Skip Navigation

Rent vs Own: Blue Test

Started by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006
Discussion about
Now that the Lower East Side's Blue building is opening, we can do an A-B comparison of renting versus buying. I purchased a unit there for $860k, putting 10% down. The same floor plan is now up for rent for $5k per month. So we can now compare apples to apples on living standard and determine the better deal: Invest the down payment in the market and rent for $5k or buy and pay roughly $4,400 per month total after tax break. So, renting costs about $600 more per month but you keep and invest the down payment. Buying saves you $600 per month but you might do better investing the down payment (plus about $50k in additional purchase fees) in the market.
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

The rental fee is more along the lines of $6400 per month because you would not have the tax break.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#1 - where is LES' blue?
#2 - the tax break applies to the interest only so you'd have to add taxes to the $4400 as well if you want to compare pretax amounts right?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by matsonjones
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

And don't forget this - your mortgage is now FIXED for the next THIRTY YEARS! As inflation and rents go up, up, up for the next THIRTY YEARS your mortgage payment will never change and will be come (due to infaltion) an increasingly smaller and smaller part of you income on a percentage basis - and that's A BIG DEAL! This in no way even factors in the increase in value of your place (meaning the down payment) over the same thirty year period!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

I am not sure your math works. To take the down payment investment issue out of the equation, let's look at it like a 100% financed deal. Also let's only look at interest expense as amortizing the loan is really adding to equity. So, an $860K mortgage at 6% would set you back $4300/month plus $750 CC and $850 unabated re tax. That's a pre tax total of $5900/month. Tax at 35% would give you an after tax cost of $4100 which compares directly and favorably to renting at $5000/month and we don't have to argue about how we might have invested the downpayment. Oh, and by the way, the tax is abated for the firts 10 years and starts out at around $75/month.

Am I missing something?

And no, I am not a broker, nor an owner, just a poor broke renter.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by ssskit
over 19 years ago
Posts: 69
Member since: Dec 2006

(Comment from original poster.) Good points. Really, I'm trying to find reasons why I should NOT have bought at Blue.. Not bought meaning I could have lived in equal "luxury" and came out better financially.

BTW, to poster 3, this is Blue: bluecondonyc.com/.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#5, thats a good analysis, only issue is whether the AMT actually allows the buyer to enjoy the full 1800 a month in tax savings.

#1/#6, why are you looking for reasons not to buy, you already bought, just enjoy your new place.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

OP and 6, if you decide you want to move in the next few years, you probably would have done better by renting. You may find it hard to realize a positive ROI...esp considering the high closing costs of a condo and new construction. So if your career is in flux, you want to live/work elsehwere, you bought a small place and want to start a family, etc, you may have done better by renting.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

I'm not starting a family anytime soon! But yes, agree that this only works as a 5 year plus timeframe.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

more like a 10 year + in this market

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

CUT TO: MATSONJONES looking at keys to leased Lexus while surfing EBay for a used H3, feeling oddly unfaithful then quickly indignant.

MATSONJONES: (softly) I deserve it.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

fugly building anyway, i mean c'mon.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment