Explain why Chelsea Grande still so OVERPRICED
Started by jimstreeteasy
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1967
Member since: Oct 2008
Discussion about
This is a sincere post. I lived in NYC last 8 years ago, and would like to move back and buy a place, but I am waiting for prices to reach sane levels. For all I read on here about discounts my sanity check, to see if the market is truly repricing to something reasonable, is the building I lived in 8 years ago. I lived in a above 10th floor middle-unit facing south in the E range (basically, it's... [more]
This is a sincere post. I lived in NYC last 8 years ago, and would like to move back and buy a place, but I am waiting for prices to reach sane levels. For all I read on here about discounts my sanity check, to see if the market is truly repricing to something reasonable, is the building I lived in 8 years ago. I lived in a above 10th floor middle-unit facing south in the E range (basically, it's like two small hotel room boxes), one-bedroom, 640sfeet. In 2000 I paid $2900 rent, and it was priced for 380,000$ but ,unfortunately, I opted to rent. Today apparently that sort of unit would rent for about 3200$, and sell for about $750,000. SO FAR I SEE NO EVIDENCE OF MEANINGFUL REDUCTIONS IN PRICES IN THIS BUILDING, SO MY QUESTION IS: WHAT IS GOING ON;IF THE MARKET IS REALLY CRASHING SHOULDN'T THESE UNITS BE DOWN FROM THE PEAK SIGNIFICANTLY?. It is interesting to see such a small change in rent, such a big change in price. Finally, Chelsea may be popular but this buiding is hardly ultra-luxury, really quite plain,but I'm no expert on what "luxury" means. To me it is very run-of-the-mill. An example unit: http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/365851-condo-270-west-17-street-10011-chelsea-new-york [less]
Help me out people -- this apartment building is no great shakes, why is it impervious to a crashing market?
If we experience what other weak housing markets have, then the "sellers" who don't adjust their price expectations don't sell.
If you are seriously interested I would contact the brokers for the listed apartments. Overpriced inventory is not trading and brokers are going to be the ones to nudge their clients away from the expectation that they are going to get peak asking prices, but they my guess is they will only do this by bringing them a willing and able buyer at a specific (lower) price point. Bid low and see what happens...
your example really brings the point home about how out of wack the buy vs rent math has gotten over the past 8 years, too. If I'm correct in understanding:
2000 rent: $2,900, buy: $380,000
current rent: $3,200, buy: $750,000
anybody want to unleash their analytics on this example?
mrsbuffet your numbers are correct...it's amazing isn't it.
Of course I realize that ALL BUYERS list higher than they want, but if they are decreasing at all right now that's a bad sign as to how far they would go down presumably.In other words, it would be better if they were showing already a 15% decline,so a buyer could go in and ask for a further 15%; they wouldn't likely drop 30% from a no-decline posture.
this thread finally presents a crystal-clear example of what sjhx has been trying to show in other threads - was that $380K price for "insiders"?
When I rented the apartment in 2000 the landlord said "you can rent for 2900$ or if you want to buy I will sell for 380k". That was it. Simple as that and I don't know what you mean by "insiders price". The building was at least 10 years old at that time I think.
I guess I need to rephrase this posting since so few commented. IF THE MARKET IS DROPPING LIKE CRAZY THEN WHY ARE PEOPLE IN THIS BUILDING AT 270 W 17TH NOW SHOWING ANY SIGNIFICANT DROPS???/
I meant to say NOT SHOWING SIGNIFICANT DROPS......
Thanks for the clarification - person who offered it to you for sale or rent was owner of only an individual unit? Sellers do not usually, as a herd, drastically chop their asking prices when the world changes. Lots of people are waiting and seeing........
Yes ..in 2000 the building had long since been sold out by the developer. An ordinary individual who owned only one unit on earth or in this building offered to sell or rent at the time he was moving from nyc.
Nothing is impervious. Maybe the owners here do not need to move or have a lot of cash.