Lawyer Layoffs
Started by malthus
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1333
Member since: Feb 2009
Discussion about
Just a newsbit from yesterday below. Although it doesn't get much attention in the shadow of some of the bigger happenings in our economy, these kinds of stories are coming out on a daily basis. For all the talk here and elsewhere about Citi's better than expected results, it is worth noting that the effects of the financial crisis on service providers has only just begun. Lower profits for... [more]
Just a newsbit from yesterday below. Although it doesn't get much attention in the shadow of some of the bigger happenings in our economy, these kinds of stories are coming out on a daily basis. For all the talk here and elsewhere about Citi's better than expected results, it is worth noting that the effects of the financial crisis on service providers has only just begun. Lower profits for partners, less associates and smaller incoming classes will continue to negatively impact real estate prices and rental rates in NYC. "Let's hope the dismal news coming out of White & Case today won’t be catching. On Monday afternoon, the 2074-lawyer firm announced that it's shedding a whopping 200 associates and 200 administrative staff people. That's on top of the 70 associates the firm laid off last November. Even more ominous is that the announcement says the firm also is evaluating its partnership, "which will result in a reduction in the number of partners, commensurate with current and anticipated business needs." The news also is bad for those about to join the firm: White & Case says it will be "deferring the start date of approximately 60 percent of this year's incoming associate class in the US until 2010." [less]
There is a rumor that one of the truly top-tier firms is about to join the ranks of the job choppers. That will start something really ugly in this profession.
Some smaller firms are rescinding offers. Most firms are taking measures to try to minimize or greatly reduce the number of first years that are coming on.
They are also salary cuts in big law too -20% plus.
Some firms are freezing salaries. Partners salaries, obviously, are all over the place but at all but a couple of firms they're down. Essentially over the next couple of years they're trying to also eliminate most of a full class of attorneys. It must really suck to be graduating from high school, college, grad school (wherever you had expected to find a job) right now. This does seem worse than '81-2. Of course, it also sucks to lose the job you have.
Huh...Re big law: I'm only aware of bonus cuts and salary freezes, not salary cuts (yet).
oops, I thought big law meant top-tier. my bad.
Coming from someone at a very secure firm: "Everyone should be worried. It is scary right now."
not fun times...
Obviously some partners have had their pay cut, or have been told it will be going down going forward, in big law. But uswmom, you're right, in terms of associate pay reductions, I've only heard that McGuire Woods has decreased first year salaries.
I'm not in the know but I would expect salary cuts to be coming:
a. they spiraled upward over the last 15 years along with the credit bubble;
b. firms are suffering and there are only so many headcount cuts they can make;
c. partners will be taking profit cuts and will certainly want to share the pain with associates;
d. clients may be negotiating rates downward; and
e. associates have no leverage.
The good news is that I expect most attorneys who keep their jobs will have better buying power in a relative sense since they will have far fewer MBAs 10 years junior to them taking the apartment stock. But for the market as a whole, this will create more downward pressure.
malthus, I agree. add f. clients aren't paying their bills.
And yes, I think if you manage to retain a well-paying job you should do OK. As you say, all but the top levels or mid to top levels of the top tier have not been able to do well recently in this real estate market.
The hubby and I were discussing this. If salaries go down, but the costs of many of the things we need/enjoy also do so, then some people, assuming they retain employment and wages don't plummet, may be doing better at the end of the day. I used to be able to afford to go to the Caribbean when I was younger, recently I could still afford to do so, but only in the off-season to even lesser resorts than when I was young and "poor." Obviously that trip is a trivial thing when put into the context of all the loss and suffering that is going on, and the husband could lose his job as well, but it would be nice someday to not feel as though prices were being constantly driven out of reach.
"Huh...Re big law: I'm only aware of bonus cuts and salary freezes, not salary cuts (yet)."
i already read about job cuts in the FT, so that's the ultimate salary cut. law firms were expecting tons of lawsuits coming that didn't (clients are in such a bad shape they are not litigious to save cash) and as aboutready says more of them are having trouble paying their bills. many of the job cuts on law firms, as i understand it, are due to an adjustment of expectations of more work that didn't materialize and no upward trend in sight. a couple of areas were doing well though.
that said, anybody knows anything about consulting firms? they tend to pay well, i wouldn't be surprised if their work load is going to go down even lower than law firms. any job cuts there? for the most part they are private companies, so i've seen no public announcements about that.
i've seen some reports of conulting firms cutting, but none that said which cities. if I can find the sources I saw, I'll post them.
admin, clients are also waiting to see who they might want to purchase/take over at the end of the day before they sue. I think there will be an uptick in litigation, the statute of limitations only runs so long for causes of action, but it has definitely taken longer than law firms anticipated.
In watching law firm responses to the downturn (are we calling it the "Great Recession"?), it is worth noting that not all firms are structured the same way. It will be interesting to see if there is a disparate impact and/or response by the various model types. For example, some partnerships are an "eat what you kill" arrangement where partners understand the more money they bring in, the more they will personally benefit and if they have no business or too little, their share plummets and can even be zero. Other firms are more traditional partnership models where all share in the good and bad times; when corporate deals generate huge sums, the litigation partners share in the wealth even though the corporate & banking departments brought in the money--in downturns without much deal making, the litigation and labor departments may pick up steam and provide for the famine in the corporate department. This latter group has to balance its methods so that the highest earners don't defect because they feel they're getting too little of the draw. But if the one-for-all, all-for-one ethos is culturally entrenched, these firms I suspect may fair better and have less internal bloody brawls than the eat-what-you-kill places.
For attorneys inside and outside the world of law firm life, it'll be interesting to see it play out to say the very least.
Very good point, kylewest. It must also be noted that some of the law firms avoided the overexpansion/overleverage of the times, while others did not. Traditionally, due to their structure, law firms have not been perceived as "well-run businesses." Now, some of the firms that decided to embrace the financial world's model may be hurting, while some of the stodgier, more traditional firms may do better. Most of the better firms will try to minimize the loss of firm culture. One very sad and notable exception is MoFo, which went on an expansion rampage in the 00s, and recently fired a large number.
So, wait, let me get this straight... the lawyers and the Irish carpenters are NOT saving us?
Looks like its up to the Russian Oligarchs, nyc10022. Oh, wait:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/08/business/08shift.html?scp=1&sq=russian%20oligarchs&st=cse
I just hate it when the Russian Oligarchs let us down. Maybe the tour groups of Chinese speculators?
admin - "i already read about job cuts in the FT, so that's the ultimate salary cut." - yes, it is, but I have to think that salary cuts across the board, in addition to layoffs and smaller incoming classes, would have more detrimental effects on NYC RE than layoffs/smaller classes alone. Though, I could be wrong.
aboutready - "If salaries go down, but the costs of many of the things we need/enjoy also do so, then some people, assuming they retain employment and wages don't plummet, may be doing better at the end of the day...it would be nice someday to not feel as though prices were being constantly driven out of reach." - - I am SOOOO with you on this one!! We were just recently discussing how absolutely absurd it is that a mid level associate salary gets you a one bedroom in manhattan. It's unbelievably insane that you can't afford to purchase a place for a family with that salary!
"aboutready - "If salaries go down, but the costs of many of the things we need/enjoy also do so, then some people, assuming they retain employment and wages don't plummet, may be doing better at the end of the day...it would be nice someday to not feel as though prices were being constantly driven out of reach." - - I am SOOOO with you on this one!! We were just recently discussing how absolutely absurd it is that a mid level associate salary gets you a one bedroom in manhattan. It's unbelievably insane that you can't afford to purchase a place for a family with that salary!"
totally agree, and add to "that salary" the dedication time wise, the cost of the education needed (in money, time, energy) to get there... it doesn't necessarily pay back as handsomely as it looks from the outside.
uwsmom, are you talking about renting or buying a one bedroom in Manhattan? If you meant buying, are mid level associates making $300K+? If so, I am totally in the wrong field...
No, admin, it does not! I think I can count on one hand the number of weekends my husband has had free in '09 as well as the number of times he's been home for dinner in the last month. It's not an easy lifestyle...
i know, and they you get to know about the high school drop outs retired for the long island railroad, for example, that get $250k per year thanks to fake disability... they might not even know how easy they had it for so long.
It's been better the last three or four years, but I remember one 15-month stretch where my husband had one holiday off (Presidents' Day, go figure).
admin, not only has it not paid back as handsomely, it has seemed to pay less and less as time goes by, in terms of purchasing power. and the road had been getting harder and longer to get ahead in law firms, and now, of course, who knows. for now, I'll just consider us lucky as long as he holds onto his position.
I should add that there are very nice perks. For instance, my husband was able to take 3 months off when we had our daughter. It's all about trade-offs.
hejiranyc - I meant buying...salaries and bonuses are public knowledge.
and, yes, aboutready is right. it is getting harder and harder. I don't think my husband's firm made anyone partner last year (I may have that wrong...not sure).
a couple of friends graduated from columbia law school a couple of years ago. one regretted it just before finishing. thanks to huge students loans she found no other choice but to have her blood sucked by the company that hired her till the loan is paid back and she becomes a free human again. the other guy is not as unhappy, but the payback seems decades away when one becomes a partner, and then becomes a blood sucker of younger aspiring partners. but i bet that there are a lot of options in other parts of the country with less competition once the loans are paid back (that requires a high salary if you want to pay that fast).
seems that the biz model of consulting firms is similar, blood sucking and no life/work balance on the beginning for gold at the end of the tunnel (if you make it).
Gold at the end in a law firm? A few years back a guy who made partner at Wachtell Lipton left to become a professor. (To put this in context, partners at Wachtell are consistently the highest paid big law firm attorneys.) When a reporter asked him why he left, he said it was like a pie-eating contest where the winner gets more pie.
Law school should be only 2 years but that is a topic for another thread and another board.
Maybe copper. My husband actually enjoys what he does, so there is that. Most attoneys don't, which I would imagine makes the environment that much worse. In the mid-90s it wasn't so bad. Things seemed to get worse a bit later (Greenspan, you've got a lot of 'splainin to do).
admin, I just recalled. Booz let go 150-60 recently. Here's where the sick amongst us can go for up-to-the-minute coverage of the carnage. Notice the law firm entries:
www.vault.com/companies/layoffs.jsp
Malthus - that pie eating contest story is a classic! In fact if my memory is right - the guy had only been a Wachtell partner for a year or so (putting in 8 years of work). (And somehow I find myself in big law . . . what am I doing wrong?)
Thanks for the link aboutready. That leads me to another aspect to all of this -- and one that gets us back to real estate. There are a fair number of observers that believe that NYC actually has much more in common with London than with most places in the US. To that point it is interesting that the London real estate market starting dropping earlier than NYC and has gone further down. Similarly the London law firms started their layoffs before the local ones, and they seem to have cut deeper. It could be that is even more reliant on finance (it is). But it might also serve as a leading indicator.
malthus, if you're right (and I believe you are) it's scary. The Brits are shedding partners far more quickly than US firms. Particularly, I might add, the London firms that had the greatest expansion in the NYC market the last few years. expand, conquer and crash.
october, "what am I doing wrong?" there's nothing wrong about your job. to put it in context, there are people that are getting their PhDs in hard core science (which is even more demanding) and find no jobs at all. the best of the best get half or a third of what a lawyer gets paid.
just saying that rewards are not always aligned with effort and how difficult your job is. when it comes to options for unlucky people like me, without a clear answer to "what you want to do when you grow up?" but ready to work hard, Law is one of the routes (also MBAs) that people like me would opt for. it's interesting to know that not always works out as well as it seems.
among the best paid people in our society are entertainers. guys that aim at putting a ball in a specified spot and actors. anyway, i'm off topic as usual here but how those get paid more than scientists is weird in a way.
when i read that instead of kick ass scientists the best paid in universities where a dermatologist and football coaches, i kind of got scared.
Admin - you will get no argument from me!
yes UWS mom - big law and top tier. Someone in my close family got a big salary cut - his specialty has no business now do to the markets.
If I'm recalling my husband's jabber correctly, Wachtell is a slightly different beast from the rest.
October - my husband really enjoys his firm, his work, and, for the most part, the people he works with. We often have a chuckle over myth vs reality discussions. It's not easy, but it's not blood-sucking either. I suppose it all depends on your mind-set.
Admin - all so unfortunately true.
cc - that stinks!
uwsmom - I love the firm, the people I work with, and sometimes even the law - but I think one day I'm going to do something different.
so is he :)
is that you dear?
Different lawyer - but I think it's every lawyer's dream!
My problem now is that I have this money in cash which I was planning on using for a down payment on an apartment - but given the economy I'm holding off (as prices come down and until I know that I'll still have a job a year from now). Now part of me wants to forget buying and just take the cash and travel and write for a few years.
I wonder if there will be a difference in how the Great Recession is weathered by the eat-what-you-kill partnerships versus those firms with more traditional distribution of profit models.
Here are a couple of blogs that have become the best sites for tracking law firm layoffs:
http://www.abovethelaw.com/
http://lawshucks.com/
Long hours + young beautiful associates = a lot of office affairs. Have many attorney friends and they tell me some pretty tawdry stories. According to one of my friends, a secretary once even walked in on a partner caught in the act with another associate. Made the rounds in the office. All felt so bad for the wife at the Christmas party.
I guess it happens in all professions, especially ones where long hours are needed. You end up seeing more of your coworkers than your spouse. It just seems much more common in law and finance though.
wow - justlooking1, you've clearly never worked in medicine ;)
Or worked in anything else...
Without Lawyers, none of you could buy an apartment.
The more layoffs and the more you besmirch brokers...the more you'll be paying for legal advise.
idiots all
Who was asking about salary cuts as well?
"Dewey & LeBoeuf has confirmed that 66 partners -- about one in five of the firm's 350 partners -- have seen their compensation reduced by as much as 80 percent over the past 15 months."
But what about the irish carpenters?!?!
This Irish Carpenter who bought at 75 Wall Street
11 Oct 2008
By his own admission, Kenny Timmons has never known bad times. When he left school in Kells in 1992 he went straight on to building sites, and by 2004 he had his own carpentry business that employed about 20 men. He has an apartment on Wall Street in New York to his name, and another in Dubai in the United Arab Emirates. "I could see this recession coming here. Unfortunately, I couldn't see it coming all over the world," he says.
Of the 20 men who worked for him four years ago, only two remain, and while he feels the sense of panic is overdone, he admits to feeling a little nervous. "It's tight for money now - very tight. It's the end of the tax year and the Government are expecting a lot of money in from everyone. Everyone is in the same boat . . . a week's wages is all we're getting now.
"The banks are to blame for this. They could have kept a better control on it. They were giving them out willy nilly to everyone, mortgages and loans. And that was driving everything up. And now things are gone down, they're not giving anything out."