$5,200
for rent
Base rent only. Price may not include required fees and charges.
850 ft²
$73 per ft²
5 rooms
2 beds
1 bath
Four-family home
- Carroll Gardens
Under NYC law, you can't be charged a broker fee if you didn't hire a broker.
Listed by
This home has been saved by 13 users.
Listing by Compass, Corporate Broker, 514 2nd Street, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Available
9/14/2026
Days on market
Listed today
Last price change
No changes
About
Your search for an authentic floor through apartment in Carroll Gardens stops here.
Welcome home to a newly refinished, floor through two-bedroom where no expense was spared in its meticulous gut renovation. Featuring a spacious and flexible layout with open living and dining areas, a king-sized master bedroom and windowed kitchen with stainless steel appliances includin a dishwasher.
Policies
Sorry, policy info isn’t available right now. Check back later.
Home features
Central air
Dishwasher
Fireplace
Decorative
Hardwood floors
Building amenities
No info on building amenities
About the building
158 President Street
158 President Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231
4 units
3 stories
1900 built
Property history
Prices shown are base rent only. For total monthly price and additional fees, see .
| Date | Base rent | Event |
|---|---|---|
8/29/2026 | $5,200 | Listed by Compass |
6/7/2021 | $2,450 | |
6/4/2021 | $2,450 | |
5/28/2021 | $2,450 | |
5/24/2021 | $2,450 |
Past listing photos
Sign in to take a closer look at how this home compares to similar homes.
Explore Carroll Gardens
Transit
| Location | Distance |
|---|---|
FGat Carroll St | 0.36 miles |
FGat Bergen St | 0.53 miles |
FGRat Smith–9th St | 0.59 miles |
R2345at Borough Hall/Court St | 0.84 miles |
ACGat Hoyt & Schermerhorn | 0.9 miles |
About Carroll Gardens
Sales
Median asking price
2 beds
$1.72M
Rentals
Median asking base rent
2 beds
$5,750
Carroll Gardens is at once the heart of old-school Brooklyn and a showcase for the borough's brownstone boom. The neighborhood has long been known for its red-sauce Italian joints and lively street life. But now, staples like Caputo's Bake Shop and Monteleone's Bakery and Café abut upscale stroller shops, yoga studios and fro-yo joints. Despite the newcomers, the neighborhood still feels like a small town, one of the few places where you might know your neighbors, your postman and your butcher by name.
Learn more about Carroll GardensSimilar homes
Rental unit in Park Slope
505 12th Street #2B- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- - ft²
Listing by NOVO Living LLC
previousnext
previousnext$4,638 net effective base rent
1.5 months free·12-month lease- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- - ft²
Listing by Doorway NYC, LLC
previousnextRental unit in Carroll Gardens
546 Henry Street #3C- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- - ft²
Listing by The Excelsior Collection LTD
previousnextRental unit in Park Slope
238 Eight Street #4R$4,813 net effective base rent
1 month free·12-month lease- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- - ft²
Listing by NOVO Living LLC
previousnextRental unit in Park Slope
257 15th Street #502$4,673 net effective base rent
1 month free·12-month lease- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- - ft²
Listing by Park Slope Warren LLC
previousnextMixed-use building in Park Slope
370 5th Avenue #2L- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- - ft²
Listing by NOVO Living LLC
previousnextFour-family home in Columbia St Waterfront District
76 Carroll Street #4- 2 beds
- 2 baths
- - ft²
Listing by NOVO Living LLC
previousnextRental unit in Carroll Gardens
104 Luquer Street #D4$4,923 net effective base rent
1.25 months free·12-month lease- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- 780 ft²
Listing by Z+G Property Group
previousnextSimilar Homes looks at ad spend and other factors like location, price, and number of beds and baths.