The Gotham - what gives?

sellers can ask whatever they want..the only thing that matters is where the bids are

I can't speak to the 2-beds, but I am somewhat familiar with the 3-beds in the building (we saw W19C not too long ago, spoke to the broker a bunch, actually considered making an offer, but probably won't)

W19C is bigger than W11A, on a higher floor, and has outdoor space. Really not apples to apples.

That said, the ask on W19C is a total joke. The kitchen is nice, but pretty much everything else in the apartment needs work. And the floorplan is a bit funky, not the best use of space. And the maintenance + RE taxes add up to over $2psf. We did not see the pool, but the gym was mediocre and the playroom was depressing/disgusting, so I don't think you're paying the maintenance for the amenities.

The broker said they were very motivated sellers, so if she's telling the truth, I won't be surprised to see W19C on the "successful lowballs" thread in the upcoming months.