Skip Navigation

Implications of the housing crash for late baby boomers, many will hope they had rented

Started by notadmin
over 17 years ago
Posts: 3835
Member since: Jul 2008
Discussion about
"Finally, the projections show that the renters within the same wealth quintiles in 2004 will have more wealth in 2009 than homeowners in all three scenarios. In the second and third scenarios, the renters will have dramatically more wealth in 2009 than the homeowners who started in the same wealth quintile. Homeownership is not everywhere and always an effective way to accumulate wealth. For... [more]
Response by type3secretion
over 17 years ago
Posts: 281
Member since: Jun 2008

This is a very sobering assessment. Are there no comments from the RE Bulls to debunk this analysis?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by budda
over 17 years ago
Posts: 69
Member since: Jan 2009

When people overpay to buy 3 times more than the rental cost, what do you think happens to their money. They should have rented and bought muni-bonds or treasuries.

Its buy cheap and sell dear. These people bought dear, and many will likely sell cheap when their income doesn't support their "investment".

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jklfdsainkj
over 17 years ago
Posts: 178
Member since: Nov 2008

The short term market price of a house bought and paid for and lived in until one dies does not matter. Housing is a place to live and a form of consumption, not an investment, since one has to live somewhere.

If a boomer thought a house was an investment, and didn't invest elsewhere, that is their problem.

Owning is better than renting, because the mortgage gets paid off and rent is forever.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by mike_s55
over 17 years ago
Posts: 66
Member since: Dec 2005

This is retarded. Baby boomers should at this point have no mortgage on their home therefore $0 out of pocket cost a month excluding taxes. If you were a baby boomer and rented your entire life this would totally not be the case.

Slice it and dice it all you want but I would much rather have $0 cost of living excluding taxes vs renting any day of the week. For the majority of home ownership history - perhaps excluding the last few years it ALWAYS makes sense to buy.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10023
over 17 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008

This is not a new thing. Demographers have been forecasting this, oh, since about the early 90s. If you had bet on it then, you would have been dead wrong and way poorer. There's a famous book about this - I forget the name... Basically, the premise is that the early boomers and the slightly earlier pre-boomers (born late 30s and during the war) made out like bandits. They were the top of the pyramid, got in the job hierarchy and had the ranks expand beneath them. They would have bought in the depressed market of late 60s and early 70s, retired just before the stock market crash and have paid off their mortgages and put their kids through school. The late boomers, another story - they will all head towards the exit right around the same time at the same time that the Gen. X (baby bust generation) are moving through the ranks but are way thinner in numbers, too few to support the giant Ponzi scheme of public pensions and medical benefits as well as to buy all the houses now on the market as the late boomers downsize. Ditto for the stock market as the mid-late baby boomers exit those markets at the same time.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10023
over 17 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008

The book is called "The Pig and the Python"

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by budda
over 17 years ago
Posts: 69
Member since: Jan 2009

Happy owner and Mike_s:

If you buy for cash, you still have to pay maintenance and cc. That is now about $2 psf (per month) in a doorman building with staff. If you rent the same apartment, you pay about $4 to $5 psf. So your return on your $1500 psf cash outlay is $48 to $60 per year, i.e. 2.5% to 3%. The remainder of the mortgage amortization is just forced savings of 3.3% per year over a 30 year period. So for most people who bought over the last 5 years, you are financing at 6 to 8% an asset that returns 2.5% to 3%, with a little bit of forced savings. To me, that is a net looser unless property appreciates. Well, it depreciated over the past 2 years and will likely depreciate more.

The only thing that you get for buying is the intangible: I own this home and it is mine. You also get the intangible: I'm stuck in this home and its a real pain to sell if I ever want/need to move and it has this financial implication that it might go up or down in price. With it you get the tangible that you are paying twice as much to live in the purchased home at today's prices as renting, and if you are taking a mortgage out, you are loosing savings you could have had by renting to place into investment, and are instead paying off what is a negative present value investment with your excess disposable income. Until prices come back into equilibrium with rents and cap rates on equivalent investments, financially it doesn't make sense to buy, or to continue to own. It makes sense to sell and park your proceeds into something that covers your rent appreciation (NE Apartment REITs or NYS/NYC munibonds). Either your REITs will appreciate or your rent will stay low. Take the excess savings and invest them in other diversified instruments that have good expected returns over your investment time horizon. That's a plan.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by budda
over 17 years ago
Posts: 69
Member since: Jan 2009

Sorry, correction to above math:

Your return is the difference between the $2 psf maintenance/cc and the $4 to $5 rent over the cash outlay. So that is $24 to $36 per year, or 1.8% to 2.2% doing the math in my head. Compare that to your 5% mortgage or your alternative 9 to 10% REIT, or your 4.5% NYS/NYC muni-bond. Buying now is just spending wealth for an intangible "I own my apartment". People do this, but it is not economically rational as one can create the same investment profile and end up with excess cash by renting and investing the down payment (or principal in the case of an all cash buyer). Its not even close.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by RioS
over 17 years ago
Posts: 8
Member since: Feb 2009

Budda -- thanks for your comments. I am completely torn about whether to buy or not. I was thinking of getting in late this year but am now reconsidering whether or not its ever really worth it. I have a question about your 9 or 10% return on REITS -- is that accurate given today's markets?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by alpine292
over 17 years ago
Posts: 2771
Member since: Jun 2008

A lot (if not most) baby boomers do not have mortgages, so I would be skeptical as to whether renters will truly be better off than them. Also, homeowners who bought many years ago will ALWAYS be better off than renters since their monthly bills are very low, even if they have a mortgage.

My grandma owns a 2 family house in Brooklyn. The property taxes are $4,500 and the rental income from her tenant is about $14,000 a year. She bought the house for $55,000 in 81 for cash. Who is better off: Her or a renter?

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment