Ryan Medicare Voucher Program Destined to Fail

Will Anyone Even Insure Seniors if Paul Ryan's Medicare Plan Passes? At first glance, Paul Ryan's plan to send millions of seniors into the free market with dwindling vouchers in hand might seem a boon to the private insurance industry. But would companies even want to participate? Unlike the Affordable Care Act, which mandated that millions of young and healthy Americans purchase insurance with... [more]

Will Anyone Even Insure Seniors if Paul Ryan's Medicare Plan Passes? At first glance, Paul Ryan's plan to send millions of seniors into the free market with dwindling vouchers in hand might seem a boon to the private insurance industry. But would companies even want to participate? Unlike the Affordable Care Act, which mandated that millions of young and healthy Americans purchase insurance with government subsidies, the Paul Ryan plan would instead bring the oldest, sickest, and least profitable demographic to the table. And with the CBO projecting that the average senior would be on the hook for over two-thirds of their health care costs within just 10 years of the plan's adoption -- a proportion that is projected to worsen in the long run --- the government subsidies backing them up may not bring in enough profitable customers to make things worthwhile. "If reimbursement rates are too low to provide basic benefits, they'll tell the government, 'You do it,'" one insurance lobbyist told TPM. "I don't think they can require they lose money, they'd just pull out." Insurers have successfully demanded funding hikes to other programs even as their clients faced far less dire circumstances than projected under Ryan's plan, raising the question of whether Ryan's savings would ever come to pass. Take Medicare+Choice, a private exchange for seniors created in 1997 by the GOP Congress. Under the program, the government paid the equivalent it would use to fund Medicare coverage to reimburse private HMOs instead under the theory that the free market would operate more efficiently and produce better results. Instead, insurers found they were unable to sustain a profit and began pulling out en masse. In 2000, more than 900,000 patients were dropped as HMOs deserted the program, citing inadequate federal backing and a lack of a prescription drug benefit. "Year after year, the reimbursement rates were cut for these plans, making it increasingly unattractive for private providers to offer plans," one Republican congressman recalled in 2009, adding that for seniors who lost coverage "the consequences were painful and the vocal anger was justified." That congressman was none other than Paul Ryan. http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2011/04/will-anyone-even-insure-seniors-if-paul-ryans-medicare-plan-passes.php [less]