502 Park Avenue, 7H, Advice Needed
Started by realestaterookie
over 17 years ago
Posts: 13
Member since: Mar 2009
Discussion about
Really like the building and location. Seller bought this for $1.156 in December 2007. It is currently listed for $1.249. Where do you think it ends up? What would you offer? http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/360010-condo-502-park-avenue-lenox-hill-new-york
What's the rush? There'll always be one-bedrooms available there. Seller bought at peak; no need for you to, too.
Understood, although other units have sold for more since then. Where do you think it should end up?
Beats me, but consensus here is still going down. We're still near the peak. There's no danger of your missing the bottom, give or take a few percent. Rent for awhile; can't hurt.
Also, just to be snide, don't buy there until they take Trump's name off it. Bad for resale.
Here's the sales history for that unit:
08/18/2004
Previous Sale recorded for $734,000.
12/21/2005
Previously Listed in StreetEasy by Corcoran at $1,300,000.
07/26/2006
Corcoran Listing is no longer available. Last priced at $1,200,000.
12/28/2007
Previous Sale recorded for $1,156,500.
10/25/2008
Listed in StreetEasy by Corcoran at $1,395,000.
01/12/2009
Price decreased by 3% to $1,349,000.
03/02/2009
Price decreased by 7% to $1,249,000.
See the sale price in 2004? It was $734,000. Bid under that. WAY under. And I totally agree with NWT about waiting until Trump's name is removed.
Are you kidding me? $1MM+ for this? You walk into a 1/2 kitchen which is also your entry foyer and coat closet. There's a decent size livingroom except you have to put a dining table someplace in it; the bedroom is okay size but only access to bathroom is through bedroom and there is not even a little hall or alcove separating bedroom from living room. This is as cookie-cutter and dull a one-bdrm layout as exists. All to live in this building? With so much to choose from in NYC, this kind of money for this apartment baffles me. I'd see how much this layout is worth in average building on east side (currently maybe $450,000-500,000?) and then ask myself how much more is it worth to live in this building at this location. If the answer is location+building = $500K+, then bid away. Otherwise, any bid will be rejected in all likelihood at this time and you are wasting the seller's time.
Total bubble-fluff pricing that makes no sense, even at the peak on a comparative basis to other areas. Sellers asking these kinds of prices are hoping and praying they will find the last greater-fools in Manhattan who somehow haven't gotten the wake-up call.
I'm not defending the pricing but if you look at other condos in the area, (521 Park, 525 Park), I think they are in the ball park. Don't forget there are not too many pre-war condos on Park Avenue.
Since you like the area, check out the <$1M one-bedrooms a block away at 480 Park. Living rooms as big as both 502 rooms together. Classy building, too. Just hate to see you fall for shiny and new, when it'll look funky and wrong-kind-of-old in ten years, anyway.
Thanks NWT. I've seen 480 Park. Beautiful building also. But again, condo versus co-op that requires 50% down and you cannot rent out freely for life.
Holy crap... Bring you $1M down to lower fifth and get a much better 1-bedroom in a much nicer building in a much better part of town.
Shouldn't you find three or four places you would like at VERY substantial discounts to asking, and then make very low ball offers, and see what happens. What I mean is -- this market is so illiquid, and so potentially volatile, the discount you might get with this strategy is multiples of what it might have been in the past, say a year ago. I don't know, it just seems that if you want to buy under these perilous market conditions you ought to at least extract the "fear" discount that may be lurking in one or another seller.
This is not my original idea. Someone else on here wrote that in this kind of market it is a mistake to fixate on one unit....keep looking until you find the desperate seller.,
Let's say prices in 1995 were at 100. Someone with your income (which must be decent, or we wouldn't be having this discussion) in 1995 dollars could live pretty well.
Prices are now at around 450. From 100 to 450 in 14 years. Even after we discount down to 1995 dollars, that's an enormous appreciation that's justified by nothing except RE being included in the general asset bubble. Why buy now when you can wait and get, say, three times the apartment for the same money?
If 7H thinks they can sell now and not take a major, major, bath, then they're nuts. Don't be an enabler of that. Put another way, don't hand a stranger a gift of many hundreds of thousands of dollars.