Need Advice
Started by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006
Discussion about
My situation: My wife and I are currently renting in a one bedroom ($3,500 per month) in the Trump Buildings on the Upper West Side and are desperately in need of a 2-bedroom due to limited space and she works from home sometimes. We have 500k in cash and an income around 225K per year. Based on my calculations and coop (thre are very few condos on the UWS in locations I like) requirements, we... [more]
My situation: My wife and I are currently renting in a one bedroom ($3,500 per month) in the Trump Buildings on the Upper West Side and are desperately in need of a 2-bedroom due to limited space and she works from home sometimes. We have 500k in cash and an income around 225K per year. Based on my calculations and coop (thre are very few condos on the UWS in locations I like) requirements, we could afford an apartment in the $1.2 - $1.3 range. Other than a tight market now on the UWS, I have been trying to convince my wife to move to San Diego within the next five years. She is apprehensive due to the distance from friends/family. So based on say a 50/50 chance we leave in 5 years or less and want to stay on the UWS in a quality building, which option is better: 1. Buy a 2-bedroom apartment (considering we can find one we like in this market) and take the risk that prices will be stagnant or less and take a loss when we sell due to closing costs, mansion taxe etc.. 2. Rent a 2-bedroom in a very tight rental market around 5K per month and basically waste money. However, this would give us the flexibiblity to leave when we wanted with no strings. Thanks in advance for your comments. [less]
You can still buy, then rent the apt out when you leave the state. There's property management companies who takes the responsibility of managing your property for a small fee. They will rent, collect rent, pay your mortgage, and respond to all problems by the tenant.
I assume the OP can't do what #2 is suggesting because he'll need the $$$ for a new home in SD. I say continue renting for the next year or two to get better visibility on your long term plans - prices aren't going to appreciate signifcantly in the next two years anyway.
If you are trying to move to California in te next five years, and are considering 50/50 odds on that I do not advise buying a coop. Even if you can rent for a few years, generally no more than that and you will then be forced to sell. If you can afford to hold 2 apts so long as 1 is rented, then look for a condo but only a condo. If you will need to sell prior o moving, then honestly keep renting. Maybe in a year the possibility of a move will be more clear, perhaps far less likely at which point you can buy. Though I am not one of those who believes the market will crash, or even go down significantly, I do not believe the prices will go up much in the next year or two either. I would say rent at this point until you are clearer on the plans...PARTICULARLY if, as you say, you would most likely buy a coop.
Renting is not always "wasting money". For such a short timeframe of 5 yrs, very little equity is being built up and most of the payments are going to interest payments. I think you run a big risk with buying if there's a good chance you're going to be moving so soon.
We just bought a 2BR on the UWS. We will either stay in it or rent it for at least 5 years though. If there were a 50% chance that we would leave the city before then, I think we would have kept renting.
have you considered buying a condo instead of a coop (maybe not in the neighbourhood that you are looking at but slightly further away)? then you could still rent it out easily if you do move away (and let the rent pay the mortgage) and if you don't move, then you protect yourself from any possible price increase.
My suggestion would be to buy, but buy smart. It used to be that you could buy anything in Manhattan and its value would escalate almost immediately. That is no longer the case. However, regradless of market conditions, there are always certain properties that sell. Location, location, location + view + whatever. Look hard with your head, not your heart, and buy.
between the two of you, you only make 225k!
Move to Jersey you schmuck, you'll fit in better there!