Seeing more and more $600/sq. ft. places
Started by InvestorMan
over 17 years ago
Posts: 135
Member since: May 2008
Discussion about
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/387925-coop-118-e60th-lenox-hill-new-york?email=true Just here and there. But, it's, nonetheless, starting. Think you'd see anything like that a year ago that didn't have a rent controlled tenant, require all cash, or need gut renovation?
And, yes, I know this is a tiny studio apartment that many on here are far too wealthy to even consider looking at. But, ya know what? The average middle-class, single/young, worker in NYC, regardless of collar color, is looking along these lines.
Still $100k overpriced compared to alternative investments and today's rents, but this does represent progress.
This is a step in the right dire ion. My view is that 600sf is about right for a condo in central chelsea or another nice location, meaning that would be a sane level to buy in my view, and if this location is not so desireable then it should be even less.
I dont think 500sf is "tiny"....given that some studios are even smaller.
any other examples of 600 sf?
what should wmburg end up at?...450
While the price initially seems attractive...consider
1. condition is original and needs complete updating
2. "approximately 500 square feet" used by the broker...
YEAH, RIGHT. Being generous, that apartment is 400 square feet, bringing the price/square foot to around $750. Not that great of a deal, but at least they're not asking $399,000, which I would assume would be the apartment's price at the peak.
I'm not excited yet. Just because an over zealous broker claims it's 500 feet, then fudges the floorplan to equal around 410 square feet, I'm not buying it. The given dimensions are not even in scale to each other.
remember, brokers do not represent square footage in co-ops and have no legal requirement to be accurate.
condos, are accurate in square footage.
the studio apartments at this price is usually because the maintenance is high.
I'm not surprised. I would think we'll be around that within the next 12 months.
julia: $1.69 per ft isn't high maintenance. If most would consider $1.10 low and $1.90 high and north of $2.00 over the top white glove. This doesn't seem to bad for a doorman building. Don't know the building. But the maintenance alone is not worth dismissing it. Deeper investigation is warranted. How much is it too high by?? .19 cents? That comes out to $1,140 a year. check out the service before you dismiss. It could be the best grand you spend all year.
The area is probably next to the off ramp of the QB Bridge.
> The area is probably next to the off ramp of the QB Bridge.
Nope... not even close. Its lex-park... around some very expensive buildings (bloomberg, Trump Park ave, the 59 & Park tower). Its actually a decent spot.
Its a small apartment... but, hey, when was the last time you saw a studio in the $200s....?
That's close enough to the off-ramp, frankly (2.5 blocks), and the traffic coming from Queens goes right down 60th. It's nice to see movement, but this is a really noisy area that's UES in name only (feels like midtown), so still think this is overpriced.
"but, hey, when was the last time you saw a studio in the $200s"
probably 2001. The stock market is at 1997 prices. The issue is not how old a price is. Now that it is conceded that a mania to buy housing existed and it has passed, it is time to look at the fundamental measures of value. I say, let the bean counters do their capital asset pricing models, or the real estate types use their cap rates. I don't trust the buying public or realtors to set prices, err wait, is there a buying public?
"condos, are accurate in square footage. "
Absolutely false! you lie like a rug. Corcoran, Halstead, prudential - they ALL show floorplans that clearly and unambiguously list more square feet than can actually be found on the very floor plans they publish ontheir sites. See this thread:
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/talk/discussion/8529-broker-squatre-foot-inflation
As for the building in this thread - its PRIME UES, Lenox hill. As others have said - its between Trump Park Ave and the Bloomberg buidling. Its in a posh area AND near the NWR and 456.
jason10006, are you on crack?
The thread you supplied the link to was about a broker inflating the price on a co-op, which I said is what all brokers do.
But brokers cannot inflate the price on condos, because unlike co-ops (where you buy shares in the co-op and not the apartment) in condos you are buying the unit. They are required by law to represent the actual square footage of condos. If you see something otherwise in representatin of a condo, I would report it immediately.
If a broker misrepresented the actual square footage of a condo, it would be an open invitation to nullify the contract and set damages. Ask any broker about a co-op square footage and they will say "approximately" or "I cannot represent the square footage of a co-op"
Know your territory before you say it's a lie, jason.
kingdeka - is this actually true, though? Must the square footage of a condo in a listing be accurate, or is just in the offering plan/contract? Even if the listed footage is accurate, it is probably not true usuable square footage if it includes walls, storage space etc.
If you're talking about hallways, closets, foyer, yes it is included in the square footage. That is a completely different argument. What you're talking about is how well the floorplan is organized to minimize wasted square footage.
No law protects reducing wasted square footage from awkward floorplans.
Closets, as everyone knows, are a premium in NYC, so of course they will include closet dimensions in the total.
What jason was saying is that condos do not advertise proper square footage. That is completely incorrect. No broker can misrepresent square footage for a condo. Unfortunately, there are no rules for representing square footage in co-ops because you are buying shares in the transaction. If you look at a contract when you buy a condo, it states the square footage, but a co-op states the number of shares you are buying.
I hate when RE brokers misrepresent square footage in co-ops and uneducated or uninformed buyers take it as gospel truth. You cannot gage price per square footage accurately from co-ops unless you do the measurements yourself or have an appraiser take the measurements.
If a broker is intentionally misrepresenting the condo square footage, it has serious consequences.
One of the many major differences between condos and co-ops.
If you see a CONDO with the listed square footage as "Approximate Sq Ft" that should be a RED FLAG. Ask/demand (if you are serious about the property) that the broker tell you the accurate square footage. They cannot in good faith represent the condo as being approximately. It must be exact.
On a showing sheet, they can get around this law by prefacing square footage with "approximate" but if you are serious about going into contract for a condo, the law protects you and the broker must represent the actual square footage. No laws protect you for co-ops.
A condo's size and method of calculation is in the condo declaration. Some measure from the inside face of the glass, some from outside face of the outside wall. Walls between units are split between the two, walls between unit and hallway/firestairs/elevator taken to outside face, usually. There're variations, so you have to read to compare.
It's my understanding that condo developers only started to include a % of the common elements in reported condo unit square footage this decade. Condo plans from the 80s and 90s are generally reliable measurements of apartment size in my experience. The amount of wasted square footage to hallways varies, obviously, regardless of the age of the apartment. It's easy to see in smaller units. Compare today's version of a 600 square foot alcove studio to an 80s built 550 square foot one. The floor plan on the 80s apartment will often have significantly larger dimensions in the living spaces.
new alcove studio condo, reported 597 sq ft:
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/345578-condo-200-west-end-avenue-lincoln-square-new-york
80s alcove studio condo, reported 550 sq ft
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/rental/386425-condo-222-riverside-drive-upper-west-side-new-york
there are no common elements included in the older condo, so despite its official smaller size, it has more living space.
"That's close enough to the off-ramp, frankly (2.5 blocks)"
Actually, the ramps are even further. The direct bridge is 60th and 2nd. Ramps land higher in the 60s between first and second. 60th is a "through street", but its actually got a lot less traffic once you cross 3rd (most cars go down 2nd or up 3rd).
> It's nice to see movement, but this is a really noisy area that's UES in name only (feels like
> midtown), so still think this is overpriced."
Premise might be correct, but logic and conclusion are not. Yes, its more midtown.. and that has proven MORE expensive. Bloomberg Tower, which is a block away, might be the most expensive building on all the east side. Plaza, Trump Parc, bla bla. The whole "59th street corridor" move. 15 CPW on the other side. Low 60s (and even high 50s) in many cases is MORE expensive these days...
nyc10022,
Regardless, it's very noisy, and that affects the value. And I'd disagree that most cars turn at 2nd or 3rd - many people go to the west side from there as well. It's just a busy street. As for the midtown argument, I think your conclusion is wrong. The Plaza and 15CPW derive much of their value from their Central Park views and ultra-lux status/finishes. This co-op is in a very different situation.
"The thread you supplied the link to was about a broker inflating the price on a co-op, which I said is what all brokers do. "
No, in fact it was about CONDOS AND COOPS both misrepresenting square footage, and even brokers on the the thread admitted it was a problem. Here is a news story about BOTH condos and coops misrepresenting square footage. Besides, as many on that other thread will attest to, they have seen it with there own eyes.
http://ny.therealdeal.com/articles/playing-the-game-of-inches-in-measuring-square-footage
That is a non-sense article. Says everything I said.
There are legal consequences of misrepresenting square footage in condos, which was cited in the article, and that co-ops do not abide by these rules.
You just made yourself look like an idiot, Jason. Misrepresentation by brokers of condos has legal consequences, so if any broker misrepresented the square footage in a CONDO, they are open to litigation. They cannot represent square footage in co-ops.
and BTW, the thread you gave a link to was someone challenging a square footage about a CO-OP.
Obviously this information goes over your intelligence level.
"That is a non-sense article. Says everything I said."
It says that BOTH ccops and condos have and have had inflated square footage in there listings...and that increasingly there are consequences. It cites examples of BOTH coops and condos. It does not say this is rare or never happens for fear of the consequences...in fact it says the opposite. As of its writing, in September 2008, it was so common that the REBNY would not issue guidance on the matter. It did say that people have been sued, yes, so by inference the practice may stop. But it certianly does NOT say that it never or even rarely happens.
"and BTW, the thread you gave a link to was someone challenging a square footage about a CO-OP.
Obviously this information goes over your intelligence level."
The FIRST post was on that. The ENTIRE post was on BOTH coops and condos, with examples cited for both, with links.
For example, from the thread which you claim is JUST about coops, comes a BROKER posting her blog in which she talks about CONDOS overstating square footage:
"nshipley: Well, I'm certainly not going to defend myself against being called a scum, but here's my take from my blog:
http://nychousewhisperer.blogspot.com/2008/12/square-footage-myth.html "
Here the article quotes a brokerage firm saying that because as of the writing of the article, this was a big problem, brokers of CONDOS were starting - STARTING, to change their ways:
""All parties involved are paying more attention," says Max Dobens, a vice president with Prudential Douglas Elliman. His firm — like the Corcoran Group, Brown Harris Stevens and Bellmarc Realty — inserts "approximate" or "estimate" before square-foot figures in its condo listings. Still, "if you see a round number, it's probably wrong, and the right number is probably higher rather than lower," he says. " from http://ny.therealdeal.com/articles/playing-the-game-of-inches-in-measuring-square-footage
Everyone: It's no use arguing with the "King"deka. He likes to make pronouncements and assume that his word is Law. When he starts to see himself being contradicted with facts and logic he just starts making things up, and calls them incontrovertible facts. When that fails, after he is continually proven wrong he likes to call people names. He misinterprets a disagreement or friendly argument as a direct attack against his dignity as a person. It's best not to engage in discussions with him, they go nowhere.
$600 per square foot is coming very soon to a condo near you in Manhattan.
Under $500 psf...
http://www.prudentialelliman.com/Listings.aspx?ListingID=995801&utm_source=StreetEasy&utm_campaign=Agent&utm_medium=listings
505 e. 79, 15d
That 225 East 36th listing is impressive. I mean, maintenance is pretty high but not delirious (it's not like that land-lease apt. in another thread, whose maintenance justified a price of 50K, at most). I wonder if they'll be able to get offers at asking or above, if they are really going to increase it back 500K (don't think so). It gets interesting. It's pretty close to an auction.
great find nyc10022. the maintenance is obviously a problem on that unit and i'd want to find out what the building's finances are. but assuming this isn't some land-lease disaster in the making, you are looking at well under 3k per month for a large one bedroom with a separate dining area and a nice view. not the best neighborhood, but not horrible. that could really be something.
That is a great find, nyc10022. That price should sell the apartment, and maybe even inspire a small bidding war. Smart seller.
Aboutready - nice find, too.
a bidding war? i don't think so.
505 E. 79th is waaaaayyyyy East, which is a definite negative.
some people love the eea area. i'm not one, but it has it's fans. plus, this is really inexpensive.
> the maintenance is obviously a problem on that unit
Its not low, but I wouldn't call it a problem. $1.75 psf, includes central air, doorman, garage, roof deck, and a pretty fancy entry.
And its not like this thing is a few bucks below $600 psf. We're talking $400s here if space is accurate.
wow. This e 36th street thing is the most interesting I have seen on here. Is this what it takes to move a property fast right now?
"some people love the eea area. i'm not one, but it has it's fans. plus, this is really inexpensive."
I hate it, but people who live there like like people like RI or BPC - really far from the hoi polloi the subway brings.
Does Central Harlem count? If so, 100 W. 119th, 6A, originally listed at $1.275, now $725K, 1467sf 4/2 with combined cc and taxes of around $940. Layout is awful, but you could combine bottom two bedrooms and open up the one on the other side of the kitchen as den/dining and for the price is nice layout.
NICE!
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/376314-condo-299-west-12th-street-west-village-new-york
wtf!
decorativewbfp, that is a teeny tiny studio asking nearly 2k psf. i don't think it really qualifies for this thread.
happyrenter, it was a sarcastic attempt to demonstrate an extreme example of how far removed some sellers are from $600sqft. The Bing & Bing buildings will no longer benefit from the hype that's always surrounded them in this market.
decorative, we get your point, but maybe a thread entitled "I can't believe how clueless these sellers are" might be in order? many would enjoy and contribute.
i got the sarcasm, just not clear what it has to do with this thread.
I know this is Harlem, but still. 307 w. 111th, 2E, listed as 800sf, maint. $809, small 2/1 for $295K, and doesn't seem to be a cave at all.