Let's Play Pretend-Wells Fargo
Started by McHale
over 17 years ago
Posts: 399
Member since: Oct 2008
Discussion about
Using the “mark to market” accounting method, mortgage-backed securities were valued relative to the latest prices fetched by the sale of similar assets on the open market. Currently, those bonds are being sold at deep discounts to their original value. By “marking” their unsold bonds down to those prices, the insolvency of our financial institutions had been laid bare. The new accounting changes will allow the nervous owners to assign more “appropriate” (i.e. higher) values. Problem solved.
The imaginative conceit that lies behind the accounting change is that the toxic assets polluting bank balance sheets are not really toxic at all. They are in fact highly valuable assets that for some irrational reason no one wants to buy.
+1. Just adds to the opacity of the industry. Won't touch bank stocks with a ten foot pole.
Saw this quote recently, “The ultimate result of shielding men from the effects of folly, is to fill the world with fools.” (Herbert Spencer)
Last week analysts were predicting a 6.3 billion write down of toxic assets but BAC announced it was only 3 billion yesterday...... TOTO were in Disney Land again
Apparently people don't understand how bank accounting works. Illiquid assets have always been marked to market in one way or another. Only recently was the rule changed to force banks to take into account the last traded price (of an illiquid asset).
Previously, mark to traded prices was only required for assets held for sale. Assets held to maturity were booked at their purchase price. If you hold a long-term asset that you plan to hold to maturity, it makes no sense to mark it to short-term prices. Markets are irrational in the short-term.
Imagine you own a house. No one wants to buy it. Is it worth $0?
I'm with Steve on this - if you purchased an asset intending to hold it to a maturity that is decades away, why should your capital ratios suffer because the market for that product is frozen due to a panic? There are securities that are getting at best 10 cents on the dollar that have a higher inherent value if kept to maturity, not sure it benefits anyone to have these priced every darn month. GAAP rules on this have evolved over time and I think the current update makes sense. It's a middle ground between priced at purchase and mark to market. I don't see how this hurts anyone - if you don't trust it, stay away from, or better yet, short bank stocks. I purchased C at $1.62 and am happy about that trade. I mean, heck, it's either going to zero (in which case add it to the list) or blowing past 5 at some point, can't hang out in the 3's forever.
Much of the public's misunderstanding of banking derives directly from the press' misunderstanding of banking. Recently Andrew Ross Sorkin of the Times was on CNBC to discuss his article on the FDIC's accounting of contingent liabilities. He said Sheila Bair had screamed at him that he didn't know what he was talking about - and she was right.
He thought the FDIC had to book a liability for contingent liabilities on loan guarantees. I actually wrote to Ross Sorkin with a copy of the accounting rules - contingent liabilities are not booked as anything other than a memo entry if a) the liability is not likely to be incurred; and b) it can't be quantified.
Both of those are true in the FDIC's case. Sorkin didn't answer me.
For mortgage-backed securities, they are currently trading at prices indicating that 90% of the underlying assets will default. That is obviously untrue, yet it works to the benefit (yet again) of the short-sellers, who because an asset does not trade actively and/or they don't want to buy it, they can force the price down. The unintended effect of the FASB change was to give banks the option of pricing their illiquid securities properly, which inadvertently created a secondary market for them as short-sellers can't sit idly by as prices fall. All the recent Bush-era changes in securities rules seem to have been written by the short-sellers themselves: eliminate the uptick rule, unregulated CDO's which when their price goes up forces the stock price down, failure to prosecute or even investigate naked short-selling, changes to FASB. Is it no wonder that stocks fell the fastest since 1933 just months after the rules enacted in 1933 were repealed?
SteveJ - we don't agree on much when it comes to our prognostications on NY real estate, but I am 100% with you on this topic. Well said, sir.
The banks had the option of valuing the toxic waste either way. They chose to value it at sale, rather than maturity, price when the bubble made the fools gold look good. Now that everyone sees that housing prices do fall and homeowners do default, the fools who are holding this junk want to change the rules. Sorry. Time is money and the bank balance sheets look very different when assets are held to maturity.
Stevejhx - you're obviously well schooled on this topic. However, I was talking to someone in the business. He told me that over the past few years, banks were unable to sell off their lower quality mortgage assets and this is what's sitting on their books (or off their books). The point is that these assets were not intended to be held to maturity. In this case, mark-to-market should apply.
Banks loved mark-to-market when markets were going up, because they no longer had to defend the high prices they placed on their assets. They could just mark them to the market price, watch billions of dollars of profits flow through to the bottom line, and cash in at the end of the year.
Now that markets are going down, however, banks are screaming bloody murder about mark-to-market, because it is making them insolvent. Wrong on this Stevejhx and you know I always agree with most of what you post!
OTNYC/Stevehjx.... what is the value of a 30yr $4.99MM mortgage with no interest/principal due until the 30th year that was written on a $5MM new development condo in NYC in 2007, where the current market value for the property is $2MM? Should a bank m2m or just stick their heads further up their arse?
Look at cash flow in the 2nd, 3rd and 4th qtr versus earnings. If the earnings from these valuable "assets" don't show up as cash then you can kiss your $1.7 C goodbye. Oh you should also buy GM at $3.... cause it ain't going to be at 3 forever :)
the problem with cdos's is that when 10% of mortgages are non performing, some of the cdo tranches, and the bizarro synthetics, and cdo squares will NEVER receive a payment of interest or principal, i.e. some are worth nothing or close to nothing. even if you hold them to maturity they are worth zero or close. that is why they are called toxic assets, because they ARE toxic, not because the market is illiquid. the market is illiquid because the banks refused to sell these cdo tranches at the appropriated level and accept the implications for marking these assets down, and the buyers actually e know enough to not pay fraudulents inflated prices. it's a bankers strike, holding out for more money from geitner and company....i.e. from us to buy their garbage. they want us to fund their failed institutions, their jobs, their salaries, and maintain their fraud.
when reagan came in to office one of the first things he did was to break the strike of the air traffic controllers. if obama is inspired by reagan (as he says) it't time for him to break the bankers strike, and replace the current bankers with scab bankers. in this case scabs that will be willing to deal with reality, not steal from taxpayers, and accept that their institutions should be in receivership.
steve is right - excellent comments by the way Steve. But I wonder if you can tell me if this is accurate as well, as this is what I am told regarding the OP starting comment.
Its the assets in the HOLD books (accrual books) that are NOT marked to market and are still marked to model. This is why MAYO said many whole loans and other HTM assets are currently still marked around 98 cents on dollar. I actually think they are marked a bit lower, but for most part he is right. I talked about this in my 'Markets got Severity Right, but Not Duration' piece last week:
http://www.urbandigs.com/2009/04/mayo_rains_on_equities_parade.html
The HOLD books are still an issue. They get marked when the entire book starts to non-perform. So if total loans in the book sees a 5% deterioration in performance, then the book is marked down to 95 cents on the dollar - NOT the last trade in the marketplace. So here we are wondering if future economic activity is going to improve, or if we still have loans deteriorating at a faster clip that is yet to be reflected in these hold books.
Clearly, we now see that PRIME is deteriorating at a faster clip than subprime.
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_pMscxxELHEg/SdZBslDNagI/AAAAAAAAE-w/CxJafxk8158/s1600-h/SeriouslyDelinquentQ42008.jpg
See a trend? Add in that default rates for credit cards, student loans, small business loans, jumbo prime, etc.. are all starting to rise big time, and you start to see that this is an overall debt problem, not a subprime problem. We seemed to handle the subprime/alt-a part so far with all gov't/fed programs, intiatives, lending facilities, etc.. But as this aspect of balance sheet is cleansed, other areas are starting to deteriorate. The duration of this process is what I am questioning that the markets are getting wrong.
in addition - with refi boom in place, and record low rates, I think we got the option ARM reset problem taken care of too. However, its not the reset Im worried about, its the RECAST of the loan! When the loan is recast, the payment required to fully amortize the loan over the remaining term becomes the new minimum payment, and the payment cap no longer applies. Expect many min payments to jump for those whose loan balances rose since origination, part of which will be cushioned by the refi that took place though.
This whole thing is so complex, and many people are mislead by headlines to think all is better again. Hey, banks are having amazing quarter (great what ZIRP, and backdoor bailouts to counterparties via AIG can do right, and a trillion in PPIP here and there). Expect monster quarter from GS, JPM, and BAC to bully stocks a bit more. Euphoria will set in, people will think all is better, recession is over. bank stocks will surge 50-60-70% in some cases. GS is up 55% in a month, and it prob will rise more on earnings. But IS all better again?
Expect to see MANY more capital raises by banks as they take advanatge of this move. If companies are much better, and they see stock going much higher, they would NOT do a capital raising effort! But hey, got to pay off TARP right to get govt off your back for employee compensation purposes or risk losing talent! So, expect to possibly see another surge in equities when we hear that companies are paying off TARP - GS will start us off as announced on Blooomberg.
Again, is all better again? Jobs / salaries are all fixed? House prices rising again? Consumer balance sheets all better and incomes can now cover debt service? Umm, dont think so.
The latest figures I have seen indicate that most banks have marked MBS's to 91 cents.
Here's the problem: each of these securities is unique, no two contain the same loans, and it's not possible to apply any statistical formula to all of them; they are opaque. The intent when creating these devices was to use the reinsurance model to distribute risk; the problem is that reinsurance is backed by volumes of actuarial data that reasonably predict performance. Except for facultative reinsurance, where a price is determined for each individual policy.
What needs to happen is the factulative model must be applied to each individual MBS. But we're talking about securities backed by thousands or tens of thousands of individual mortgages, or portions thereof, none of which may be the same as the rest.
It's a significant problem. The solution isn't to mark them all down to $0 because no one knows what they're ultimately worth, however. To me it's sort of like if you know you have a rattlesnake under a rock in your lawn. What do you do? Lift up the rock, or just cordon it off and wait till the thing dies?
MBS's don't mature for many years. In those years banks will have the opportunity to build capital, and the principal amount will be eroded by inflation. The best thing to do is to mark them to a standard discounted cash-flow model. It's relatively common and easy, and the performance of each loan can be checked by auditors. The worst thing to do is to value them at near zero because no one wants to buy them.
so stevejhx how do you view this latest bank rally then, considering this?
UD, I can't make short-term stock market predictions. I invest medium- and long-term. That said, I would hardly call it a "rally" when BAC is trading at $8, which is where it was in December.
I've said on another thread that I am back into financials. I believe that (except for C, which I've said before I don't understand) they are vastly oversold. I came to that conclusion when BAC was trading at less than the value of its minority interests, meaning that the stock market was valuing its branch network, Countrywide, Merrill Lynch, MBNA credit card portfolio at exactly $0.
Let's face it: BAC, JPM, WFC are money machines. Retail banking is easy and profitable. None of those banks made the mistakes that Washington Mutual, Wachovia, Merrill, Lehman, Bear made, though they inherited legacy positions from them. They all have clear, US-based strategies, that are easy to understand. I know what they do & how they plan to do it. I don't know what the short-term holds, but I do know that I made my first money when I bought BAC for $8 when I worked there (after the 1987 crash) and sold it for $100. I also know I kicked myself for not buying IBM when it was going through its problems in the early 90's. Despite what people are saying about Ken Lewis, he has proved them wrong every time, and he will prove them wrong this time. He did misstep, but sometimes, when a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity presents itself, you just have to take it.
Buy them when they're down. Their franchises are amazing. These problems will pass. FASB has been updated; the uptick rule will be reinstituted; naked shorting will be vigorously pursued. That's just my opinion, and I could be wrong. God knows I was about Lehman (never thought they'd let it go under) and it cost me. But I recover, slowly, and don't worry about day-to-day price changes.
yea I know Steve. I just like to ask you. I must admit, I bought some BAC/JPM and AIG in my SEP that I just set up a few weeks ago - not much though, only like 10K worth in total. And that account is not traded. I am going to at least attempt to have one account that is a buy and hold. I hate myself already.
But in all fairness, I started buying some shorts mid week last week that are hurtin now, so giving up some trading gains and I dont like the next few weeks ahead of me. I think BAC/JPM will KILL earnings and I think GS will show a monster quarter. Not sure why I got in front of this train, but I tend to nibble a bit early. I do think the rally will end up being a false hope and I see another wave down after that, and a retest of lows. But for now, I think market has 3-4 weeks of gains ahead of it that will surprise many. Ill wait until may to add more to these positions and get out if market does take breather next week.
All I really know is momentum trading, which is my sickness I guess. Enjoy your weekend!