question for anyone....
Started by jenny9823
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 89
Member since: Dec 2006
Discussion about
why do you think inventory continues to go up - close to 10k at least... and # of reductions and # of price reductions and # of new listings continue to go down.. is it because sellers are reluctant to move on price as new listings are coming at more "reasonable" levels? that still doesnt explain why there are fewer new listings put out...
new listings really come down that much? price reductions may have slowed but that's only because so many price cuts happened in the past 2 months. people don't chop prices on their apartments every 2 weeks it doesn't get sold. you can't read these things too week to week. there are many forces at play here. first of all, there have been a ton of new listings in the past 30 days, about 1900 or so. you call that going down? that's about 20% of the housing stock added in 1 month! the only reason inventory is not even higher is because many people are taking their listings off the market. as many people took it off the market going into the holiday period, there are many listings that have been on the market for quite some time and they are probably de-listing to wait the rest of winter out and re-list in a couple months for the spring selling season. that way, their listing looks "fresh."
i heard somewhere that on streeteasy (and certainly could also be the case on other major websites) that if you take your listing off the market for a certain period of time (i think 3 months in the case of streeteasy) that you actually get listed as a whole new listing and not as a re-listing of an old listing. not sure if that is true though...
by the way, i expect that when march rolls around we are going to see a huge inventory spike. what many de-listers don't realize is that the spring selling season is going to be even worse than trying to sell now because inventory will probably be in the 12-13,000 range by then.
jenny,
look at his six month chart--it is a lot more informative than the one month version i think you are looking it. here's what it shows: new listings and price cuts have fluctuated wildly, while contracts signed has basically trended downward and stayed pretty stable with much smaller fluctuations. in any given week the number of new listings or price cuts fluctuates pretty wildly, but no trend has been established. there were a lot of new listings in september october and november, then few in december, then a lot in january, now fewer in february...it comes and goes. same with price cuts.
inventory rises because, as you can see from the charts, we have had far more new listings than contract signings at every single point in the last six months. so as long as there are more new listings than contract signings + apartments removed from the market, inventory goes up. and that's what is happening.
in a bear market you actually expect the number of new listings to fall sharply even as inventory continues to rise--that is normal. look at the art market--also in a severe bear market right now. the number of paintings put up for auction has fallen significantly. why? because people who don't need to sell are not selling. the market is reverting to reliance on the three d's: death, divorce, and debt. so new listings can decline and inventory can still rise dramatically.
Partly, it is January effect leading to more inventory.
Many people refuse to actually look at the market. They remember that one sale from '07 and believe that is what their place is worth. Maybe they'll get the picture after not getting any offers this spring.
SpecialK..."people don't chop prices on their apartments every 2 weeks" ... This one is pretty close :)
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/350038-coop-201-east-66th-street-lenox-hill-new-york
05/07/2008 Previously listed in StreetEasy by Metropolis R.E. for $800,000
09/10/2008 Metropolis R.E. listing unavailable at $650,000
09/18/2008 Listed in StreetEasy by Elliman at $650,000
10/06/2008 Price decreased to $625,000
10/14/2008 Price decreased to $610,000
10/21/2008 Price decreased to $600,000
11/17/2008 Price decreased to $595,000
12/05/2008 Price decreased to $575,000
12/11/2008 Price decreased to $550,000
02/10/2009 Price increased to $575,000
I also think what the listing price is and what the negotiated price/closing sale price is very different.
looking2, touche! i also just checked on urbandigs and 30 day cumulative price cuts is 2300. certainly some of those are the same apartment cutting twice, but still, that seems like VERY heavy cutting to me.
Happyrenter. thanks. that makes sense, but even looking at the six month chart looks like there has been a dramatic decrease in new listings and price cuts since January. Probably just the volatility in this market, but guess we need to wait a couple months and see where the data begins to normalize at.