Risk of using handyman for reno

if you're doing and extesive reno, it may take significantly longer than with a GC. the handyman will still have to serve other tenants in the building, at least for little things.

i had my reno done by the doorman who's a handyman. he worked 5 hours per day and took 6 mos on a 3 mos project. since i was selling my other place, i didn't mind.

Most buildings limit work to be done between about 9 am to 4 pm, Monday through Friday. I'd ask how they can do their jobs and also work for you during these hours without you having to be limited to their off-hour availability. The other question is insurance -- individuals rarely-if-ever are incorporated and carry insurance (liability and workman's comp, which are always required by coops and condos). I'd also insist on references from others in the building since this could either be a very smart way to go or else a complete nightmare. Good luck!

Repetition matters a lot in terms of one's ability to provide quality. It is one thing to be a good carpenter. It is quite another to know how to measure, correctly specify/order, and install a tempered glass shower wall. Same for glass tiles, for example--they're almost impossible to install well and you need someone who has done it a lot. Custom doors with inset panels need to be ordered? Does he understand how much they weigh and that the hardware specified has to match the weight? Will those faucets you love work on the sink you want, and which gizmos and fittings from the faucet company are needed to make the faucet work? You want door jamb light switches--has he installed those before?

The handyman may work out, but I've never heard of it for a "complete reno." They are handy, not contractors. They likely also have limited experience bidding jobs and if they underestimate the costs, you and them both will be miserable.

Renovations are a hassle, but the nightmare stories come from people who cut corners and attempt a gut reno without an architect and proper GC. It may succeed and save you some money, but the odds are against you. I do not recommend this route.