Downside of waiting for absolute bottom
Started by bugelrex
over 17 years ago
Posts: 499
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
I expect prices to fall much further, but there is a downside to waiting too long. Similar to department store sales where they slash several times, 10% -> 20% -> 50% off Those that buy at 10% get a better selection and sizes, those that wait until 50% get a cheaper price but the selection is complete crap as all the good stuff was taken in previous sales.. Because of the limited 'decent' inventory in Manhattan, you run the danger of waiting too long and end up buying something very cheap, but its horrible. Any thoughts? Could RE be different where the GOOD inventory only comes out when everything has given up hope at 50% off?
bugelrex,
real estate is very, very different. the inventory is constantly and continually refreshed by the three ds: death, divorce, and debt. these things do not stop in a bear market. new units will come on the market every single day, and it doesn't matter whether apartments are selling for 10% off peak, 50% off peak, or 90% off peak. there will always be inventory.
Agreed but as I mentioned in a different thread, do not expect to get the majority of today's inventory at tomorrow's prices until tomorrow!
bugelrex,
I hear what you're saying, but I don't think you need to worry about the quality product flying off the shelves. Sure, if you come across a home that fits perfectly with your detailed and unique vision, it may be worth jumping on, but by and large that's a rare occurrence. Nobody knows if we're at or near a bottom (and frankly, I would largely ignore anyone who tells you they're certain either way), but real estate reacts slowly enough that even if you miss a real bottom, prices won't immediately skyrocket to a level where you'll regret not acting. That said, those that are lucky enough (and I emphasize "lucky") to get in a little before the bottom will probably have an overall slightly better stock to choose from. I don't think it's all that enormous though.
bjw - very well stated.
Bugelrex,
In theory you are right, but unlike a retailer where all of the available product is put on the shelves at once, new real estate continues to come onto the market, so the selection at the beginning while better is only better for those apartments listed at the beginning. Further price discovery in the markets will push new listing prices down without the loss in quality of new listings (assuming people decide to sell). The retail example more fits the X celebrity designer who doesn't sell hardly anything in the stores (similar to most rational people not buying apartments now) and then the entire product line is liquidated at some later point with great selection and prices.
bugel..your concerns are def valid. It's simple. Why did manhattan volume abruptly drop 75%. Is it because everyone decided to live elsewhere? of course not. it's because the buyers, not having to buy, decided to wait. They are still waiting. They are waiting for what they perceive as being the bottom and can score that reduced price apt. The problem with that is SO IS EVER OTHER BUYER OUT THERE. ThE bottleneck of buyers all hve their eyes on whether or not the economy has bottomed. Then it's time to buy! There will be inventory being absorbed rapidly. So, the time to buy is when the pickings are good. Looks like we are close to bottom now. Good Luck.
http://www.nypost.com/seven/03052009/news/regionalnews/ny_unemployment_at_7__in_january_158160.htm
supplement to prior post...Unemployment is @ 7.2% for nyc up 1.9% from last year, jan 08 so it can't be unemployment.
people receiving severance aren't included in the unemployment numbers. the number of NYC high-wage earners losing jobs is unprecedented.
steveF, you say people haven't decided to live elsewhere? where's your demographic proof? will the city see anywhere close to the usual influx of new arrivals over the next few years?
I actually know quite a few people who have decided to move elsewhere. They are mainly wall-streeters who know the salad days are not coming back any time soon. I expect that a lot of recently laid-off lawyers will be joining them in the next couple of months. The fallout continues. There is no bottleneck of buyers, just a growing pile of inventory.
aboutready,
people receiving severance can collect unemployment so they are def included in the numbers.
why would transaction volume slow so drastically? You tell me? Is it that suddenly Manhattan was less desireable? Of course not. It's buyers waiting. Of course some sellers are waiting except those with the 3D's who have to sell. But the majority of sellers will just forget about the move and refocus energies elsewhere. First time Buyers, on the other hand, want that ownership, so they are compelled to make a move. They are hoping for that score.
yes, nyc is less attractive if you have few job prospects. i too know a number of people who have and are moving, mostly wall street types at this point. but the other point is equally important, no NEW blood is coming in. law firms, banks, etc. aren't hiring at the bottom of their ladders, either. a market needs buyers at all sizes and price points to operate effectively.
there has been a very rapid adjustment regarding issues such as desirability of owning. not owning now doesn't seem like such a bad decision, does it? many who wanted desperately to buy are just grateful they couldn't. i don't think the buying frenzy upon which the previous bubble relied is rearing its fugly head anytime soon. but we shall see.
i'm not sure about your take on the unemployment issue. i'm fairly certain i read otherwise. anyone with a definitive answer?
..i hear after todays market soon apartments in NY willbe buy one get one free!!!
There is another issue.
What will the RE graph look like?
The 'bottom' implies that it acts as a trapoleen to send prices back in the direction they came.
It might hit bottom and splat. No bounce...just splat. It might stay that way for, well, who knows.
I have noticed that their is always a boom followed by a bust. Markets act and react. The reaction to that last action should be significant and, that seems to be the case.
Social conditions change that make cities either more or less desireable. Intense unemployment for a protracted period of time will have a profound effect on our social condition. Shrinking tax base puts the city in fiscal peril.
The city morphs again. A new configuration, a new zeitgiest, so different from the last phase it's impossible to believe you're in the same town. Not better, just different. Prehaps teenagers will pride themselves on their capacity to wear out jeans into that dirty ripped look instead of their Moms buying them pre-worn and destroyed at Abercrombie for $235!!! How retarded was that decade!!! We went to the mall, got wasted on carbs at the food court and, traded our houses and our childrens future for a flat screen TV and patio furniture. Why didn't that mall cop stop us!!! It can be OUR fault!
Save me Daddy Obama, save me!!!
What a bunch of maroons...
Oh, that felt good.
> Is it that suddenly Manhattan was less desireable? Of course not. It's buyers waiting.
So, if you don't buy something, you are "waiting" to buy?
I think we might have lost a generation of buyers. We're not going to see the numbers of interested parties anywhere near previous levels for a LONG time.