Interesting UWS sales statistics
Started by OnTheMove
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 227
Member since: Oct 2007
Discussion about
Once in a while I look at recent closings on the UWS and for the first time I came up almost empty: 0 closings in the last week, 2 closings in the last 2 weeks. To get an idea of how this compares to previous time periods, I surveyed the number of closings in the Streeteasy database over different time windows and calculated the average weekly number of closings over the same periods. Here is the... [more]
Once in a while I look at recent closings on the UWS and for the first time I came up almost empty: 0 closings in the last week, 2 closings in the last 2 weeks. To get an idea of how this compares to previous time periods, I surveyed the number of closings in the Streeteasy database over different time windows and calculated the average weekly number of closings over the same periods. Here is the (shocking) downward spiral (all numbers approximate): Past year (2/1/2008-1/31/2009): 1226 (~24/week) Past 6 months (8/1/2008-1/31/2009): 439 (~17/week) Preceding 6 months (2/1/2008-7/31/2008): 787 (~30/week) Last 60 days (12/1/2008-1/31/2009): 57 (~7.6/week) Preceding 4 months (8/1/2008-12/1/2008): 382 (~22/week) Last 14 days (1/17/2009-1/31/2009: 2 (~1/week): Preceding 46 days (12/1/2008-1/17/2009): 43 (~7/week) Last 7 days - 0 (0/week) When was the last time the UWS saw no closings in any given week? If I were making a bid, I would make a really lowball offer, accompanied by these statistics. [less]
Not just UWS. When I search recorded sales in "all downtown" below $700k it's totally dropped off.
so..volume is down...BUT prices in buildngs I look at simply do not reflect massive drops...see my post re Chelsea Grande where prices are basically still at absurd, record price...this was posted today
Using sales volume data to justify a lowball offer i not going to get you anywhere. Very few people care about volume. Instead, you should find COMPS to justify your offer. And besides, this is the slow time of year.
I also think it has something to do with the pace at which banks can finalize and close mortgage loans. The banks have been overwhelmed and unable to support all of the refi's and new loans and they are almost at a standstill right now.
alpine292, you are right, it does not justify a "lowball offer", it justify a "NO OFFER at all". everybody knows that in a sticky market like real estate, before severe price adjustments you have a collapse in volume. hence, chances are that you current offer will lead you to catch a falling knife.
If you look at the closing prices of UWS units that sold in Dec, they were still fairly high indicative of the strenght of the market. Buyers could have walked but did not.
If you look at the closing prices of UWS units that sold in Dec, they were still fairly high indicative of the strength of the market. Buyers could have walked but did not.
Alpine,
Few post-Lehman, same-apartment comps in UWS from urbandigs site...
334 West 87th Street #4D
StreetEasy History
07/27/2007 Previous sale closed for $807,500
05/03/2008 Listed in StreetEasy by Elliman at $829,000
06/13/2008 Price decreased to $799,000
08/01/2008 Price decreased to $775,000
10/10/2008 Elliman listing entered contract
12/08/2008 Sale closed for $675,000
157 West 79th Street #10AE
StreetEasy History
09/07/2005 Previous sale closed for $1,328,000
09/13/2008 Listed in StreetEasy by Halstead Property at $1,495,000
09/30/2008 Price decreased to $1,395,000
11/11/2008 Halstead Property listing entered contract
01/14/2009 Sale closed for $1,280,000
http://www.urbandigs.com/2009/01/price_discovery_phase_1_begins.html
Prices are not "correct" until volume becomes normal. Until then, the prices you see are simply asking prices and the few comps that exist are rather meaningless. A market cannot survive without buyers. Once transactions are at historical levels you will know what the true price level is.
Volume goes down, then prices folow. There is a substantial delay between the time the decision is made to buy and closing, so the higher closing prices reflect condition that existed 3-9 months ago.
alpine,
i agree that one should look at comps when making an offer. but those comps should be from 2002. comps from 2005-2007 are more or less meaningless. some might look at 2004, but i'd look at 2002. the low sales volume indicates a disconnect between buyers and sellers. without a buyer an apartment is worth $0.
i agree -- how does one locate 2002 comps -is there an easy way to do this?
acris
The long-term volume drop is stunning. January was especially slow, but there were some extraordinary factors there, including the rush of some sellers to close in calendar 2008. Closings will pick up in February, but prices won't.
alpina... WTF? deflation => people stop purchasing goods bc they believe (correctly) prices will be lower later :) hence no volume...
sellers at this point would take a hairy low ball offer, much less no offer at all .. .sweaty hairy low ball? I digress ....
It doesn't necessarily mean anything yet. It could be a lag in streeteasy. Maybe they'll drop all the closings in a big batch.
ACRIS might show a mortgage amount but as far as I know it is difficult to determine a down payment. You might assume 20% down on a property but it might have been 10% or 90%.