Co-Op Financials
Started by mjiam
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12
Member since: Jan 2009
Discussion about
I've looked at the financial statements from a Co-op where I'm considering buying and was hoping for some thoughts on what any of you have seen in terms of basic balance sheet health? Are there "rule-of-thumb" reserve coverage ratios relative to annual op-ex? Cap ex? They show 2 years of operating losses, de minimus the first year, and somewhat alarming (10% of operating budget) in year 2 that I fully expect will require higher maint in the next year but I'm wondering if all boards respond to deficits with higher spending (maint fees) or do they ever cut costs? Any insights/thoughts would be appreciated
in addition to the first two years of financials, you can review the building minutes. I would go back 5 or 7 years and look for the rate of maint. increases. also -- assessments -- etc. The financials are not very useful as they try to breakeven. most proprietary leases mandate that a coop charge maint to assess ongoing op expenses and assess for large purchases.flip taxes are usually for capex -- the real key is to assess how much teh building is at risk -- ie -- 50% down -- more equity built. Undrawn lines of credit? Bloomberg just boosted taxes on rela estate.
The financials have to be looked at in conjunction with the board minutes. Still, a deficit is not "normal" and there are not often ways to make it up other than to raise maintenance. Options are limited. Eliminate amenities (but if all you have is a doorman, what are you going to cut?); create more income via storage units and the like (that won't get you too much income); raise the flip tax (more than 2% is considered high--at least in the past...we'll see in the emerging markets); refinance the underlying building debt; raise maintenance. That's about it. Unless the coop wants to borrow more money to make up a deficit (not sound), or dip into reserves (not sound).
How big is the building (# of units)?
Thanks. The building has ~100 units and already is generating incremental income through the streams you mentioned and a few others. Their reserve fund is held in low-yielding money-mkt funds and low-yielding CD's, but those CD's will roll at lower rates, denting a decent % of the operating revenues. Frankly, it's not an inspiring set of financials but I just wanted to get a better sense of what is considered acceptable before moving forward
You can read the "Staying within limits" you may find it helpful.
http://books.google.com/books?id=wPNMU8mdSZQC&pg=PA54&lpg=PA54&dq=co-op+financials+run+a+deficit&source=web&ots=5Bns2136tj&sig=Wi3OFH_RlU4YsUgL4g9Tx_jzjYM&hl=en&ei=2HiRSd-iA5jAtgeI67DYCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=5&ct=result
What is the reserve fund? Are there upcoming capital improvements needed (e.g., roof, elevators, lobby, hallways, furnace, sidewalk vault, facade work, windows)? The absolute minimum reserve should be about $300,000. I'd be a lot more comfortable with $500,000 for a 100 unit building without knowing more.