New Republican Proposal - 4% 30-year fixed rates to anyone
Started by luis5acc
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 81
Member since: Oct 2007
Discussion about
What do you think about the Republican's new plan of offering 4% 30-year fixed rates to anyone who is credit worthy? I think this could stabilize the real estate market if commercial property can get these loans too.
They might as well declare the US Government bankrupt right now. But then that's their goal.
All they need to do is find some credit-worthy people who are looking to sink some money in a house. Right. In areas of mass foreclosures, maybe. Elsewhere, not so much. Anyway, that's not much different from what's available right now in the conforming world.
it continues to keep the bubble going. say rates go to 6% in 2 years. prices will go lower then. delays the inevitable. traditionally its been better to buy when rates are higher. its all about afordibility.
What is the inevitable? Prices need to stabilize, right?
No, not until the asset price is in line with incomes and the rent/buy calculations make sense.
I think the 4% is only for first time buyers....not for refi or people that own now , are selling, and want to buy again...also...in nyc most everything is jumbo...so 4% is just for the suburbs or people buying a starter apt. It needs to be 4..then 5% for jumbo...
Correct me if I am wrong, but didn't artificially low interest rates help fuel the bubble in prices? Honestly, isn't that how we got in this mess in the first place?? Option arms, interest first (aka principal never), teaser arms, 2/28s, 3/27s etc, etc. And a 1% Funds rate for far too long. And while I am at it, what exactly is so wrong with requiring a 20% down payment to purchase a primary residence??
Home price equilibrium is a function of the price, incomes and mortgage rates. Prices rose too fast and are still too high. Incomes, well, many are losing their jobs and have no income and many people with jobs are seeing their incomes shrink. Mortgage rates are already the lowest they have ever been. I would argue mortgage rates are the least important variable in arriving at an equilibrium.
Prices need to keep coming down. Policy makers need to find ways to help people keep their jobs and then let people keep more of their income. Unfortunatley, New York City has taken some strong steps in the wrong direction. State, local, sales, property taxes are all going up reducing take home pay and making home ownership more expensive.
I think there can be a balance...prices are coming down that's good. Also, people could use the help for lower rates for re-fi's..it is different from before with sub-prime...those people had 100% financing..what were they thinking!!!! If you can't put at least 10%...even better 20% down you should NOT BE ALLOWED TO BUY A HOME. People that can't afford to buy should not buy....period....people should live within their means.......everyone wants stainless steel and radiant heat flooring...but sometimes it's smart.
> They might as well declare the US Government bankrupt right now. But then that's their goal.
Well, if they can charge 4% interest and sell bonds at 0%, they'll actually make some margin. As long as they keep doing this, they can let the ponzi go on for a while, at least until the economy recovers.
Let's say you are right and the prices need to come down, then what happens to NYC real estate prices and rents? Won't the deflationary hits cause our city and state government revenues drop and then taxes would rise again leading to more deflation. The spiral of collapsing prices could really hurt, right?
luis, yes. payback's a bitch. although whether or not taxes rise also depends on services and population issues, not necessarily a linear relationship.
I should have said "how much taxes rise" not whether or not. Duh.
Why is this payback? Our investments like retirement funds are in the values of commercial real estate, right? When I say our investments I mean the whole country. If we don't stabilize then the whole system implodes. How can the government pay Social Security or Medicare if it is broke. How can the city and state pay pensions if there are no revenues?
It's payback for the profligate creation of a bubble that enriched so few at the expense of so many. Those issues you raise? Perhaps somebody should have thought of them earlier, because the asset is only worth what someone can and will pay for it, and without excessive credit and/or artificial stabilization, very few will and fewer can.
We're not saying it's pretty, and yes, it could and will really hurt. As many of the increased population in homeless shelters could no doubt already tell you.
THe bubble enriched LOTS of people. Sounds like you are jealous that you were not one of them.
The government already has spent trillions trying to stabilize banks, right? This idea could really stabilize real estate and help regular people instead for far less. The idea of 4% 30 years allows the state and city governments steady taxes and values instead of what is currently happening.
"The government already has spent trillions trying to stabilize banks, right?"
I don't know, you tell me:
Wall Street Bailout Exceeds Cost of All US Wars, the Louisiana Purchase, the New Deal, the Marshall Plan and the NASA Space Program Combined
http://www.rockcreekfreepress.com/
luis, mortgage rates are NOT the problem, except for certain mortgages that were issues with punitive rate increases, but mosst of those were issued to people who shouldn't have qualified in the first place and wouldn't qualify now.
Mortgage rates are already extremely low, a small further reduction won't make any significant difference.
alpine, so, do you think the enrichment was worth it?
If a business is paying 8% for commercial property and can refinance to 4%, then that is a real savings! $7337/month versus $4774/month = $2563/month. If the government guarantees the loans, then families paying 6.5% which are the majority of homes in America, then they will see a savings immediately. 4% percent 30 year loans are not available. Just last week rates were moving up again to 5.5% and only for those with pristine credit for conforming loans. Commercial ventures would be the main beneficiary of this policy as well as jumbo rates holders who are paying 8% if they are lucky. Remember, it is small businesses that employ more then 70% of the people.
"Wall Street Bailout Exceeds Cost of All US Wars, the Louisiana Purchase, the New Deal, the Marshall Plan and the NASA Space Program Combined "
Only if you believe their $8.5 trillion number.... which is way higher than all of the packages are actually for...
6.5% for 200000 = $1264 versus 4% for 200000 = $954. These are significant savings.
Nyc10022 - Exactly, the big banks and investment firms have received more than 8.5 trillion but the average business and family continues to pay with more and more uncertainty. Local and state govt. will be going bankrupted within the next two years as property taxes have always been the lifeblood of their revenues.
The real ponzi scheme is Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid.
They currently cost about 8.5% of GDP.
In 10 years this figure will be at 12.5% of GDP and in a steady uptrend as the retiring Boomers need more and more services.
Corporations must fund their pension obligations today and invest in stocks, bonds, etc. The government has virtually nothing salted away. What little it does have are just invested in a bunch of government IOUs.
Pay-as-you-go?
Hold your hats. Taxes are going up. Way up!
After we right the economy with the current stimulus packages, seems to me austerity will be the order of the day.
Social security and Medicare and Medicaid are real big problems. I would suggest raising retirement age to 69 for all three. Also, the real problem was failing population. However, 4% 30 year mortgages may help.
falling
> Exactly, the big banks and investment firms have received more than 8.5 trillion
No, not exactly.
Deflation.... when people hold off buying things bc they believe prices will fall..... mmmmmm mmmm mmmmmm I wonder where this is occurring? mmmmm.... mmmmmm let me think.... me thinkz some more..... where are buyers holding off bc they believe prices will fall? mmmmmmm mmmmmmm
Oh... yeah but I can get 4% financing... LMAO..... zero ain't making me buy a Ferrari.... and zero ain't making me buy the 60 ft swan.... zero is desperation... .4% is for suckers and desperate talking heads... smart people see thru BS all the time... but who said America was that smart :)
FYI.... u see Geitner... he's getting red from all the blowing he's doing... as far as I can tell... that mouth is too small and the balloon too big .... sorry next....