House of Cards
Started by new2ny
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 38
Member since: Jul 2008
Discussion about
David Faber of CNBC just had a two hour show on how this market mess happened. If anyone else saw this could they comment on how this will effect the NYC housing market. It seems like prices will come down and average people will be able to buy a house. It sure makes one mad how all this took place.
This was an excellent documentary very sobering. Makes me very angry at all the warning signs and greed that took place in the mortgage industry.
I love how the "financial engineer" for bear sterns came up with all these CDO products you need a PhD to understand - even Alan Greenspan couldnt understand the products wall st was selling - yet he had the nerve to not admit they werent a sham and that people should have understood them. No the phD in math heading the risk mgmt dept of Bear Sterns is doing photography full time.
“You can tell whether a man is clever by his answers. You can tell whether a man is wise by his questions.”
Thanks for the heads up. Watching it now.
GREAT show. Very sad. Greenspan's last lines were telling.
it was quite interesting. greenspan is going down in history as a disaster--another one of the great gifts bequeathed to us by ronald reagan. the villainizzed carter gave us paul volker, probably the most successful chairman in the history of the fed.
as for implications on nyc housing, isn't it pretty obvious? housing prices are declining.
HR: I think credit for Volcker should probably go to Nixon, though you're right about the timing of his ascent to the chairmanship.
Now you know where the bonuses came from, & why they're not coming back. Fraud, and leverage.
The American dream is - privatize profits, nationalize loses.
That was an excellent special. My favorite are the small infomercials from Quick Loan Funding. Image getting a check for $40K in only a week and with no documentation that you can even pay it back. It seems ridiculous but it happened!
great documentary. It really touched on the true culprits while mentioning pretty much everyone involved. It would have been good to have not made Kyle Bass, and others who took out the credit default swaps into such big heroes though. Also, Greenspan's ending quote made him go down as completely naive to the end. He justified doing nothing by citing human nature! THat's exactly why we can and should do things to have prevented this - we know human nature and that it doesn't change and is predictable.
Anyone know when it repeats?
Also, in the doc (paraphrasing) "the main American export over the last decade was risky debt to Asian countries."
I warned all of you for years.....
Alan Greenspan couldn't understand the products wall st was selling and he said he has 100 of the smartest economists he consulted with in his department.....scary. They are right they need to pay billions of dollars in bonuses to retain the assholes who wrote these derivatives when they were high on LSD and psychedelics.
"Anyone know when it repeats?"
Saturday (Valentine's Day) from 7-9pm and again from 10pm-12.
Prices for Manhattan residential real estate will continue to decline until the following set of fundamentals are in place:
1) The cost of owning is equal to or cheaper than renting.
2) Unemployment has stabilized, and people begin buying units that they can afford based upon a minimum of 20% down, and that may go as high as 30-35% for the norm.
3) All of the excess inventory has been converted to rentals or unloaded for a very steep discount and loss.
4) The quality of life either does not erode too much, or if it does erode, returns to a level of acceptability for people to want to return.
As of now, these dynamics have not even started to unwind, and when you consider the caps on Exec pay in the "stimulus" bill, one can see further downward pressure on prices form Manhattan real estate. It will take years for this to play out, although I suspect that in the next 12 months we will see a race to the bottom as more and more unemployed or underemployed people sell their apartments. Watch the Hamptons as a barometer of this for houses in the 2-5 mil range. They were bought with new money and they are going to be coming down in prices fast and hard.
mh23 I agree with you on #1 for 80% of the population, but the top 20% I think will want a bit of the stability and privilege of ownership.
mh23, I agree with you, you are talking sense. BUT -- everything you say assumes a sort of rational unwinding of the current situation. And I wonder -- perhaps things will occur more chaotically, perhaps it will all be a big mess for a long long time.
It is something of a mess right now in residential re in NYC. Prices are down here and there, yet in truth neither sellers nor buyers know where to set the price.
It seems certain that some residential products will decline in value, but at the same time it's not entirely clear WHICH products will decline, or by how much -- will it be new construction condos? Will it be freestanding houses (which inflated enormously)? Will it be co-ops, which are harder to get into than condos?
It's a very big, irrational, complex mess. I suspect it won't sort itself out for another two to three years at least. And by then, we'll know more about whether the economy is going to stabilize in the near-term (or not).
It may be that this rational scenario you have mapped out for New York, where the cost of owning is equal to or less than renting -- this rational scenario may never come back, or at least it may not come back for many many many years.
But I hope I'm wrong.
This was indeed a very good and disturbing documentary. I thought David Farber was excellent. My only question, and it really is a question, is about the quality of CNBC's own reporting in the year's leading up to the crisis? I was living abroad for the last three years and didn't watch CNBC at the time. I remember during the DotCom boom that CNBC was pretty solidly part of the euphoria in the collapse came and wonder if it was similar this time around.
does anyone have a link to video?
http://www.cnbc.com/id/28892719
Show times and clips