RE tax different on two identical condo apartments ?
Started by renovice
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 55
Member since: Feb 2009
Discussion about
Is this possible two apartments in the same condo, same line to have different RE taxes? If so why? and is it possible for the owner paying more to do something?
How can the two apartments be identical. Aren't they on different floors? different view?
ok - *almost* identical, the point being they are same sq.f. in the same building
Check out their histories at NYC Finance's web site. Maybe one owner disputed the assessed value and got a reduction.
Different floors have different intrinsic values, so the taxes SHOULD be different (unlike common charges, which assume the same costs psf). Are the taxes radically different? What are the two floors in question? Are the views very different?
alanhart -- in my former coops -- both re tax and maint are assessed prportional to shares -- the more sq footage, hiher floor, better views, the higher the shares.
Yes, coops use number of shares to divide the costs that are basically the same psf (heat, service, water, cleaning, capital replacement) and the one that's not (RE taxes, which the corporation receives based [in theory, anyway] on the building's total portfolio of floors, views, layouts, etc.), so number of shares vary front the start.
In a condo, these two categories are separate, so the number of shares (thus common charges) are the same for each line, but the taxes assessed by the city have nothing to do with that. It is [in theory, anyway] similar to nearby and identical suburban tract houses, one facing a freeway and the other a lake . . . the lakefront one will be taxed higher.
Re: allocation of common charges (percentage of common interest) in a condo, the method varies by building. In some each apt in the line has the same PCI, and in others the PCI increases slightly by floor. Check the condo declaration for the particular building. But, as alanhart said, that's nothing to do with taxes, except to the extent the city used the same criteria when assessing value as the sponsor used in allocating PCI.
so if two apt (sameline) have same condo CC, they can still have different RET ?
Yes. If, say, 12A gets its assessed valuation reduced, the city's not going to automatically adjust 11A and 13A. It's up to those two owners to monitor other apartments' taxes and try to get similar reductions. That's what public records are for.
Yes, NWT may well be right about the assessment-challenge history.
But also even without reassessment, apartment 4A, facing the 5-story tenement next door, will have a lower tax assessment than apartment 22A, which clears that building and has river views.
thanks NWT, where can one check the public records for a property? somewhere on the ACRIS website?
From ACRIS, go sideways to Property -> Valuation/Assessment -> View Individual Assessment Value Information.
Also, depends on the owner, some people in sertain categories can get tax deductions, terefore pay less tax/month. It doesn't mean though that new buyer will get their benefits.
elena
(broker)