SEC considering temp ban on mark-to- market. That seems like the solution we need.
Started by steveF
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2319
Member since: Mar 2008
Discussion about
This seems like it could be the turning point for banks. I'm thinking that this means no further writedowns or reserve for writedowns on those illiquid mortgage securities. Isn't that the cause of this economic problem to begin with?!! One question for all you finance people. At what price would these assets be priced at? Would it be book value? So do banks balance sheets asset side immediately increase. What would be the accounting transaction? Debit assets for the security price improvement and credit what?....
Response by West81st
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 5564
Member since: Jan 2008
1) It's a rumor.
2) The most prominent version of the rumor suggests that the suspension will be a fig leaf to justify the execution prices on asset sales to Treasury's "Bad Bank". In short, instead of paying 70 for a bond that's on a bank's books at 50 (a criticized attribute of earlier asset purchases), Treasury will let the bank mark the asset up to 70, then buy it "at the market".
IMO, the story isn't the possible rule change. The story is that Treasury is moving ahead with a credible Bad Bank plan that seeks to address the politically unpalatable aspects of massive asset purchases.
I don't know why you care about the GAAP treatment. It probably depends on the extent to which the institution retains upside or liability for the future behavior of the sold asset.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by junkman_r_u_serious
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 230
Member since: May 2008
It's irrelevant. Accounting only tells you what has already happened.
Even if the rule is suspended it isn't like counterparties are going to accept the book value of the assets and obligations on bank balance sheets in lieu of the true economic value, it will just be more difficult to ascertain. In my opinion, abandoning mark to market accounting would do more harm than good as it would diminish investor confidence in company financial statements.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by waverly
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1638
Member since: Jul 2008
I think that the suspension of the mark to market rule will help with the "bank bank" structure, how to price them for the sale and will allow the banks to finally be rid of the toxic assets on their balance sheets. Once done, the banks should be able to begin lending money which shoud provide an immediate boost to confidence as well some sort stability/growth that we haven't had for 3-4 months....or at least that is the theory.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008
in the end, the market seems to have loved it. Right now, thats the most important thing - confidence. Because lack of confidence creates actual problems, like tight credit.
So, even if its a complete layer of BS, we need more BS around here, as long as it is positive.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by McHale
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 399
Member since: Oct 2008
About $2 trillion in credit derivatives in 1989 jumped to $8 trillion in 1994 and skyrocketed to $100 trillion in 2002. Last year, the Bank for International Settlements, a consortium of the world's central banks based in Basel (the Fed chair, Ben Bernanke, sits on its board), reported the gross value of these commitments at $596 trillion. Some are due, and some will mature soon. Typically, they involve contracts of five years or less.
Credit derivatives are breaking and will continue to break the world's financial system and cause an unending crisis of liquidity and gummed-up credit. Warren Buffett branded derivatives the "financial weapons of mass destruction." Felix Rohatyn, the investment banker who organized the bailout of New York a generation ago, called them "financial hydrogen bombs."
Both are right. At almost $600 trillion, over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives dwarf the value of publicly traded equities on world exchanges, which totaled $62.5 trillion in the fall of 2007 and fell to $36.6 trillion a year later.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by McHale
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 399
Member since: Oct 2008
BTW SteveF are you clueless like a blond........... or as dumb like a rock?
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by 93rd
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 69
Member since: Apr 2008
"Some are due, and some will mature soon"
McHale - are you referring to CDS contracts? Could you please clarify - I don't understand the impact if it matures with no credit event.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by manhattanfox
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1275
Member since: Sep 2007
OUCH!
Your book value question/comment shows that you have no concept of valuation and should immediately be used as a red flag to you to not comment on anything value related -- including home prices.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by farquhar
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 124
Member since: Jun 2008
SteveF - have you had NO success selling your properties?
Will you promise that when you sell your last property, you'll stop posting about things you know nothing about?
1) It's a rumor.
2) The most prominent version of the rumor suggests that the suspension will be a fig leaf to justify the execution prices on asset sales to Treasury's "Bad Bank". In short, instead of paying 70 for a bond that's on a bank's books at 50 (a criticized attribute of earlier asset purchases), Treasury will let the bank mark the asset up to 70, then buy it "at the market".
IMO, the story isn't the possible rule change. The story is that Treasury is moving ahead with a credible Bad Bank plan that seeks to address the politically unpalatable aspects of massive asset purchases.
I don't know why you care about the GAAP treatment. It probably depends on the extent to which the institution retains upside or liability for the future behavior of the sold asset.
It's irrelevant. Accounting only tells you what has already happened.
Even if the rule is suspended it isn't like counterparties are going to accept the book value of the assets and obligations on bank balance sheets in lieu of the true economic value, it will just be more difficult to ascertain. In my opinion, abandoning mark to market accounting would do more harm than good as it would diminish investor confidence in company financial statements.
I think that the suspension of the mark to market rule will help with the "bank bank" structure, how to price them for the sale and will allow the banks to finally be rid of the toxic assets on their balance sheets. Once done, the banks should be able to begin lending money which shoud provide an immediate boost to confidence as well some sort stability/growth that we haven't had for 3-4 months....or at least that is the theory.
in the end, the market seems to have loved it. Right now, thats the most important thing - confidence. Because lack of confidence creates actual problems, like tight credit.
So, even if its a complete layer of BS, we need more BS around here, as long as it is positive.
About $2 trillion in credit derivatives in 1989 jumped to $8 trillion in 1994 and skyrocketed to $100 trillion in 2002. Last year, the Bank for International Settlements, a consortium of the world's central banks based in Basel (the Fed chair, Ben Bernanke, sits on its board), reported the gross value of these commitments at $596 trillion. Some are due, and some will mature soon. Typically, they involve contracts of five years or less.
Credit derivatives are breaking and will continue to break the world's financial system and cause an unending crisis of liquidity and gummed-up credit. Warren Buffett branded derivatives the "financial weapons of mass destruction." Felix Rohatyn, the investment banker who organized the bailout of New York a generation ago, called them "financial hydrogen bombs."
Both are right. At almost $600 trillion, over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives dwarf the value of publicly traded equities on world exchanges, which totaled $62.5 trillion in the fall of 2007 and fell to $36.6 trillion a year later.
BTW SteveF are you clueless like a blond........... or as dumb like a rock?
"Some are due, and some will mature soon"
McHale - are you referring to CDS contracts? Could you please clarify - I don't understand the impact if it matures with no credit event.
OUCH!
Your book value question/comment shows that you have no concept of valuation and should immediately be used as a red flag to you to not comment on anything value related -- including home prices.
SteveF - have you had NO success selling your properties?
Will you promise that when you sell your last property, you'll stop posting about things you know nothing about?