chicken or the egg? the coop buyers dilemma
Started by patient09
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1571
Member since: Nov 2008
Discussion about
Wow, with all that we are aware of regarding coop's potential financial issues, who is the riskier party? The new buyer?, or the existing shareholders?. Will this market get to the point where a new buyer says, "I would love to buy, but I want current financials on all the existing shareholders before I make my final decision" Could a Board get so desperate for a financially sound new partner they would agree to this?. Do any all cash, deep pocket, new buyers have the stones to demand this?
Does the buyers RE lawyer have access to financial profiles of existing shareholders? Especially for smaller unit co-ops (less than 20)
I don't see how this would be feasible for the following reasons:
(1) shareholders provide their financaial info to the board when being considered to purchase. This reflects their financial standing AT THAT POINT IN TIME, which could have been years ago and would be irrelevant today.
(2) After the coop board renders its decision on the prospective buyer, financial info is typically (or at least should be) destroyed or returned to the shareholder, due to the confidential nature.
(3) Requesting the latest financial info for each shearholder IN ADDITION to the coops financials would be an arduous, time consuming task, and I doubt many would be willing to provide their credit scores, bank statements, etc. After all, would you?
(4) On that note, my building has about 250 units. Would you be willing to sort through that many sets of financials?
So that said, it begs the question, how do you know?
Well, look for these signs:
How strict is the board when requiring financial info? i.e. 2 yrs liquidity? at least 20% down? do they allow risky mortgages? Or are they flexible on these points? And for how long have they had these requirements?
Is there a limit to how many units each shareholder may own? The less concentrated the ownership the better.
How are the building's financials? Cash reserve?
Does the building prefer shareholders who have a more steady stream of income vs. one who may have a large sum of assets w variable income? For example, someone who earns a large base salary vs. a teacher w a trust fund or a wall st broker whose annual pay is variable.
When you interview w the board, what are the people like - professional? Do they seem to have a grasp of how to manage a building from a financial perspective?
Honestly, I'm a NYer, a Manhattan-ite. So I'll go with the chicken. The chances of me letting the egg grow into a chicken, blah blah blah, I'm not a farmer. Did I say I was a NYer?
Uptowngal,
Good info, but what if you only find out this info during the board interview (i.e lawyer says things look good, but during the interview things seem very different)..
Its a shame theres no get out clause for the buyer at that point
patient09: I'm sure you're kidding about asking for detailed financial information about each shareholder, but I think your general point is completely valid. A coop might be the only type of corporation in which we would ever invest with little or no transparency; it's certainly the only type to which we would divulge our own financials as a condition of the Board allowing us to invest.
I think it would be much more politic to do one's own research based on public records. If you see a lot of miscellaneous liens, several Madoff client matches and a high concentration of CMBS MDs or hedge fund types who purchased after 2004, there's probably a lot of risk.
Still, I suppose a truly brazen bidder could request certain pertinent data at a summary level, e.g.:
1) Whether the Board currently has any claims pending against shareholders, and if so, the number of shares affected.
2) Whether any shareholders are currently more than 30 days in arrears on maintenance, and the number of shares affected.
3) Whether the Board has received/approved any requests that involved waivers of shareholder obligations for financial hardship (for example, requests for payment plans), and the number of shares affected.
4) How much the Board has reserved to cover arrears of delinquient shareholders, or to pursue claims against shareholders.
I don't see the need to antagonize your future neighbors. Just hire a good investigator, or do it yourself.
Excellent points as always, 81. Thanx!
West81St's list of info to obtain is very sound and I'd expect no less be learned from the due diligence process. Board minutes, financials, treasurer's reports should reflect number of units in arrears, legal actions pending, waivers granted or applied for. If the minutes are silent on these issues then I would have my attorney submit a written request for answers to these questions, and unless answers were provided, I'd walk away without signing a contract. These are fundamental indicators of the building's financial condition and health as a corporation and a prospective shareholder owes it to herself to have this information. A board omitting this type of very basic info from the minutes would not inspire confidence in my. It crosses from lack of transparency to secrecy. Without this info, aside from a prospective buyer being unable to assess the coop, future boards will have not even a basic historical record to refer back to if needed.
West81st's ideas make a lot of sense.
Here's what I will put forth: there are co-ops out there that are currently in bad financial shape. We don't necessarily know which co-ops these are. But I am certain that, at some point in the relatively near future, a story will come out about a prospective all-cash buyer who says to the co-op board: "listen: I am presenting you with an all cash offer contingent upon you opening your books to me. Take it or leave it."
This may not happen frequently going forward (though I would be surprised if that were the case), and it won't happen at the highest end co-ops, but it will happen somewhere.
kylewest, "A board omitting this type of very basic info from the minutes would not inspire confidence.."
True, but many boards purposely hold back on producig detailed minutes because they don't want to open themselves up to lawsuits. To get around that, I agree, a good RE attorney will know which questions to ask during the due dilligence, and provide these in writing.