Bank of America Rejects Foreign MBA's!!!!
Started by counciler
over 17 years ago
Posts: 104
Member since: Dec 2008
Discussion about
ok, so we are rejecting those with most talent for those with less talent? what in the world is going on in the United States? In a few months, maybe B of A will put up a sign saying No Asians No Europeans No African Americans No Jews or Muslims. this is indeed a sad day in NYC history.
Link?
In financial times - http://www.ft.com/cms/s/aa648182-0c3d-11de-b87d-0000779fd2ac,Authorised=false.html?_i_location=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ft.com%2Fcms%2Fs%2F0%2Faa648182-0c3d-11de-b87d-0000779fd2ac.html%3Fnclick_check%3D1&_i_referer=http%3A%2F%2Fmeganmcardle.theatlantic.com%2Farchives%2F2009%2F03%2Fbank_of_america_unhires_foreig.php&nclick_check=1
Apparently the reason is due to H1-B visa restrictions for financial institutions receiving TARP money.
http://www.marketwatch.com/news/story/bank-america-pulls-job-offers/story.aspx?guid={BD612BC4-6CE4-4E4E-A3A7-DF78436C354D}&dist=msr_7
the united states, and NYC must be set up for massive failure. these policy moves are self-destructive.
NY as financial capital? haha
http://www.businessinsider.com/bank-of-america-slams-door-shut-on-foreign-mbas-2009-3
the bad thing is the legislation, not the fact that BAC complies with it. obama & the democratic congress (pelossi, barney frank and chris dodd) becoming less of a populist circus would be a change i can believe in.
very sad day in NYC history, as this will impact housing sector once again. Alot of foreigners came here, got jobs in finance and purchased Manhattan real estate. Now that $$$ will flow elsewhere.
This is indeed a sad day. Some of my best colleagues are from other countries. This is why this country is so strong!
we all know where this is heading ... Democrats want to unionize everything
The law in all countries is that foreigners cannot take jobs away from qualified locals. Often companies use these visas to get workers at lower pay rates who are tied to the company for their residency. Indentured servitude, more or less.
Take it from a former expat in London & Madrid.
The only reason to give jobs to foreigners if if no Americans can fill them, not necessarily that they're unqualified. With unemployment rising, that's a tough criterion to meet.
this only (seems to me) to affect people that would just start their process to be sponsored towards a green card. not foreigners that already have a green card or already got their H1-B, right?
places that didn't receive TARP money will be able to cherry pick among the best of the best, that would be an advantage against those that received TARP money if they were hiring.
FT says that it affects not more than 50 MBAs at BAC, unknown quantity if other banks comply with this rule. only 10% of MBAs from top schools are foreigners that need H!-B sponsoring hoping to work on the finance field.
this % would have gone lower anyway without this regulation, as expectations of job stability and wages on the sector became pessimistic (this IMHO, not the FT).
The people here on H1B's can stay in the US for 2 3-year terms, unless they begin sponsorship for a greencard. I would imagine that this group does not own much real estate in NYC, since they are here temporarily (unless they get a greencard).
Steve is also right about the companies needing to justify that they cannot find US citizens who are qualified for the role prior to opening the job up to H1B's. Although, companies can make exceptions for hard-to-fill roles, positions with a lot of travel or certain unique skill-sets.
This is not a bad thing. When you start suggesting that the banks cannot hire the best and brightest because of this you are giving the H1B program way too much credit for the vast, vast majority of people that are here on H1B's. All smart and talented people, but 99% of them are not going to make or break a company. For that 1% that really, truly make a difference, the company will find a way to still hire them.
I think H1Bs can stay for up to 7 years. A large number do eventually file for greencards and eventually citizenship and settle down in the US. People who come over on E1s and L1s are more transient.
lo888 - I agree that a number of H1B's do eventually settle here, but they are not buying real estate in NYC while they are on an H1B visa. They can be granted an extra year in the US if their paperwork for their EAD or greencard is in process, but delayed (I know, the INS being delayed...who knew?).
People on L1's can only work for their current employer in the US, so it is extremely difficult for these people to get an employer to sponsor them for a brand new h1B visa.
HIB Visas are valid for 3 years and you can renew them for an additional 3 year period.
After holding an L1 Visa for a year you can apply for a green card.
I would not sob too much for these kids or these banks. If there is one thing there is NO shortage of right now, its American-born MBAs from top 20 schools looking for jobs at top i-banks (not to mention there permananet-resident collegues.) TOP is a fool. You can throw a tissue paper on any street corner in Manhattan, London, or Honk Kong and hit 10 MBAs from top schools looking for work on Wall Street right now.
Also TOP is an idiot because this law applies as much to Swedish MBAs as it does to Indians.
Waverly - spouse and I are both on H1Bs and we bought in Manhattan. The reason? Once you leave the US it becomes harder to buy real estate.
I know lots of H1Bs and some people with even more restrictive visas who bought. Unfortunately some of the latter have been called back early because of economic conditions and are quite unhappy having to sell in this market.
The H1 program is terrible (and the L1 and E1 are even worse). However, I think it's a bad idea for any country, especially one in an economic downturn to place restrictions on incoming goods (tariffs) or labor. We all agree the Smoot Hawley prolonged the depression, right?
H1s exist throughout NYC -- in law, technology, quant finance, regular i-banking. Part of what made NYC an attractive place is that if you got an advanced degree from a US University it was relatively easy to obtain an H1 and work here legally. I do think this will hasten outsourcing to countries that are less restrictive -- i could see many hedge funds and banking groups relocating to Singapore, Shanghai, or Mumbai (which is already happening with GS, MS, and JP but which they will accelerate).
Protectionism whether it is jobs or goods is a losing hand IMHO
it's a tragedy. period. alot of H1 were also europeans, russians, etc of affluence...they came for a summer, then a year, and it's the parents who fork over the $$$ for the 1 BR's and studios.
To say this has no impact on NYC is unheard of.
I think we all agree this is a not a +++ for NYC.
You are all overreacting. Its just banks that take TARP money. When they pay off the TARP money, they can hire away. Coincidently, there will be a GLUT of top-tier job-seeking MBAs, so no one will even notice.
counciler, how do you think this will negatively impact NYC?
most foreign investment bankers are here temporarily and are very entry level, not exactly your typical condo purchasing NYC buyer.
I take it from your sensitivity to the issue you are impacted by this.
oldbuyers - a lot stick around much longer than you think.
yeah we really need a bunch of mindless robots with MBAs who are obsessed with greed and don't have the creativity skills Americans do...
Stevejhx - I agree with you completely. Difficult times are are upon us and we have to take care of our own - there is no other country in the world that maintains the "open door" policy that we have here in the US. I too was an expat in London for many years, and the Brits I worked with didn't even make a lame attempt to hide their resentment. I survived for 6 years only becaue I was very good at what I did AND becasue I reported to an american. So, don't count me in with counciler's comment that "we all agree this is not a +++ for NYC". It is in my mind - a HUGE plus.
93rd and lo888 - certainly there are exceptions to every rule, but the overwhelming majority of people on H1B's in NYC did not buy real estate until they were closer down the road to a greecard.
counciler - people on H1B's are not here for a summer or a year. Most are here for at least the 1st 3-year term of their visa. L1's may be able to apply for a greencard after a year, but it doesn't happen. The L1 only allows you to work in the US for your current employer. So, if you worked for Goldman in India and they sent you to the US on an L1 you could only work for Goldman in the US unless another company sponsored you for a brand new H1B (not going to happen) or a greencard (no way/no how) or maybe if you married a US citizen. Now, if Goldman in India sent you to the US on an H1B visa, you would just need a company to transfer the H1B visa and that is more likely to happen.
i happen to be a u.s. citizen and this in my opinion is only setting the stage for capital and brainpower to move elsewhere.
something that the FT doesn't mention is that this could affect foreigners that work in banks that received TARP money but don't do finance but IT, for example, which is a field popular with foreigners.
good point admin. if only there was an ETF to short NYC as a whole. Fortunes could be made.