What Should I Do
Started by Mhillqt
over 19 years ago
Posts: 405
Member since: Feb 2007
Discussion about
Ive been living in a rent stabilized loft studio for 10 years in murray hill....Nice area off park avenue......i didnt buy a 1 bedroom prewar condo on 39th and park in 1996 @ 175k because it seemed high(now worth $1 million) NOR did I buy a few other 1 bedroom coops in the area at the time for $100k......didnt buy since rent is good....NOW Im faced with getting older(45) and wanting a separate... [more]
Ive been living in a rent stabilized loft studio for 10 years in murray hill....Nice area off park avenue......i didnt buy a 1 bedroom prewar condo on 39th and park in 1996 @ 175k because it seemed high(now worth $1 million) NOR did I buy a few other 1 bedroom coops in the area at the time for $100k......didnt buy since rent is good....NOW Im faced with getting older(45) and wanting a separate bedroom but everything in my area(which is where i want to live) is $500k PLUS......I cant seem to make the plunge since I know that these same apts were worth 1/5 of the price 10 years ago and 1/2 of the price 5 years ago.......will i be saying in 5 years the same thing OR will the market fall...ive waited so long, should i just stay in my nice studio at low rent and see what happens....dont want to be 50 saying the same thing...im sure others are in my same boat...I HATE THIS REAL ESTATE MARKET for FIRST TIME BUYERS! [less]
The market may go down but I doubt you'll be getting deep deep discounts on something desirable. Get out there & look around & you'll find something you like, maybe not your one bedroom right away, but at least you'll be in the market & perhaps at 50 you can start looking for that one bedroom. I think of my 92 year old aunt who's still gasping at the prices of everything because she remembers the 5 cent loaf of bread. Those days are gone & deal with what you've got now.
I can understand and appreciate you frustration.
I bought a place in Murray Hill in 2000 (at 20 East 35th Street) for $299,000, and sold it in 2004 for $435,000. It probably sells for about $620,000 (+/-). I remember that a few years prior to that in 1997 or so I had the opportunity to get a rent stabilized studio on the top floor of a building in the west 30's around 6th Avenue for a $15,000 'key fee,' but turned it down.
I would say the first thing is to not look backwards. It dose nothing but create anxiety and lack of confidence. The only reason to 'look back' is so that you are realistically aware that real estate doesn't go up all the time.
Having said that, (I'm also 45, BTW), and having just bought a (relatively expensive) new home, I would say in your case, because you have a nice low, fixed rent stabilized situation, to bide your time. I don't think the market will totlally crash. Nor do I think it's going to swing upwards in any serious way. It could,however, go stagnant for quite some time.
What you have to balance now, most importantly, is the following -
1. Interest rates are at historic lows, and will, most certainly over time, rise.
2. You need to balance that fact aginst a situation that even if the real market comes in a bit, if the interest rates rise, it'll still basically cost the same amount to buy now or in the future.
3. Finally it also depends heavily on your down payment. If making that down payment is going to leave you too 'house poor,' that can be a dangerous thing when you have approximately 20 (give or take) years to put together a nest egg for 'retirement.'
You need to balance those three things against each other when making your decision. Ig you know for sure that your rent sabiliztion situation is going to be a long term permanent lock, then at least you're in a situation where you can assess things without feeling you have to make an uncomfortably fast move.
Mhillqt, I just bought my first place and I'm around your age so I understand your anxiety. I had a great rental deal for a while but knew I had to move out soon, so my mortgage & maint payments are about equal to what my rent would be for a comparable place, even less after tax.
Knowing my rent was cheap enabled me to save enough $$ for a down pmt + closing costs. What I found as a buyer was that good places, even in this market, don't last. So if you're considering buying, take your time.
The market may dip, you never know, but if you're planning to stay for at least a good few years or so (sounds like you will) it makes sense to buy. good luck!
Sounds like you are in a neighborhood you want to stay in and that a 1BR will suit you fine for space for a long time. With that in mind, I say you should jump in and buy something as soon as you can. As long as you plan to stay there for awhile, you can ride out any dips in the market. The key is finding a place you know you can stay in for awhile and one that you can afford while you are there. If that happens, buy and start building equity. (unless of course your apartment is $500 per month and you are saving a ton of money each month.)
I agree totally that you need to forget the past and what you could have bought (although we all think of that at times) and look forward to where you want to be in 5-10 years. Good luck.
Thanks for all your replies...I will continue to look...my rent is cheap for a great area - ie $1,000 per month.....20 e 35....love that building! Its still hard to let go of backing out of the contract on that 1 bedroom prewar condo on park avenue....i would have netted $800,000!!!!!
Since you love that building so, can you stay there & buy a little place & rent it out? I'm surprised how (relatively) inexpensive some little studios are still in Manhattan. Maybe you can have your cake & eat it, too. Since you're still crying about that Park Avenue deal, decide you won't make the same mistake again & that $800,000 is coming to you in a different way!
I dont live at 20 E 35...was commenting on how the poster above sold a place at that address....dont get your last comment...are you saying, dont make the same mistake twice...ie buy now? Ive been in my studio over 10 years and its rent stabilized.....
I'm the poster who lived at 20 East 35 - well, think of it this way - 10 years ago, a one bedroom in that building was probably $150,000, and now, it's about $650,000, so you're only out $500,000 there, not the $800,000 on the Park Avenue condo!
$1,000/month for a stabilized studio certainly is a good deal. To buy a one bedroom at 20 East 35 right now, assuming $650,000/20% down/30 years@6.375% and the current maintenace of $1,119 you're at about $$4,500/month total (before the tax deduction for the interest on the mortgage and the maintenance). A rough guess would be the after tax cost to be $3,500 - $3,750 monthly.
So the big questions are 1.) can you swing the monthly cost comfortably? 2.) based on the differential are you comfortable putting that extra monthly amount above the $1,000 you're currently paying for rent into a home rather than investing it somewhere else? 3.) will the downpayment and closing costs (roughly $135,000 in total +/-) put you in severe financial situation, if, heaven forbid, you become ill or need to quickly access a chunk of money?
Since you would plan on living there a very long time, the issue of flipping is moot, and the value of the home will, of course, go down and up, but if you're 45 and believe that you'll be there for 15+ years, time horizon is not a big issue.
I would put more of a downpayment since I saved money while living here....so, i dont think the issue would be financial MORE about paying 5x what I want to pay! I initially backed out of my condo deal at 77 park avenue 10 years ago but the apt stayed on the market for months....they couldnt give away a 1 bedroom prewar condo on park at 175 k in those days...can you believe it....so, I came back and the seller accepted my offer the 2nd time...i signed the contract and then sent it over and they gave it someone else...so it was really CLOSE....and have been gunshy about buying ever since...SO, having a great deal on a studio has saved me money BUT also lost me 800k profit......
Again, you really shouldn't look backward. It does not assist you in making a decision now.
I am also in favor of putting down more than 20% myself, but I couldn't assume that you could afford to (or wished to) do that.
I think, having heard your pov, that the question is even if you do plan to live in a place for 15+ years - but in the short term, the market went down and you (for a while) lost 25% of the value of your place on paper, and had to wait another five to seven years for it to come back up again - would you be comfortable with that financially and emotionally?
If the gain or loss in value on paper of your home wouldn't bother you because you imagine living there a very long time (or even going out feet first), than I think you should definitely buy. You don't view it as an assest in your financial portfolio, you view it as a home that you own and are building equity in over the long run with the eventual goal of ownership.
If the gain or loss in value on paper WOULD be something that you would constantly fret about (as I might point out that you are doing about your current rental situation), than you have simply traded a current situation of anxiety and stress for another situation of anxiety and stress - and what would be the point in that exercise?
It only makes sense to buy, even if the market does go down for a while, because you believe that you will have better overall mental hygiene than your current situation offers you.
Some people take chances and win, others lose. If you didn't buy in 1996 and
had the chance, I doubt that you will spend the cash now. No one here can forsee
the future, go with your gut feeling and be satisfied.
WOW....all this doom and gloom is really frightening...ie subprime loans, etc etc.....everyone is saying to wait....ive been waiting for so many years...feel like i have to wait a few more....i will finally buy an apt in 3 years , if it goes down.,.......i hate this real estate market