Skip Navigation

Is it legal for a seller to offer to pay a percentage of the maintenance?

Started by 407PAS
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1289
Member since: Sep 2008
Discussion about
I have seen ads where the sellers offers to pay 30% of the maintenance for one or two years. Is this legit? To me, it looks like kickback that will obscure the true price from appearing in the database. The price is forever, the maintenance subsidy is temporary. What do people think?
Response by goldfish
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 13
Member since: May 2007

Welcome to New York "Real Estate"...
At least what you saw was open & disclosed. Usually it's not. Those type of deals often happen in some dank lawyers office and never see the light of day.

Is it Legit? Depends who you ask. But your assumptions are valid. One has to wonder why the seller simply doesn't lower the price by the amount offered as a kickback?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Topper
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1335
Member since: May 2008

Sounds reasonable to me.

In the words of economists, people have different "utility functions."

Some people find the idea of a lower maintenance charge particularly intriguing for whatever reason. Perhaps their cash flow would otherwise be inadequate for the first couple of years and they're confident they'll get a nice salary increase in year three. Whatever. Seems to me it part of the "art of the deal."

I can buy a car at a certain price for "cash." If I take out a 0% interest rate loan through the dealer the price might well be different.

It doesn't do much for me and I'd be looking at this based upon a present value analysis - but it works for others.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by julia
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2841
Member since: Feb 2007

i wouldn't trust the seller to follow through...it's like alimony what are you going to do if they don't pay. I'd rather it come off the price of the apartment.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by tina24hour
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 720
Member since: Jun 2008

You can ask that the 2 yrs maintenance be placed into (and paid out of) an escrow account. That way the seller can't rescind.

But to answer your question, yes. A seller offers to pay the maintenance to keep the sale price higher. Sometimes this is because the co-op is more likely to approve the sale at the higher number, as it will help with comp sales. Before everyone screams about this, please note that a co-op is a business and will act as one. Yes, prices are in decline, but a co-op will do what it can to protect its investors. As long as the sale goes through, the sellers are not truly injured by this policy, and can offer to pay the maintenance in lieu of a price drop. But it does NOT benefit the seller. A reduction in price would reduce the seller's tax burden and broker's fees and flip tax , etc.. So chances are it's the result of outside pressure.

As a buyer, there are several benefits to this scenario. First of all, it can ease the monthly cash flow, which can be especially tight in the first two years after a home purchase (those opportunity costs are massive, as we are frequently reminded on this board). And if the bulk of your home purchase is financed, you pay only 20-25% of the "value" of the maintenance escrow upfront, and get the tax benefits for the mortgage interest you pay.

I'm a bit geeky, so I tend to make spreadsheets for my clients to show them the costs/benefits of various buying and selling scenarios. There is often a "magic number" at which everything makes sense. The sellers the OP cites may be trying to arrive at that number using slightly unconventional means - but that's the beauty of this economy. People innovate. I applaud it - there are buyers out there who will, too.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kylewest
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 4455
Member since: Aug 2007

It is perfectly legal. Buyer and seller and contract for any type of arrangement they like for the most part if the coop board approves of it. The deal would be 100% unacceptable in my view, however, unless the maintenance funds were placed in escrow.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by unrealestate
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12
Member since: Nov 2008

Why incur time & expense using an escrow account? Why not have the seller pay the Co-op at closing?
Then you have a prepaid Credit in your account, which the co-op will deplete over time. Wouldn't the Co-op prefer this too?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by 407PAS
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1289
Member since: Sep 2008

Thanks for all of the responses. I wonder what my lawyer would say, as well as the board. Interesting questions. I would tend to think that buyers would rather deal with one number and not two, but maybe there is some magic number where both parties could come to agreement, as tina24hour mentioned. As unrealestate said, what is the point of an escrow account, two years paid to the coop should be fine. That would make the board more agreeable to the deal, I would think.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by notadmin
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 3835
Member since: Jul 2008

"Sounds reasonable to me."

i'd ask the seller to discount the price by exactly that same amount. why overpaying? that seller is willing to make that payments should be willing to lower the price.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by tina24hour
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 720
Member since: Jun 2008

admin - are you an employee of streeteasy? Or is admin just your login?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by 407PAS
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1289
Member since: Sep 2008

I am pretty sure that admin is not the admin. I think the streeteasy user name is the admin, but this could be just another one of those tricks in the StreetEasy hall of mirrors.

Anyway, sure, I think it makes more sense to just fix one number, price, and let it go at that. I consider the maintenance rebate to be kind of a gimmick and I don't like playing games. I was just asking because I have seen this sales technique mentioned in some listings, rarely, I might add.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nycjunior1
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 192
Member since: Dec 2008

It's very common. Just have it in the contract that the seller pays you that amount at closing. It's basically no different from a price reduction. Of course, the buyer could choose to not spend that money on the maint, and just buy lotto tickets...

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment