Skip Navigation

Are brokers lowering fees?

Started by seller
over 17 years ago
Posts: 8
Member since: Feb 2009
Discussion about
Has anyone successfully negotiated a reduced broker fee below the standard 6% from any of the big full-service firms (prudential, corcoran, brown harris, etc.). Additionally, has anyone negotiated a reduced fee if the buyer doesn't have an agent or if I as the seller find a buyer? Thanks in advance.
Response by West81st
over 17 years ago
Posts: 5564
Member since: Jan 2008

File this one under "C" for Chutzpah:

I recently received a newsletter from a broker at one of the major houses. He laid out a passionate case for sellers offering listing brokers HIGHER commissions in a bear market. His reasoning: selling brokers (i.e. those who bring buyers to a sale) mostly care about money. With buyers scarce, they will be even more prone to steer their clients to properties offering bigger splits.

Sadly, it's hard to dispute his basic reasoning. If I were a seller, though, my answer would be this: look, I'm paying you 6% (or 5%, or whatever), and that's plenty. If you need to offer other brokers 4% to draw them to my apartment, be my guest. I'm paying you to handle marketing strategy, so split your commission however you see fit. Just don't make it my problem.

As far as what happens if you find a buyer yourself, that's a negotiable clause in the listing agreement. For example, the commission might be 6% if fully co-brokered, 5% if brokered in-house, and 4% if you find the buyer. Often, the last two numbers are the same, which looks unfair on its face but does avoid arguments about who found the buyer.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kas242
over 17 years ago
Posts: 332
Member since: May 2008

Seller, I will be signing a brokerage contract today, and yes, fees are very adjustable from standard 6%. In fact, I didn't even have to push the issue. A major brokerage in your list (prefer not to say who) offered me 5% -- and I didn't even ask! If it's co-broked within the firm, it is still 5%. If my listing agent finds the buyer, it is 4%, and if I find the buyer it is 3%. I should note that I've had a long relationship with this broker, so perhaps she was more flexible than most?

To West81st's point, my RE attorney brought up the same issue. In this market, I don't think brokers can be so choosy. They are dealing with buyers who are very skittish and are willing to take their time. IThey need to show their clients anything that could remotely ring their bell. I'm also selling a one-bedroom in a building that is largely youngish buyers who are accustomed to doing their own research (i.e. they very well may not use a broker) or pied a terre buyers who are savvy enough to do their own searches even if they are using a broker. Perhaps I am delusional, but I decided to go with 5%.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by front_porch
over 17 years ago
Posts: 5325
Member since: Mar 2008

Every commission is negotiable, by I am actually generally raising my fees in this market because I expect properties to be on the market longer, and I'm going to spend more marketing money on them. It's not about the co-broke -- in this environment people will take what they can get -- it's about getting enough of a budget behind the property to get to the right buyer.

Nationwide, that's roughly the trend as well.

ali r.
{downtown broker}

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by patient09
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1571
Member since: Nov 2008

ali: Why would you say what you just typed? "I expect properties to be on the market longer, and I'm going to spend more marketing money on them."

This makes no sense, every broker on planet earth says that buyers are out there. In fact I agree, I think the run rate is about 350 units per month going to contract. Price it correctly and it will sell quickly. This would lead to a QUICKER sale and LESS marketing expense and thus a lower required commision. If a broker takes a listing, knowingly prices it incorrectly and BLAMES it on the marketplace. Well thats just garbage and why the overwhelming majority of brokers are treated like worthless dirt.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by valueseeker
over 17 years ago
Posts: 22
Member since: Jan 2009

I don't understand why tiered commission approach does not take hold in the RE industry. In corporate M&A world, its routinely common to take a higher commission/fees if the company sells for the expected prices, but reduce the fees if the closing prices are lower.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by lo888
over 17 years ago
Posts: 566
Member since: Jul 2008

We've interviewed 4 brokers to sell our place. Three large firms have all insisted on 6% and will do 5% if the buyer is not represented. The smaller one is negotiable (haven't tested them yet) and wiling to cobroke. The smaller agent said that over 95% of all deals have brokers representing the buyers. I am of the opinion that in this market a lot more buyers are looking discreetly on their own and my concern is that if they are not familiar with Streeteasy, Trulia, etc, they will only look at the large brokers' sites and the NY Times. He told me that those are likely to be bottom fishers and I wouldn't want them anyway. Many might be but you never know.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by hypnotik
over 17 years ago
Posts: 40
Member since: Jan 2009

the 6% includes the seller-paid buyer agent commission of 3% right?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by front_porch
over 17 years ago
Posts: 5325
Member since: Mar 2008

Patient09 -- I can only work in the market I've been given -- there ARE buyers out there, but they're taking longer to make up their minds. This isn't anecdotal; statistically days on market have lengthened significantly . . .and that can't be broker mispricing, because it's the same set of people who were pricing 90 days ago!

But it's a large part of my brand that I price things very accurately, and while I do what the seller wants, I urge them not to shake hands with the first bottom-fisher at the risk of leaving money on the table. The swing in real estate commissions of a half percentage or a full percentage is not much compared with the gain you'll make if you price your asset accurately.

Lo888, posters on other threads have reported that some agents at the larger firms has offered 5% even with a co-broke, so I'm a little surprised to hear your experience.

On the starter I'm selling in the Village (small one-bedroom, $519K) I have had about 30 shoppers and two offers. In general, the shoppers who come in without brokers are intrigued by the fact that buying now compares favorably to renting, but they are early in their buying cycle and not yet ready to make deals. The two offers have come from clients with brokers. I know that's just one data point, but .. FWIW.

ali r.
{downtown broker}

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by KeithBurkhardt
over 17 years ago
Posts: 3003
Member since: Aug 2008

All brokers search the same places to find listings for there clients, the NYT's, OLR or RLS. It does not matter what broker added your home to one of these sites...I don't care what they tell you. I have had my listings in special advertising sections of New York Magazine, The Post, Times etc...never one call from these sources.

Price it correctly this is priority number 1.
http://www.theburkhardtgroup.com/about.php

In this market I won't take just any listing and have turned down 3 fairly recently. I own the company so I don't want to waste your time or mine. A big firm has the money to wear you down, after 3-6 months you will either fire him or finally give in and lower your price.

Note: New picture of me in a suit and tie coming soon...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by KeithBurkhardt
over 17 years ago
Posts: 3003
Member since: Aug 2008

Sorry should have been THEIR clients

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by soph
over 17 years ago
Posts: 55
Member since: Jan 2009

Seller- in terms of negotiating on the standard 6% commission it really depends on the price of the property and which agents within the big firms you talk to. In general, if the listing is over $1M many of the big firms will be willing to do it for 5%. That said, I know that most of the "top" brokers within the big firms won't deviate from 6%. To look at it from the RE agent's perspective, reducing their commission is a double edged sword- on the one hand, we're in a difficult market right now & it's going to take me more time & money to sell the listing so they don't feel that they should reduce their commission but on the other hand times are tough & most brokers aren't really in a position to turn away business so it might be better to agree to a reduced commission in order to get the exclusive. (As a RE agent myself, I'm often faced with this scenario & in certain cases agreed to a reduced commission).
That said, I don't think you should choose your broker based solely on the commission rate.
There are many other factors to consider.
sanzaroot@gmail.com

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by manhattanfox
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1275
Member since: Sep 2007

I heard flexibility on apartments over $1mm only....

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by soph
over 17 years ago
Posts: 55
Member since: Jan 2009

lo888- I happen to agree with Ali/front_porch- I work for one of the "big" brokerage firms & have taken listings at 5% on a co-broke & I have colleagues that have too.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by starfish
over 17 years ago
Posts: 249
Member since: Jul 2007

We used one of the big 3 last May to sell our apartment and negotiated 6% if we got full ask (which I told the broker would never happen, but luckily it did), 5% if the sale price was $25K or more below ask, and 3% if there was no buyer's broker (that part surprised me, but he suggested that number first). Our guy said there was little chance of an unrepresented buyer so he would likely end up with 3% anyway. And that was before the big fall, so I have to believe you can get something like that.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by patient09
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1571
Member since: Nov 2008

ali: days on market is a useless statistic because it includes all listings, even the ones that never will sell. It is not easy to construct, but a great statistic is sales that occur on properties that were sold in the first 6 months of listing. Another is time to sell after last price cut. These statistics are more revealing about an agents and owners ability to correctly price the apt, and therefore, the amount of time spent marketing it by the agent.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by valueseeker
over 17 years ago
Posts: 22
Member since: Jan 2009

Starfish- great job. Something like you did should be the industry standard. Otherwise brokers have the incentive to overinflate asking price when trying to get an exclusive from the seller.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment