Predicting 60% Decline for Manhattan Property; TARP for Trump?
Started by McHale
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 399
Member since: Oct 2008
Discussion about
Predicting 60% Decline for Manhattan Property; TARP for Trump? by: Nick Gogerty February 04, 2009 Nick Gogerty Add to Your WatchlistAbout this author: * Profile & More Articles * Visit Nick's site: Designing Better Futures Become a Contributor Submit an Article back to yahoo finance add to my yahoo back to cake * Font Size: * Print * Email * TweetThis A very effective guide for long term home... [more]
Predicting 60% Decline for Manhattan Property; TARP for Trump? by: Nick Gogerty February 04, 2009 Nick Gogerty Add to Your WatchlistAbout this author: * Profile & More Articles * Visit Nick's site: Designing Better Futures Become a Contributor Submit an Article back to yahoo finance add to my yahoo back to cake * Font Size: * Print * Email * TweetThis A very effective guide for long term home values is actually median home price to income. Houses actually don’t gain in value over the long haul. Urban density and usage shifts can dramatically change the value of real-estate, but outside of that real estate is just a flat asset. Here is an academic paper showing the value of prime real estate in Amsterdam over a 400 year period, it's a break even proposition. A home is only worth what people can afford to pay for it. If you can squeeze more people onto a given area of land and create more homes then you can maximize the value of the land such as in Manhattan over the last few decades. Over time the utility function of real estate is scarcity relative to the available income of those seeking the homes. I mention this relative to an article posted in June 2007 which anticipated a 20% nationwide property decline using this metric. Historically relative to growth and all things being equal, homes are worth about 3 times the median income of a household. Please note this includes adjustments for cultural shifts in 2 income households over time. Economists see real estate more as a positional scarce good. Housing capital with a life of 50 years for example has a replacement rate of 2% year. If a housing market starts growing beyond that rate and the increased population something fishy is going on. Securitization magic anyone? The U.S. grand daddy real estate market is the metropolitan New York area which has been relatively immune to decline. The excuses for why New York real estate is special equates to the number of residents in the city. Unfortunately the quantity isn't equitable to quality. Because people want to believe they are special they parrot messages they have heard to that effect. Such ethnocentric or industry centric myopia is the nectar for those wonderful bubbles that pop up every 10-20 years. According to the BEA, the MSA metropolitan statistical area known as “New York-Northern New Jersey-Long Island, NY-NJ-PA” has an average per capita income of $53,428 as of 2007. If one assumes 1.8 wage earners per household we end up with a household income of $96,170. Using the crude 3:1 rule of thumb, housing should be priced at $288,510. The reality according to Realtor for Q3 2008 is at $452,500 per home. Reversion to the mean indicates a 36% decline is reasonable to expect. Sadly the decline in financial jobs which ballooned to a ridiculous percentage of S&P 500 earnings means a drop of %50 from peak to trough is not unimaginable in the New York MSA. The same figures if plotted for Manhattan are even worse as the distortions of increasing density and influx of high flying finance jobs which was a positive force for property values is now going to go in reverse with a multiplier effect. Predicting peak to trough declines of 60% does not seem egregious, especially when one considers the shift in desirability for certain neighborhoods as services diminish and vacancies increase. The tide of hip, cool or gentrified that crested after the Starbucks (SBUX) arrived on the corner is now ebbing rapidly. The city has a 23% poverty rate. Grande Latte soy mochaccino anyone? Although dangerous, to put a number and a date to an opinion, my guess is a 60% peak to trough decline in 12-16 months for Manhattan residential property. As things decline rapidly in the metro area. We are all living faster now, still not sure what the rush is about, but we if we keep those Blackberry's and i-phones humming we feel connected and thus must be winning. The only caveat I put on this prediction is please keep it in nominal terms as the printing presses are humming at the fed. Oh and if you liked paying for bankers bonuses you’ll love the catch phrase “TARP for Trump!” Related Articles * M/I Homes, Inc. Q4 2008 Earnings Call Transcript Feb 05, 2009 * AvalonBay Communities, Inc. Q4 2008 Earnings Call Transcript Feb 05, 2009 * Essex Property Trust Q4 2008 Earnings Call Transcript Feb 05, 2009 * Equity Residential Q4 2008 Earnings Call Transcript Feb 05, 2009 * Regency Centers Q4 2008 Earnings Call Transcript Feb 05, 2009 Free E-Newsletters Wall Street Breakfast The Macro View Investment Ideas Jim Cramer's Picks We don't spam This article has 8 comments: Register or Login to rate comments » * o constructe o 596 Comments o Feb 04 02:51 AM Very good point. A house is an asset you get utility out of, living, not a money machine. As for prime property real estate in big cities, you can't really value it off mean income like others because it is often gentrified wealthy people swapping properties. They could make 0 and still buy you out 7x over (Wall Street quote). That doesn't mean to say, as their paper wealth vaporizes they won't be stiff lipped about the next house they swap down to. I'm with you on the value of real estate still declining. Especially areas laden with laid off bankers. I just think it won't be as extreme as you are implying. [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
17 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
12 Comments
-
1 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
The important variable is how much income city residents have in 5 years. Even if folks don't leave in droves (which is being suggesting in some articles on middle class), how much will these people be taking home?
That is going to determine what the housing is "worth"...
Well it's income as well as access to credit. The current long-range forecast is way down on both fronts.
true... but access to credit will never be as high as it was.... so that just means more downside risk...