Price trend - anyone have an explanation?
Started by sidelinesitter
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1596
Member since: Mar 2009
Discussion about
Since last May, I've been running a simple search - UES, 3br or more, price $2.5-3.5mm - every few weeks to try to establish a trend. The table below presents the results. Date #listings Median price/sf/ppsf 5/16 135 $2.985/1,923/$1,508 6/24 124 $2.950/1,925/$1,502 7/20 119 $2.950/1,925/$1,502 8/29 102 $2.950/1,995/$1,504 9/13 111 $2.950/2,000/$1,504 10/25 120 $2.995/1,995/$1,530 12/7 147... [more]
Since last May, I've been running a simple search - UES, 3br or more, price $2.5-3.5mm - every few weeks to try to establish a trend. The table below presents the results. Date #listings Median price/sf/ppsf 5/16 135 $2.985/1,923/$1,508 6/24 124 $2.950/1,925/$1,502 7/20 119 $2.950/1,925/$1,502 8/29 102 $2.950/1,995/$1,504 9/13 111 $2.950/2,000/$1,504 10/25 120 $2.995/1,995/$1,530 12/7 147 $2.950/1,926/$1,540 1/15 134 $2.960/1,900/$1,549 3/5 155 $2.950/1,900/$1,552 Even with all the appropriate caveats about comparing apples and oranges as the sample changes, asking (vs. sale) prices not meaning much, median potentially being misleading, each properry being a unique value proposition, etc., I would still have expected to see something that looked like softening in the aggregate numbers. Instead, square footage for the money appears as low as it's been and ppsf as high as it's been. The number of properties on the market is higher, but I don't even have a full year of data yet, so that could be seasonal. I believe that the market has come off substantially and that it is headed lower, so I'm at a loss the explain the results. Perhaps some of Streeteasy's resident gurus have a theory on what is happening... [less]
You have to look at # of days on the market. There are lots of apartments that haven't had price changes that have been sitting unsold for hundreds of days. Sellers can list their apartments for whatever price they want. Whether or not they sell is an entirely different story.
that's a great point iMom, could you run the same search on actual sales?
Is the quality of the listings getting better? I'm seeing the same in my searches, which are different depending on area, but basically something more than a standard 2/2 for under $1.75. Same number of places, but better quality. I recently looked at lower priced properties for fun, and alot of the type of product that I had been seeing has moved down the chain, so to speak.
Think the issue is that you've held the price constant. Given that, you'll likely always come up with the same average or median. If every week, all apartments drop 10%, you'll simply exclude all apartment at the bottom end of your search (i.e., the apartments which are $2.6M reduced to $2.4M) and include apartments not in the prior search (i.e., the $3.6M apartments marked down to $3.4M). What may be changing is the quality of the apartment available in this price range, which would not be apparent in the metrics you're tracking. Would be more interesting to track the apartments which began in that range last May and see where they ended up when/ if they sold.
tob - No, because the OP held the footage constant. Lower prices should mean lower per f2.
The real reason is that prices are not down very much. If sellers hold out another year or so, they will get their price or higher. If you must distress sale quickly while people are scared, well, that's the free market, and the few sales there are will be at low prices for a short while.
"The real reason is that prices are not down very much."
not nec true. by doing the search on the properties that are "for sale" he's missing the real price choppers, who are the only ones that reduced their prices enough for a buyer to be tempted. that are the prices you care about, not those "asks" of sellers that don't mind not selling. that's why i would care only about those listings that actually sold. those lingering in the mkt forever should be disregarded.
thinking - great point on median given fixed range. Brain cramp on my part not to have seen that.
about and thinking - I didn't save any of the searches or print out a hard copy of the May baseline listing, so I can't compare precisely. My impression is that quality is better (in terms of building/address), as you suggest. However, another side of quality is size (how many sf for the money at a median price that, to thinking's point, is basically fixed) and that hasn't moved. The quality theory works if all the market movement is manifested in better location without increasing ppsf, but I would expect to see some ppsf improvement as well (unless the less desirable locations are all dropping below the bottom end of the search).
Anyway, thanks for input. I will have to put more effort into tracking my results.
also, as admin points out it's the sales price you need. for some time the listing discount percentage was extremely low. in your price range it may be much higher now.
each search (listing vs sales prices) answer different questions in a mkt like today's. the first answers "how much are sellers hoping for" at each point in time and the second answers "how much buyers are paying" at each point in time.
if your search is to analyze changes in sellers expectations then using listing prices is fine. if you want to see actual changes in $/ft2, then the second is the one you need to use.
18 sales with that criteria in the last 60 days and 3 of those are new development at the Brompton. So ex the new development thats 7 or 8 a month with your 155 for sale. 20 months of inventory. Urban digs shows in the last 30 days there were 4 new listings in Manhattan for every 1 going to contract. 41 of your listings have had a price decrease of at least 5% and 21 listings have had a price decrease of at least 10%.
It's interesting that the number of new listings have gone up so much. There may also be a surprising bias to your survey. There are fewer apartments as you go up in price. When a listing that was originally in your survey drops its price below $2.5 mm it drops out of the survey. Listings originally priced above $3.5mm were not in your survey fall into the survey when they cut price. Since there are fewer apartments above the threshold you could argue that as prices drop the number of listings in the survey should shrink. The bias in your survey is to fewer listings as prices fall. In fact, the inventory number has done just the opposite reflecting the growing inventory and the growing number of price cuts.
jake, great points!
jake................we might have a genius in our company, kudos.
Agree, great points, jake, esp. the second one. This is what I had in mind when I asked for input from the Streeteasy gurus. I'm reminded of the PGA golf advertising tag line - "These guys are good"
interesting, I might expected a declining trend too. I guess the number of listing is going to go up as bankers continue to get fired and that will definitely increase this summer.