Skip Navigation

How vulnerable is nyc?

Started by scoots
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 327
Member since: Jan 2009
Discussion about
Anyone have any opinions on the state of the nyc real estate market versus the rest of the country? My own thought is that - while Wall Street has driven much of the upside and will therefore drive prices down now - I personally don't know of any speculators here. In my experience, I haven't witnessed the rash speculation/over-leveraging that has happened in much of the rest of the country and... [more]
Response by Topper
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1335
Member since: May 2008

Seems to me there is a ton of new construction going on.

Those builders effectively own lots of unsold apartments with lots of leverage.

Isn't that speculation?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by serge07
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 334
Member since: Aug 2008

Sure there was. Lots of investment flows in commercial & residential by Europeans, the British & Russians, Private equity funds were also very much involved in Manhattan RE investments. There were also pools of cash set up by individuals for the purpose of buying in pre-construction deals and flipping when completed.

There also wasn't much speculation in the 1980s, until the Japanese investors started to liquidate.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kspeak
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 813
Member since: Aug 2008

It's true NYC didn't have what Miami did in that Miami and Vegas had way more condos being built than people to live in them. What New York did have driving the market for the past5-10 years was two buyer groups whose purchasing power has dramatically declined: 1) Wall Street buyers and 2) Foreign buyers

It's true many of the Wall Street buyers bought co-ops and had to show substantial income and assets to buy their places - and in the context of 2005-2007 they may have looked very secure. But many of those making $1 million 2 years ago are making their base nominal bonus now. Some lost their jobs entirely.
Most people on Wall Street make a relatively modest base - $100k - $300k. This is a lot compared to the rest of world, but doesn't get far in the world of multimillion dollar apartments. So that bonus being down 50% (which was basically best case next year) -100% down (true in many cases) is a real blow, almost as bad as being unemployed. Given the number of hedge fund redemptions and investment bank mergers, these people will not find jobs easily. There are structural problems in many of these businesses, so much of which were fueled by easy credit and a strategy of borrowing at 3% and investing at 8%. Not all jobs are gone forever - and some business will recover - but there are serious problems with many.

Oh, but most co-ops require you to have significant liquidity in the bank. True, but what if this liquidity was invested in the broader stock market, or, worse yet, Lehman stock? Even if it was sitting in cash, the cash reserves burn up quickly with a couple of kids in private schools. Many of these buyers will be forced to sell - if not now, then in a year or two. I do think it will take a while to shake out though.

Foreign buyers are struggling themselves - and exchange rates are unfavorable now. The pound has come down more than 35% against the dollar. This makes ones purchasing power go down and one's carrying costs go up.

Combine this with the development of new condos lesser access to credit. It's not pretty.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by newbieNY
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 58
Member since: May 2008

You also have to remember that the housing bubble persisted in NY for 18 months longer than it did anywhere else in the country. That means a longer period of irrational escalation, which, ceteris parabis, would mean a sharper decline.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment