Giving good speeches is not enough
Started by metalhead
over 17 years ago
Posts: 69
Member since: Feb 2009
Discussion about
Once again, the market tanked after Obama spoke on the economy. Traders and investors have no confidence in Obama's giant pork bill nor his leadership on the economy. They are reacting to Obama's massive tax hikes and anti-business policies, such as enacting a 0.25% tax on all securities transactions. My wall street friends who voted for Obama are now deeply regretting their decision.
The market tanked because the auto industry is going under, AIG is posting a $60 billion loss, Eastern/Central Europe is about to make our subprime mess look tame, potentially taking down Europe as well, and US manufacturing and employment is falling off a cliff.
McCain/Palin would have done what, exactly? And those tax increases are necessary why? What has business, including Wall Street, done for your Wall Street friends recently? Fucked the economy from here to Tibet. The Republicans killed the stimulus bill by hugely reducing the amounts available for countercyclical spending to states.
I was pleased to believe that metalhead was banned for his spamming and slopinions. Nobody, not even rufus, more consistently started as many wildly off-topic threads as he did.
Most offensive (or a blessing) is that he starts a thread and never returns to counter-comment -- implying that he visits countless boards and blogs and pastes just to post the current day's drivel-points.
report abuse link clicked.
Sorry for responding to the troll. Bad day, stress, lost it for a minute there.
metalhead, who are you talking to? Nobody is really interested in reading any of this.
Why can't you take this discussion on a political blog?
Yum Yum eat them up!!!!
"The market tanked because the auto industry is going under, AIG is posting a $60 billion loss, Eastern/Central Europe is about to make our subprime mess look tame, potentially taking down Europe as well, and US manufacturing and employment is falling off a cliff. "
And just about all of this was known when we were at dow 9k...
Anyone else find it ironic that his speech was titled "fiscal responsibility," yet he thinks we should bailout banks and homeowners that acted irresponsibly?
metalhead, streeteasy = real estate blog. do you understand? r-e-a-l e-s-t-a-t-e.
We need to leave room for error, from any leader.
well, it was predictable. the guy avoided giving any type of details during his campaign. "closing loopholes" doesn't qualify as explaining how a program is going to be funded in detail at all.
the day he said "social security is just fine" taught me a lot about american politics. if you are financially literate and honest you will never be elected (as you will have to say that entitlements and public pensions need restructuring). hence, we are left with dishonest, financial illiterates or a combination of both at the top.
nyc10022, no it wasn't. Estimates are being revised constantly. Monthly unemployment figures have already neared the Fed's prior estimates for this year's HIGH. Surprise, surprise, they just revised it up. AIG's news is old but new. Few were focusing, certainly not our guys and gals downtown, on Eastern/Central Europe, and the earnings figures for Q4 wound up being 65% below initial analyst estimates, and below what they were just recently. The numbers of where the S&P should be if you use GAAP earnings for your p/e calculations going forward are simply horrid. Other standard measurement tools don't give much solace. As Volcker said, this isn't your typical recession.
At a time when we have no money Washington is expanding government handouts. $15B more for Medicaid was just approved. Please. We should be cutting handouts. More foolish spending isn't going to help our situation.
Worst first 30 days ever:
- Lack of a consistent message on the financial system - we still can't admit the entire banking system is insolvent so the strategy changes every 3 days
- A "stimulus" bill that is really just a gigantic inbox clearer for congress - zero market confidence
- Unnecessary (and uninformed) saber-rattling about "manipulating" exchange rates that pisses off our trading partners
- A giveaway to a bunch of losers who got in over their heads with a mortgage they couldn't afford - thanks Stanelli for the rant of the year
This is what happens when you have a bunch of ass-jockey amateurs thinking they can translate a political campaign into governing the world's largest economy. You know there's zero focus on the problem at hand at the White House when the press sec is addressing a cable news personality directly. Stick a fork in it - write these next 4 years off - it's over.
jgr,
this is the worst 30 days ever you say? do you know anything about american history? do you know about andrew johnson's first 30 days? do you know about chester arthur's first 30 days? william mckinley's first 30 days? personally i think president obama has handled his first 30 day masterfully, but even if you think they have been awful, do you really feel comfortable making the statement that they are the worst ever? have you really explored all prior first thirty days of a presidential administration?
as for the idea that 'amateurs' are in charge, i just don't know what to say. clearly you are a hopelessly partisan republican, but it is hard to see how joe biden, hillary clinton, rahm emanuel, larry summers, tim geithner, carol browner, james l. jones, robert gates, steven chu, and paul volker, to name but a few, are amateurs.
dick cheney, donald rumsfeld, colin powell, condoleeza rice, and alan greenspan weren't amateurs either and they proved to be complete disasters, so i certainly don't claim that because obama's team is experienced they will necessarily be good at their jobs. obviously anyone with even a drop of objectivity knows it is way too early to say how the administration will turn out. but these people are not amateurs.
please people, go blog at the john birch society. the republican party leadership is turning to the herbert hoover model, and they are going to be about as good for the electoral prospects of their party as herbert hoover was. we just had an election, we are in an economic catastrophe, and the republican solution is to block the newly elected president and his team from doing what they can to right the ship? the country will not stand for it, which is probably why the republicans in congress have a net -48% approval rating, while the congressional democrats are at net -13% and the president has a net positive approval of 39%.
i would never claim that popularity means he's doing a good job. but politically speaking the republicans are playing with fire here. franklin roosevelt was elected in 1932--three years after the start of the great depression. the republicans like to claim now that he 'caused' the depression. and the republicans in congress between 32-and 34 vehemently opposed his policies. do you know what happened in the midterm of 1934? the republicans lost 9 seats in the senate for a total of 25. and in 1936? they lost six more seats and were left with a total of 16 republican senators (they lost several senators in the years between 32 and 34 as well). in the house republicans went down to 117 in 1932 and then to 103 in 1934. if the republicans keep this up they will suffer the same fate.
happyrenter...ditto, ditto, ditto
"this is the worst 30 days ever you say? do you know anything about american history? do you know about andrew johnson's first 30 days? do you know about chester arthur's first 30 days? william mckinley's first 30 days?"
I'll stack these 30 days up against any of those. You gave no specifics so you don't have a point. That harvard education is doing you well.
" personally i think president obama has handled his first 30 day masterfully,"
masterfully? Is complete incompetence and a total failure to communicate a cohesive plan masterful? What has he done right? Come on now, pulling the wool over your eyes much?
" but even if you think they have been awful, do you really feel comfortable making the statement that they are the worst ever? have you really explored all prior first thirty days of a presidential administration?"
I do. You are the one who has yet to present a single fact.
"as for the idea that 'amateurs' are in charge, i just don't know what to say. clearly you are a hopelessly partisan republican,"
This is when I stopped reading. I haven't been affiliated with a party since I registered to vote at 18. Whose the partisan one?
Good try, but come back next time with a more coherent and substantive post.
in Bush's first 30 days he took the CIA's attention off terrorism and focused on White Collar crime. Brilliant!
jgr, what coherent plan is available for sharing? he could lie, and say that the process of righting a global meltdown is fixable with a few steps: lowering the interest rate to zero (oh, right, already done under the last administration); providing the banks with huge amounts of capital to promote lending (also already done, little additional lending); bailing out too big to fail companies so that we won't continue to spiral down (also done, not working); manipulating money supply and mortgage rates to rev up the economy (guess what?).
What's left in the bag of tricks? What has he not pulled out of his posterior that will magically fix this disaster? He IS confident that someday this will be over. He is NOT confident that it will be easy or painless. He may have lost some confidence in the business world, by not waving a wand and restoring viability to a moribund system, but he hasn't consistently appeared saying the bottom is here, things will only get better, our (fill in the blank) plan will work and we'll turn that corner any second now. Because, guess what, we won't. Watch the Volcker video, that is not a man prone to hyperbole.
HR and aboutready - Solid points, but remember, people have to be willing to listen to learn.
Rick Santelli? Please. This knucklehead had this gem of a quote yesterday, "I guess...well, I guess you have to assume that President Obama has inherited much of these problems."
You have to guess that he inherited much of these problems? How about, he inherited ALL of these problems!
You respect a guy that has to guess that the man who has been POTUS for 30 days is not responsible for the massive financial disaster and economic downturn that we are experiencing (versus the previous administration's 8 years of economic failures that got us here)?
Seriously, you think a guy who has to guess about this has any brains in his head? Hahahahahaha!!!!!
waverly, Rick Santelli kind of reminds me of Joe the Plumber. He's having his 15 minutes of fame, as the result of a not-so-clever rant that nonetheless spoke to the mood of many. His ability to follow up is destined to disappoint.
comparing bush and obama's first 30 days is insane...bush should not have even been allowed to enter the white house...obama is trying and listening to all points of view...his biggest problems are coming from Nancy Pelosi but hopefully he'll remind her that she's a congressman and he's THE President.
Agree totally, aboutready! He will be forgotten soon enough. It's also possible that his name will become synonymous with partisan hacks who go on rants about a subject one day only to be shown to be a horse's ass soon afterwards.
Did you hear what he said the other day?
Yeah, he pulled a Rick Santelli. What an ass!
jgr,
i did not make an argument that requires any facts to back it up. you claimed that obama's first 30 days are the worst ever. to justify that point you would obviously have to be familiar with every other first 30 days. otherwise you have no justification for that position. then i asked, quite reasonably, whether you or not you are familiar with the first 30 days of andrew johnson, chester arthur, or william mckinley. if you are, then you should say you are, and you should explain why you believe obama's first 30 days have been worse. if you are not then you should acknowledge that you have no right to call them the worst since you are comparing them to other first 30 days you know nothing about.
if you think obama is awful, fine. i disagree. but you can't say he is 'worst' when you are comparing him to people you clearly know nothing about.
jgr,
Thanks for the rehashed Fox News talking points.
I find it amusing that the right wing-nuts think Obama is a failure because he has failed to clean up the mess and turn Bush's disastrous economy in 30 days.
WOW.
"- Lack of a consistent message on the financial system - we still can't admit the entire banking system is insolvent so the strategy changes every 3 days
- A "stimulus" bill that is really just a gigantic inbox clearer for congress - zero market confidence
- Unnecessary (and uninformed) saber-rattling about "manipulating" exchange rates that pisses off our trading partners
- A giveaway to a bunch of losers who got in over their heads with a mortgage they couldn't afford - thanks Stanelli for the rant of the year"
lets also not forget... four BIG botches on confirmations... Richardson, Geithner, Daschle, McKinsey lady...