Brompton or Lucida or Harrison backouts
Started by nyc10023
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008
Discussion about
Here's my 2 cents. If you want serious negotiating power, you need to find as many of the other parties in contract as possible. It helps if you have a friend at a big brokerage, see if they'll spill the beans for you (money helps to open those broker mouths). Given the specter of having some huge percentage of their "already under contract" units put back on the market at a very bad time, Related and Extell will deal. Remember, they don't get paid until a certain % of their units close.
Or find someone at the law firm Related uses to do the contracts :)
Be creative. Dig up some paralegals or someone hurting for rent money.
If you have any press contacts, try to get written up in NYMag, NYPost, NYTimes - if you are really worried about your contract. Have them publicize your contact info.
You all might be wasting your money on attorney fees. If I was the sponsor, I would let you forfeit your deposit of 15% or whatever it is and either re-sell them or rent them out. Getting 15% is a significant amount of money which will offset any future lower valued re-sales.
And don't forget you are dealing with a large and well funded corporation here who can probably weather this ok. (not to mention they probably have a full time legal department so the incremental cost to fight this is zero.)
It's sucks but in the last several years, it was the sponsors who were on the losing end when prices were appreciating far beyond what buyers were in contract for. Companies such as the The Related honored those oontracts nonetheless (unlike some of the smaller shadier developers).
But aren't those contracts pretty bullet-proof? i.e. you are liable not only for the 15%, but for the 20% more that is due at closing? So technically the sponsor can go after you?
anon10: That's actually a fair point. In the upswing, everyone took it for granted that developers would honor contracts and now everyone finds it right to get out.
in general, we are not hearing success stories from new development buyers who are going after buildings. If your building has run more than a year late, you have a case -- but you don't have a case just because the market has dropped.
I certainly have press contacts (I'm the former real estate editor of the Post) but I don't see the story here.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
front porch...what will going to the press do? No sponsor will care and no one will feel emphathy for people buying at over $1,500 SF.
Well, you may have a story if a group of people not closing force a developer into default with its lenders. The press may not care, but the banks may care a great deal.
If the sponsor retains the buyers' 20% contract deposit, they may have enough $ to stay out of default. We aren't talking about some small time developer here. We are talking about The Related Company which is a well funded and large organization.
So was Toll Bros. (and how about Macklowe, anyone, or even perhaps Tishman?) and I'd bet they go down the toilet soon. Related was heavily involved in Florida, I have no idea what their bottom line is looking like these days.
Anyone who purchased in the Brompton sign up here: http://finance.groups.yahoo.com/group/bromptonbuyers/
We are looking to organize
I haven't purchased in the Brompton, but I have at the Rushmore...any body in my situation out there. I cannot imagine that in this change in the real estate market, also in the rental market, these developers can be so inflexible. Even if one was to walk away from a healthy deposit, wouldn't that leave that much more real estate on the market.
Why is everyone under impression that it it is that easy to walk away from the deposit? Am I missing something? Yes - in a bull mkt noone ever went for more than deposit, but we are in the totally new
territory here - is walking away even an option?
Yes, walking away is absolutely an option. The contract gives the developer an out for almost any reason. The buyer doesn't get an out, but can walk away and forfeit the deposit.
aboutready, it really sucks for the buyer, but these are issues the buyer's attorney should have addressed when negotiating the contract.
I have no sympathy for this. In good times everyone took it for granted that the buyer could pocket the gain, now they are all crying wolf and want to get their deposits back. This is not a one way street...
I don't think the standard Extell Contracts that were NOT NEGOTIABLE at the time give the buyer the right to walk away. They define "deposit" as 10% + 5% + 20%(at closing) with non-payment of that extra 20% constituting a default event, in which case they can go after you for the "extra" costs of liquidating the apartment.
Brompton is Related. Lucida is Extell. I don't know about the other. If so, Kevlar, these are unusual contracts. Brompton was a 20% deposit, not the scenario you have set out.
Uppereast, the developers weren't exactly losing money, frequently delivered homes a year late, engaged in shoddy practices. I have no sympathy for them. If your contract allows it and you choose to walk away from your deposit, as most contracts allow, that is the risk you took. The developers of Jasper could say, oops, no can do, we'll (someday) give you your deposit back. The contracts are written with almost NO safeguards for purchasers, usually the ability to walk away is one.
Sorry, wasn't clear. I agree that buyers should be able to walk abway by forfeiting their deposit. But it bothers me that people think they have a right to get their deposit back only because the market has turned.
Anyone else out there that did research on the Extell Contracts?
BDS - same situation as you. Would like to chat - how best to contact you?
Streeteasyfan...when did you you put your deposit down...when are you expected to close..Do you have a lawyer?
Also bought at rushmore, closing in a few weeks and trying to weigh in alternatives. Probably a stupid question but can one create incentives for the lawyer to re-negotiate something to help out threatening to back out, or all lawyers work on the fixed fee and just want to wrap it up with less headache?
Any attorneys out there think there is anything wrong with a developer claiming they are 95% sold out when they really weren't, in an effort to manipulate the market? In order to constantly increase the price of each new "round" of units that get released by a building, this seemed to of been a common practice amongst developers. Does a contract signer have any grounds to back out based on this? Just curious, I'm not in this situation, but I'm not sure I understand "uppereast" being bothered by people trying to get out of contracts with developers who conceivable may have contributed in a malicious way to manipulate the market.
streeteasyfan, are you at the rushmore also? And sibkan, do you want to back out or just renegotiate price? My lawyer is trying several alternatives. Are you talking about the lawyer representing the Rushmore?
bds - have a lawyer. are you have luck with the alternatives? expect to close in the early rounds.
also, yes, we bought in the rushmore. put our deposit down last year pre-meltdown. I think the Rushmore actually WANT to see people walking away from our deposits so they can put the unit up for original-deposit price.
Streeteasy, we bought in july 2007. Have the prices come down this year? I didn't know that. If so how much. We are expected to close in early rounds. Right now we are in the process of our lawyer trying to get an extention because we cannot sell our house!!!!! I will keep you informed as to what happens. Also I just wonder if we and others walk away from our deposit, who is in the wings to buy these properties. And What about the banks financing Extell?
bds - just out of curiosity - are you moving in from out of state? NY real estate have been under pressure for the past 3 quarters. Prices have come down. Sorry if I am being vague - we are in a similar situation - I have more information to share but let's take this offline - Big Brother is likely watching. Since no one is buying, I suspect the sales agents surf these sites all day. If you are interested, please post an email where I can contact you at http://wirednewyork.com/forum/showthread.php?t=12039&page=6 (so you don't have to broadcast it on this website!)
sidkan - I'm also in a similar position - offer is out to you as well to speak offline. Developers are notoriously difficult to negotiate - we would have more bargaining power as a group. One drop out means nothing, but two, three, four...
bds and sidkan - i created a gmail address for us to talk about the Rushmore - please email me if you want to talk about our situation. sorry for the runaround earlier - I should have thought of this..
rushmoreresidents@gmail.com
Sibkan, please respond to Streeteasy.com She is very informed about the Rushmore....BDS
Any Lucida buyers here?
Brompton Buyers: http://finance.groups.yahoo.com/group/bromptonbuyers/