony
about 4 weeks ago
ignore this person
report abuse
Rufus is annoying, but Chicago waterfront is really impressive. And I think overall, their residential buildings are nicer than ours.
Even Rufus agrees that he himself is annoying.
NYC will never be anything but the greatest city in the world. There's still lots and lots of money.
julia, I disagree. There's still old money who live on fifth and park, but aside from that, the wealth is rapidly diminishing. Most of the wealth was based on finance, but those big bonuses are now a thing of the past.
JohnAnthony
about 3 weeks ago
ignore this person
report abuse
I am Rufus. I am also gtt. I am also quantum. I live in Chicago. I make up everything I say is fact about NYC. I am RUFUS.
Ouch.
if nyc goes under i'd guess that a city with better weather will take over. that rules out chicago.
Sizzlack -- you're totally wrong. Those usernames all originate from the same basement "apartment" in Hammond, Indiana.
"but those big bonuses are now a thing of the past. "
unless you worked at Merrill in 2008
Julia - didnt you say a week ago that NYC is dirty and nasty? I cant keep up with your swings!
I don't see any contradiction between "greatest city in the world" and "dirty and nasty". Are we looking towards Walt Disney World as the ideal?
urban, you mentioned that you've seen more buyers recently. any qualitative color as to what kind of buyers? are these wall street types that wound up getting bonuses and are now looking, etc?
Special K: I am a potential buyer, and I work in finance (although not for a big IB). True - bonuses are down for most of the Street, but those that are more affected tend to be the biggest earners. Many banks had tiered cuts based on your 07 comp where the biggest earners took the biggest cut. For people midway down the chain (neither running their own book, nor very junior), comp is less volatile. There are plenty of financially conservative types (like me!) who are looking at the rent or buy tradeoff under the new light of lower mortgage rates. I am also not expecting to earn some outsized return on my apartment -- taking a 5-8 yr holding period and looking to find a new home that is nicer than the renting stock.
johnanthony,
your definition of a great city is rather impoverished if you think it is solely measured by the extreme wealth of a small subset of its residents. detroit doesn't have central park, new york harbor, the statue of liberty, chinatown, the frick, the metropolitan opera, carnegie hall, the west village, etc. etc. etc. even when detroit was an affluent city it lacked these things, and it was never a truly great city.
on the other hand, istanbul is one of the great cities of the world but is desperately poor compared with any american city. bombay is a great city even though it is home to the largest slums in asia. so i'd broaden your understanding of a great city beyond the size of the bonus pool at goldman sachs.
johnanthony, I partially agree with you RE will continue to plummet, crime will continue to increase all of the wealthy won't leave NYC but a portion of the wealthy will leave NYC. Now the hipsters, transplants and those from the midwest who thought they would flip their 400k plus properties and return to the midwest millionaires are going to be leaving in herds especially when welfare returns to NYC unemployment only last but so long and if it goes beyond that then its welfare aka welly.
I would not assume a spike in crime, as happened in the 1970s. The 1930s were also a tough time, and aside from organized crime syndicate activity, and apple-pilfering from carts, New York didn't become a den of crime.
The 1970s crime wave was the result of myriad factors, few of which are relevant to now and the next few years.
Chitroit, on the other hand, will burn to the ground.
You're wrong alanhart. Crime will go up drastically. It already went up last year, and things will get worse as the city is forced to cut the police budget.
The crime spike in NYC actually began in the early 60's and escalated throughout the 70's and 80's. The same patterns back then are now happening again.
Less jobs less money equals spiked crime humans have to survive.
If crime is not reported because of media control thats a difference story.
I'm expecting to see spiked crime and will be more vigilant* at all times.
If crime does not spike I thank our god because he is merciful.
JohnAnthony, those are pretty casual observations to throw out, with no real substance behind them. I don't really see signs of the swift and dramatic changes you're seeing. Are people less wealthy? Sure, many are, but that doesn't mean they're herding out of here en masse. Where do you think people will go? There aren't any clear destinations that offer better options in terms of financial stability and quality of life.
mutombonyc, similarly, where are you seeing this large contingent of supposed midwestern/hipster flippers? That's a strange assertion to be making. Also, not sure what you mean about welfare "returning" here. These programs have always been strong in this city and will continue to be so.
No, the patterns of that time -- the bleeding of eastern and northern cities to subsidize the burbs and the sunbelt . . . and the spiraling effect thereof, including the ability to keep state taxes low (Texas, etc.) because the Federal govt. is stoking the economy with cash imported from older cities; heroin-addicted returning veterans; an us vs. them sense of racial disparity and lack of opportunity; on and on -- don't exist today. It's not just about jobs, or we'd associate the 1930s with high urban crime, which we don't.
Sorry, Cracker Boy, but you're as stupid as ever.
alanhart, suburban flight has begun. There was a NY Times article recently which talked about new yorkers beginning to question whether it's worth it to live in the city. Without finance, the city has nothing to fall back on.
Cracker Boy, there's always been a dialogue about whether it's just easier to throw in the towel and move to the burbs, and many families have done just that. Many who have move right back after a year or two. But the demand to stay here and move here overshadows that trend, and will continue to do so.
In the 60s and 70s, New York had far less flight (a negative, running away from something) than other cities, and to the extent that a shift to the suburbs occurred, it was for positive reasons: moving to "the country". As a result, the suburbs of NY have relatively little tract housing. In addition, those burbs offered the [illusory] combination of low taxes and high services -- no longer the case.
urbandigs...i'm surprised at your comment...i respect and look forward to your postings. The city is tired and worn (I didn't say nasty) but I also said in the same posting that Manhattan is one of the most exciting, vibrant cities in the World.
bjw2103, you wanted to be a flipper but you are stuck with that depreciating asset you mortgaged LOL, I know mentalities and spoke to more then enough people who had flipping in mind when mortgaging overpriced properties. Welfare has declined tremendously from the early 1990's in NYC, of course you were not in NYC for the days of welfare in the early 1990's as you don't know the history of NYC but you know the history of your hometown and state. While large amounts of people will be laid off and not returning to work how long will they collect unemployment compensation for? If the unemployed don't find a job in the time allowed what is next for them? Welfare, how else do they survive. Unemployment compensation a form of welfare for those who worked and separated from their jobs for various reasons. What about those underemployed how do they make up the difference, theres a lot of underemployment in NYC. No one is immune from job loss.
Yeah UD, how dare you post about Julia's many contradictions. I'm sure she will never read you site again.
what you geniuses who are predicting a return of high crime rate to NYC are forgeting is that we are in the age of terrorism paranoia. There are massive amount of funds that come into NY from the Fed that will not get cut and will probably be increased. These funds go to things like security cameras, sensing equipment, MP or police presence. So today is no where near like the 70's. Crime wont return as we live in a lock down where everything is watched.
Minor crime - the type ignored by the Feds - like pick pockets etc. But everything else will not be so easy even with the city reducing the police budgets.
mutombonyc, when did I say I wanted to be a flipper? I bought a home, not a pure investment. And my family's been in NYC much longer than you've been in the NBA, so your comments are off-base and ill-informed. You're right that no one is totally immune from job losses, but you're suggesting things like the media purposely underreporting crime, which is strange and (to-date) unfounded.
bjw2103, Did you property lose, gain or maintain value? Has your family been in NYC as long as you been in that apreciating property your "mortgage". You are saying the media reports everything and reports the truth at all times? I will tell you the truth is not always reported why did it take a year for the media to report we are in a recession? Why is the media report bogus unemployment numbers? And your former president bush black listed and censored so many people and media outlets its not even funny but our rights are only guaranteed but so much so it not strange (to-date) and unfounded. As I told you in Brooklyn we have all of this Luxury RE and higher crime is will disturb economics more then you care to admit.
quantum
about 1 hour ago
ignore this person
report abuse
You're wrong alanhart. Crime will go up drastically. It already went up last year, and things will get worse as the city is forced to cut the police budget.
Even if you are correct RoofieDoofie, the SAME thing would happen to Chicago too. So it's a lose lose.
A cab ride is more expensive then a train ride Mayor Gloombird is always promoting the most expensive lifestyles. He should pay for all cab rides with his billions of dollars until his billions of dollars are exhausted.
mutombonyc, stop obsessing about my place - it would really do you some good (and I've answered your question in prior threads, just not with an answer to your liking, it seems). Your paranoia about the media is amusing - no, they are not 100% infallible, but if you're going to make claims that they're purposely disseminating false information, then you need to justify that with some kind of evidence. Spouting off generalities won't get this discussion anywhere.
mutombo lay off of BJW. He knows what he is doing in RE. He is a graduate of the Real Estate for Hipsters 101. That is how he realized that a Williamsburg condo at the peak of the market was a good investment.
Sizzlack you moron. Crime went down dramatically last year.
Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Police Commissioner Ray Kelly, at a news conference last week, touted the continued drop in the crime rate - 3.71 percent through Dec. 28. It's the 18th straight year the crime rate has declined and the seventh consecutive year with fewer than 600 slayings, they said.
Petr...where the FU*K did I suggest crime went up last year? You are so batsh*t crazy its kind of mindblowing. The point I was making was that even if what Rufus says is true (if you paid the slightest bit of attention you'd know I think Rufus is a moron) then the same will happen in his beloved Chicago. That's all. Douchebag.
I thought Bloomberg rides the subway to work everyday.
bjw2103, I always have a good time at your place your martini's are the best LOL. You have answered my question in prior thread you are right and I won't bring it up anymore. The media is bigger then you and I combined so thats dead in the water as well. I got you bjw2103, we agree to disagree. How's your day today?
petrfitz you are funny.
bjw - I have a general rule about people that I wanted to share with you. I ignore anyone who constantky refers to another person with some snarky version of their name. Examples would be Gloombird for Bloomberg, Crashman for Cashman or Usama or Obama. People who do this are never worht the effort to have a discussion with becasue they are speaking from such a warped vantage point they will never recognize common sense or aknowledge facts.
That said, bjw and alanhart petrfitz, I agree with your assessments of why today is different than the 70's. Also, petrfitz, that is something I never thought about as well. Thanks for throwing that out there. Seems to make a lot of sense.
***should say "Usama for Obama"...sorry for the typo.
What about Codosleeza Brown Rice and Peas?
waverly, you're right of course. Can't help myself sometimes, it's kind of like rubbernecking while driving by a car crash. And yes, to get back to the real topic at hand, it's too facile (and wrong) to just say, "Oh, this will turn out exactly like the 70s!" Recessions mean leaner budgets, but this city is as safe as I can ever recall, and that's quite an accomplishment - I just don't see it reversed so quickly and so completely as some think.
I think we are starting off from a much safer, cleaner city today than the overall "health and livability" of NYC in the 70's. I think there will be some decline in areas, but overall, I think NYC will weather the storm (not talking RE prices) and come out of the recession better than most other big cities.
don't worry they are paying bonuses in commodes... very liquid at the moment... I'll buy your UWS 4bdrm with 500K commodes... beats 1MM jokes by Stevehjx :)
who's the guy with the boner... everyone look down... except Julia :)
"I think we are starting off from a much safer, cleaner city today than the overall "health and livability" of NYC in the 70's. I think there will be some decline in areas, but overall, I think NYC will weather the storm (not talking RE prices) and come out of the recession better than most other big cities. "
I think we'll eventually come out of this, but there are some MAJOR problems we have that other cities don't that will be painful for a while.
Bankers will make less, fine. That in itself is not horrible. People might pay more attention to artists and folks that actually make things or building companies. That in itself is not a bad thing. Prices will come down to match incomes, great.
The problem is, GOVERNMENT SPENDING WILL NOT MATCH THE DECLINE.
The city, and more importantly, state governments are absolute messes. They have overspent and overspent, and wasted money, and have left us with HUGE liabilities like unfunded pensions and benefits, BIG union contracts, and systems that are just wasteful. Not to mention lousy social programs (not saying social programs are lousy, just a lot of the ones we run). Our government SUCKS, plain and simple. Bloomberg is ok, but the city council is a bunch of morons in donor pockets. And don't get me started on the state legislature. They are criminals. Silver? (oh yeah, and look at bruno). Scum.
Real Estate can take $$$ being less, prices will simply sdjust.
But there is no way we can stomach the revenue losses at the government level. They refuse to cut anything beyond some vanity dollars. This is bred into the system, it is a long-broken system. The state legislature has LITERALLY PASSED LAW that says we can not lower benefits. Not saying this is not changeable in an absolute sense, but in a reality sense, it is likely not... not for a long while without a lot of effort.
We only got away with it because the city made SO MUCH MONEY. But that is over. We're spending peak dollars, and peak dollars are gone.
That problem is going to be with us for a while.
> I just don't see it reversed so quickly
Who said quickly? This is going to take years to play out. We have 2009 bonuses down 44%.... but we're pacing to have even worse this upcoming year.
The state/city budget issues are going to go on for years.
1987 crash took 4 years for the city to bottom.... don't know if anyone is saying this will be instant.
nyc10022, I fully expect that my bonus next year will be much better. Since the beginning of the year, the pace has picked up quite considerably and we are making good money for the firm right now. I think this year's bonus will be the worst, next year better (although nowhere close to previous years).
so, i work in finance - banks are def cutting back left and right. its ugly out there. however, the FEAR MONGERING needs to stop. the economy is completely overshooting at the moment, and this is due to fear. has anyone ever heard of behavioral economics? herd effects, etc, play a role in the economy and this is difficult, if not impossible, to quantify. i am by no means saying that prices do not need to adjust - all i am saying is that this talk of NYC becoming detroit etc needs to end, seriously. WHERE ELSE WILL PEOPLE GO!?? this is not an isolated problem - the entire world is going through this. finance will be around but no one knows what on earth it will look like in the coming years. and if people on here are so eager to see the collapse of real estate prices and claimn to have seen this happen bc of how expensive they are, then why on earth havent you all shorted the market? put your money where your mouths are.
nyc10022, you are absolutely right, unfortunately.
nyc10028, why don't you tell those 71,000 people who got canned on Monday to stop the FEAR MONGERING.
i am talking about fear mongering that the media and everyone else causes. its not helping. those people are not fear mongering. they are FEARING because they lost their job. its an appropriate reaction. fear mongering is what media, and most bloggers are doing. this causes further reduction and overshooting in the martketplace.
let me put it this way. fear mongering causes NO ONE, INCLUDING YOURSELF, benefit. so we have 2 options, prolonging this slide (continuing the doomsday scenerios that humans love), or stabilize markets by ensuring confidence. asset prices are as good as we THINK they are. wake up and smell how the world works.
Oh Great- Let's not talk about it and it will go away. Perhaps if he stops talking it won't happen right... a head in the sand approach will not help either.. this will take time to work itself out.. perhaps many years.. the problem is if unemployment is high and revenue is low while assuming huge federal debt at the same time.. 3 trillion is a number many others are using as a guide to bank losses.. the money has to come from somewhere.. ie taxpayers.. there is no solution other than working through it.. there will be no sudden spike in economic growth... borrowing to fuel growth has a high risk attached to it as well.. get your heads out of the sand and prepare for hard times..
ok - thats fine, but what has this country been doing for YEARS? can we ever pay our debt??? for example, what if EVERYONE margin calls the treasuries? we are all screwed. so take your pick my friend. either be the good guy and demand we get our house in order or close your eyes and pretend this will go away. the US needs to keep playing a ponzi scheme. madoff aint nothin. our lives are too short for this. i don't know about you, but i dont want to be unemployed and help to pay the US govt debt the rest of my life.
nyc10028: Wait a second...take a step back...are you suggesting that if everybody covers their eyes and says, "no place like home" it will just BE? If the same doesn't work for one's credit card debt, why would it for our country's debt? I agree that the media has been fear mongering (example: when bank of america sold it's stake in bank of china and made a hell of a profit, the media made it sound like a disaster that BAC was selling...but it really wasn't)
That being said, there are clearly issues (big ones) in America...this "american dream" idea turned into a nightmare, without any regulations or people watching...I just had dinner with a friend who lives in LA and about two years ago was thinking about buying a home...the broker told her, "What do you want to pay each month?" and when she asked for more details, she found out each year she would owe more and more (just like what happened with most americans that created this...)
that's real, and the fact that people took advantage is real, that people didn't ask how is this possible was/is real, and covering our eyes won't work. It's not a matter of "woe is us" but things are definitely going to change, for the first time in a while...they have to.
Change is good, but scares people...get ready for it...here it comes
"nyc10022, I fully expect that my bonus next year will be much better. Since the beginning of the year, the pace has picked up quite considerably and we are making good money for the firm right now. I think this year's bonus will be the worst, next year better (although nowhere close to previous years)."
Then you are the exception. M&A is down across the street (30-40% last I heard), trading profits obviouslly down immensely, prime brokerage dead, etc, etc.
Take a look at the bank numbers, revenues have fallen off a cliff.
And its REVENUES (not profit) that bonuses are based on...
You know, wasn't there some guy from Lehman on here right before it failed saying "no, we're making tons of money in my group"?
"Who said quickly?"
There are a few people around here who have proclaimed this. For the record, I was talking about crime and safety eroding to 70s levels - I don't see that.
Guys, there are a lots of people still making enough money, and with enough saving who can afford to buy in manhattan. e.g bonuses in my firm were anywhere from up 5% to down 25%, with average being around down 10%, and yes we are a financial firm.
What is holding people back is the lack of visibility on that income stream in the future, and the fact that the prices are coming down and no-one wants to catch a falling knife.
> > "Who said quickly?"
> There are a few people around here who have proclaimed this.
I don't see any on this thread. Am I missing them?
If we're going to have rational debate, lets keep it to what WAS actually said and not set up strawman arguments.
> For the record, I was talking about crime and safety eroding to 70s levels - I don't see that.
The only person who seems to have said that is you...
"And yes, to get back to the real topic at hand, it's too facile (and wrong) to just say, "Oh, this will turn out exactly like the 70s!""
Unless I'm missing something, thats a classic strawman argument.
Why don't we actually skip to arguing about what folks are ACTUALLY saying. So far, it seems like the debate is whether or not we stay about the same, or decline, though not to the level of the 70s.
I'm fairly certainly we'll see some decline. I think we'll look like the late 90s for a while.
"Guys, there are a lots of people still making enough money, and with enough saving who can afford to buy in manhattan. e.g bonuses in my firm were anywhere from up 5% to down 25%, with average being around down 10%, and yes we are a financial firm. "
Why bring out any anecdotes, when we have the ACTUAL NUMBERS?
Bonuses are down 44%. Folks saying "yeah, but mine went up" are sort of irrelevant at this point, don't you think? We're talking about how the market will be affected, and the bonus pool has been pretty well established at this point.
on these boards there is a lot of talk about ratios of rent to cost of ownership and that the ratios must come down for owning to become a good investment.
But there is no talk about the amount wall street bankers earn versus the transactions they complete. I think that in order for our country's economy to truly prosper banks need to start acting more like credit card processors than the parasites they are today.
Yeah you put together a company with funding and your bank should get less than 1% of that transaction - no more. no shares, no equity, etc.
If we are truly going to have an economy based on actual value and earnings then the bankers need to take less - much less until then it wont work.
"If we're going to have rational debate, lets keep it to what WAS actually said and not set up strawman arguments."
Read the thread please - I was talking about crime. So was waverly and a few other people on here. I was responding to these kinds of arguments by mutombonyc:
"crime will continue to increase all of the wealthy won't leave NYC but a portion of the wealthy will leave NYC"
"Unless I'm missing something, thats a classic strawman argument."
You are - I'm not attributing anything false to what some are saying. There are people who seriously believe we are returning to the 70s. People are ACTUALLY saying this. No need for your attack-dog like responses.
Back to the OP, this number isn't quite as bad as I would have thought. I mean sure, bonuses are down in aggregate 44% which is bad for the city, etc. But to someone still employed, it was only down 36% (ostensibly because of layoffs). The bonuses were still the 6th highest on record for what I believe to be one of the worst years ever for Wall Street probably since the Great Depression.
It's certainly much less purchasing power and certainly many homes will come on the market of those who have been laid off, but the 6th highest bonus ever still sounds like a reasonable amount of purchasing power. Am I missing something here?
bjw2103, my initial comments was based on the thread topic.
> Read the thread please
Really? Is this necessary? This is a bit childish.
> I was talking about crime. So was waverly and a few other people on here.
So was I.
"There are people who seriously believe we are returning to the 70s. People are ACTUALLY saying this."
Perhaps you want to respond to the folks actually doing that then. I don't see any of them here.
"No need for your attack-dog like responses."
Bjw, calm yourself... you are not under attack. Just pointing out that you are arguing with folks that aren't here...
That isn't helpful discussion.
"The bonuses were still the 6th highest on record for what I believe to be one of the worst years ever for Wall Street probably since the Great Depression. "
Don't confuse profits with revenues/bonuses. Bonuses come off revenues, not profits. Revenues were high beginning of 2008, and then fell off. The losses, which WERE records, had little to do with the bonuses.
Revenues are now under major distress, and that will continue for some time.
Banker bonuses MUST fall and can never go back to where they were.
You must all understand this. Banker compensation was and still is seriously aggregious. It was parasitic. Compensation must be decreased significantly and never go back to where it was or the economy will never flourish.
Does it make sense that a junior banker barely involved in a deal make as much off a transation than a senior partner in the company being purchased??? No.
nyc10022, read the OP - he said NYC will turn into Detroit or Baltimore. It's in this thread!
Considering the sh*tstorm this bonus has stirred across the world, I think it's safe to say that this is going to be the last time bonuses at this level are paid on Wall Street- for a long, long time, if not ever. This is the veritable last waltz on the Titanic. Any politician that has even a remote interest in getting (re)elected will put Wall Street oversight/reform/regulation/enforcement at the top of their list of things to do.
nyc10022, i think your logic is flawed.
You cant just look at the average bonus being down 44%. You need to look at the distribution. If there are 200,000 people with average 44% down, but even if there are 10,000 with flat or up bonuses, then they can still afford to buy, makes sense?
people are still making money. fear is driving this economy into the craphole. what makes us think the billions of fake wealth created by wall street isnt the same type of fake wealth created by the us (borrowing)? and what, so all of a sudden "wall street is exposed and caused all this?" can we all accept that lehman bro collapsing triggered this mess??? the counterparty risk that everyone had with lehman, coupled with the fear it caused, the liquidity crisis, etc..? c'mon lets just admit how the world turns. yes, HUGE RIDICULOUS bonuses need to stop. HOWEVER. the bonus structure in banking is simple: small base + bonus depending on deal flow. im not sure how many of you are in banking or understand, but this total comp may equal the salary of doctors and lawyers. therefore many are not as outrageous as they seem.
10028: good point..reality is at the (formerly) bulge bracket firms, maybe <10% of workers made more than a financially successful NYC doctor or lawyer. Yes, those 10% may have made 3 to 20 times what the docs and fleas made.
the compensation for bankers should not equal the compensation for doctors and lawyers. Wall Street "bankers" are basically sales guys who push paper. Their compensation should be equal to a CPA, or vaccum cleaner sales guy.
The days of making money on Wall Street are over and should remain so. Bankers bring no value they just put the two parties of value - owner and funder together. Like eBay does. Bankers should be compensated like a credi card processor - pennies per transaction.
"The sense of entitlement that's been engendered in this group of people has clearly not been beaten out of them by the brutal performance of the financial sector over the course of the last year," says Bob O'Brien, stocks editor at Barrons.com.
Of course, what's most sickening to the vast majority of Americans is these bonuses were paid (mostly) by the same firms who've received TARP funds. The rationale that "bonuses must be paid or we'll lose our best people" doesn't hold water when everybody on Wall Street is suffering and cutting back. Similarly, the idea "there are separate pools of capital for bonuses vs. lending" doesn't hold water when Wall Street CEOs say "money is fungible" as a way of explaining why they can't track TARP funds.
cant wait for Andrew Cuomo to go after all these banks and hold them criminally liable for passing out these bonuses.
If I got a Wall Street bonus from any TARP bank this year I definitely wouldnt spend it - you are going to have to give it back!
petrfitz, exactly. And you can just substitute the word "realtor" and it would be the same thing.
i actually agree w/ petrfitz here. whoa, did i just say that? wall street shouldn't be comped where they were or probably even where they are today. but the fact remains that bonuses were only down 36%. so like iamlooking said, some guys are actually faring ok in this. i have no doubt that directionally this is a negative for real estate, what i am trying to understand is how negative it will really be. A guy made $500k last year in bonus, now, assuming he has his job, he made 36% less or about $320k. That is hardly a lot of pain and he will certainly not be out on the street. For the guys who were laid off, sure they are much worse off. But again, if you were on the street for even a few years from 05-07, you saved up a reasonable amount of money. Again, you will not be on the street and will unlikely be firesaling your home because you probably have 12+ months of savings, etc.
guys - finance people are the smartest people on the street and this is reflected in salaries. finance people should be paid. i am not talking about brokers. i am talking about deal structurers, analysts, etc. there is a reason why you have to go through rigorous banking itnerviews where they giv you tests etc and if you aren't good enough and smart enough you are out. problem is GREED. people need to be monitored and regulated. when you mix smart people in with the CULTURE of wall street greed happens, and this happens. you dont understand finance if you are saying pay should be equivalent to vacuum salespeople. stockbrokers are not bankers. further, the purpose of finace is to allocate capital efficiently. if it wasnt for banks, microfinance, IMF etc would not exists. heck, you would not be able to get any loans, deals wouldnt be done, mergers wouldnt happen, etc...mergers and such create VALUE and bankers help do this. these people assist in creation of wealth and growth in our economy. enough bashing wall street.
"smartest people on the street" is like saying "king of the soulless dipshits"
"finance people are the smartest people on the street and this is reflected in salaries"
there is nothing i like better than when a smug trader tells me at some loft party that he does index arbitrage at a flow/prop desk and smiles at me like i should bow down to his general greatness. and then i say, "so you basically buy and sell the index and do the reverse on a pre-determined basket of stocks like a monkey? sort of press a button over and over again?" that pecking wooden chicken who took over for homer simpson when he had to leave the nuclear reactor could do his job...
"nyc10022, i think your logic is flawed.
You cant just look at the average bonus being down 44%. You need to look at the distribution. If there are 200,000 people with average 44% down, but even if there are 10,000 with flat or up bonuses, then they can still afford to buy, makes sense? "
Good thing the other 190,000 don't need to live somewhere.
you hate hearing it but its true. people flock to where the $$ is. enough said.
10022 i think we are the only 2 people who think this way lol
BTW, NYTimes just did a big piece on how Wall Street bonus cuts aren't just for this year, they'll get worse and basically be permanent...
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/talk/discussion/8096-ny-times-wall-street-pay-differential-to-disappear
> 10022 i think we are the only 2 people who think this way lol
Well, whether they admit it or not, the masses who aren't buying apartments anymore know it too, even if its just from looking at their own paychecks.
;-)