Skip Navigation

from contract to close: are these drops normal?

Started by GraffitiGrammarian
over 17 years ago
Posts: 687
Member since: Jul 2008
Discussion about
I was just browsing through the Recent Recorded Sales on Streeteasy's main page, and noticed big drops between contract and close on three of the five listings randomly featured there. 5 Riverside Drive fell $65k, or about 9%. http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/closing/793558 40 West 116th St fell by $100k, or nearly 17% http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/closing/793684 201 East 79 fell by $65k, or 10% http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/closing/792078. I haven't been paying attention to this -- is this a normal spread between contract and close? thanks.
Response by NWT
over 17 years ago
Posts: 6643
Member since: Sep 2008

What you're seeing is the drop from last listed price to closing price. "In contract" doesn't mean the contract is for the last listed price.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by NWT
over 17 years ago
Posts: 6643
Member since: Sep 2008

E.g., take 7A, also in 5 RSD. On 1/16, seller dropped his asking price to $1.595M. On 1/26 someone contracted to buy. The contracted-upon price could've been less than, the same as, or more than the last asking price of $1.595M. We won't know what the contracted-upon price will be until the sale finally closes and there's a public record. The contract itself isn't filed.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by aboutready
over 17 years ago
Posts: 16354
Member since: Oct 2007

I can't speak for him, but that's not how I read gg's question. We've all been following the price reductions, and often the sales price has been noted, but the amount of discount from final listing price at contract to sale is also interesting.

If we're seeing 20-25% reductions in current asking prices, and people are getting another certain percent discount from final list to sale, that could be quite meaningful. If these were just relatively highly priced listings when they went into contract, less meaningful.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by NWT
over 17 years ago
Posts: 6643
Member since: Sep 2008

We need to define terms.

Final asking/listing price is the last price publicized by the seller.

The contracted-for price equals the selling price. It's the price agreed upon, after negotiation, by buyer and seller.

What we don't know is what the buyer first offered the seller, how much the seller countered with, etc., in their negotiations to go from final asking price to selling price.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by NWT
over 17 years ago
Posts: 6643
Member since: Sep 2008

Let's take 5 RSD 14D as an example. Here's the SE history:

06/06/2008 Listed in StreetEasy by Elliman at $925,000
07/08/2008 Price decreased to $899,000
10/03/2008 Price decreased to $849,000
10/27/2008 Price decreased to $795,000
12/01/2008 Price decreased to $749,000
12/23/2008 Elliman listing entered contract
02/28/2009 Elliman listing sold

The prices from 6/6 to 12/1 are asking prices, what the seller hoped to get.

Sometime between 12/1 and 12/23, buyer and seller negotiated a price of $685K, and entered into a contract for that amount. Then came board approval, etc. The sale closed for the contracted-upon price of $685K on 2/28.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Apt_Boy
over 17 years ago
Posts: 675
Member since: Apr 2008

The real question is "Are buyers getting an additional discount from the signed contract to the ultimate sales price"

This can only be determined when the docs get listed on ACRIS and you can see either an amendment to the contract adjusting the price or simply the amount crossed out and replaced with a new price.

I think it is a given, no one is paying "list" these days, even if the sales price has been reduced.

NWY, the contract price only equals the sale price at closing, which can change in the interim

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bugelrex
over 17 years ago
Posts: 499
Member since: Apr 2007

Isn't there an 'inspection contingency' available whereby the buyer find issues they are not happy with during an inspection and back-out or reprice:

Eg.

- Ceiling may have a prior leak from tenant above
- mold in certain areas
- a building inspector sees a crack in the building foundation, thereby increasing the chances of increased maintaince
- the coop financials appear weak... you want to lower the price to reduce your risk of increased maintaince

etc etc.

Isnt't there protections for the buyer after initial contract sign? or at least after verbal acceptance

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by NWT
over 17 years ago
Posts: 6643
Member since: Sep 2008

Contracts don't appear on ACRIS, and therefore not on SE.

Due-diligence (inspection of financials, property appraisal, etc.) takes place before the contract is signed.

Of course, a buyer in a falling market (or a seller in a rising market) can always try to renegotiate the contracted-upon price, but that's not usually successful.

If you've bought an apartment, dig out the contract and see what the terms were. If you haven't, you might want to read up on this stuff before signing anything.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by triplec
over 17 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Dec 2007

With the information in the example above from NWT, there is no way of knowing when the price was set at $685k - it could have first gone to contract at $749k and then been reduced at some point. There's no way of knowing with just the information above.

I believe we will see more and more price reductions - I have seen one already in a building I am following and will be watching this closely going forward.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by NWT
over 17 years ago
Posts: 6643
Member since: Sep 2008

It's not my information. It's the data provided to SE by the broker and by NYC. The broker doesn't make contract info public, other than to say "in contract" or "contract fell through; back on market."

The city doesn't know or care about the contract. The city records the sale price, and that's it.

While it'd certainly be interesting to know what the contracted-for price was, whether that contract was amended, why either party breached, whether the deposit or some part of it was forfeited, etc., etc., there's no way to know unless the parties go to court about it or somebody blabs. In practice virtually all contracts go through as written. The contingencies (anything both parties agree to include) don't cover "Market's going down, I changed my mind, sell it to me for less or give me my deposit back." By the same token, they don't include "I got a better offer, here's your deposit back, thanks anyway."

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by GraffitiGrammarian
over 17 years ago
Posts: 687
Member since: Jul 2008

Well these were interesting comments. Just by the by, I'm a female Grammarian (altho I do realize it's a gender-neutral nom de plume ;-)

I guess what interested me here was what goes on from the buyer's perspective. For instance, a seller in NWT's example of 5 Riverside Drive sees the place first listed at $925k and feels it's too high, doesn't offer.

Then the price drops to 9, 850, 8, 750, and bingo, that 750 number is the place where the buyer feels he can come in with an offer and still have room to negotiate.

So the buyer is assuming that he can negotiate maybe up to 10% off of the asking price.

Or -- maybe not, maybe the buyer isn't making these calculations. I'm just saying, if we can see that deals are closing for 10% to 15% lower than asking price, then that's an important number to know if you plan to try to negotiate your offer down.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jmkeenan
over 17 years ago
Posts: 178
Member since: Jan 2009

GG -- I think if there is one thing I've picked up here on the boards is, always ignore list price.

For instance, if I go to Gristedes and the are selling apples for $1.50 and then I go to Citarella and they are selling the same apples for $3.00. Now, one week they both decide to have a sale. Gristedes goes down to 1.25 and Citarella sells their apple for 2 bucks. Do I buy the identical apple at Citarella b/c I'm "saving" $1 on the Citarella apple, but only "saving" a quarter on the Gristedes apple?

That's not to say your post isn't interesting in other respects -- it's amazing to see the velocity at which prices have changed in NYC. And listing price has a psychological impact -- another reason to ignore it!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jmkeenan
over 17 years ago
Posts: 178
Member since: Jan 2009

To add -- I think when you know the listing price (and its history) it would make some people (myself included) feel guilty about taking advantage of another's misfortune -- i.e.someone "losing" nearly 300k in a real estate transaction. I know that's not how one should look at it, but it's hard not to empathize with the sellers.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by GraffitiGrammarian
over 17 years ago
Posts: 687
Member since: Jul 2008

Yes, jmkeenan, I hear ya. But there is accepted practice in making offers, isn't there?

For instance, in the 5 Riverside Drive example -- if the buyer had offered $685k at the very beginning, when the seller's asking price was $925k, the offer would have been ignored as a "lowball" offer -- most likely, right?

Yet at a different stage in the process the very same buyer walks away with the apartment when he offers the same price -- $685k. That time he succeeds because it is within certain range of the (now lower) asking price.

All of which only goes, I suppose, to prove your point -- that there is a lot of psychology at play here.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by West81st
over 17 years ago
Posts: 5564
Member since: Jan 2008

In the past two week, some sales have closed at stunning discounts off the final asking price. Here are a few examples, from diverse price ranges:
535 Park Avenue #15A. Final ask: $4.95MM. Closeed for: $3.724MM. Discount: 24.8%
91 CPW #14A. Final ask: $7.4MM. Closeed for: $5.65MM. Discount: 23.6%
267 West 71st #1R. Final ask: $1.399MM. Closed for: $995K. Discount: 28.9%

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by front_porch
over 17 years ago
Posts: 5325
Member since: Mar 2008

The average discount from last list price is a closely watched stat -- and it was 12.4% in 1Q 2009, according to the newest Miller Samuel report. (In contrast, it was 3.2% a year ago).

The increased discounting is one reason sellers "overprice" things -- if a buyer is going to come in and ask for a double-digit discount on a property whether it's cheaply priced or not, often the seller is going to position the price "up" to take into account that 12.4%.

ali r.
{downtown broker}

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by West81st
over 17 years ago
Posts: 5564
Member since: Jan 2008

Ali: I see that as a fool's game. From what I'm seeing in my sector, the apartments that are selling (generally at the 10-20% discounts off ask that you mentioned) are not the ones that were overpriced. Check the three examples above. They were all arguably priced pretty well vs. prior-sale comps.

Sellers (and in some cases, their agents) may be overthinking the psychological game of pricing. Sales are happening at deep discounts because the market is falling, not because buyers expect some magical ratio between the asking and selling prices.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bugelrex
over 17 years ago
Posts: 499
Member since: Apr 2007

It would be awesome to insight from people who have successfully lowballed a huge discount from a reasonable ask. What were some of the best ways to present the offer without being laughed at/ignored.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by columbiacounty
over 17 years ago
Posts: 12708
Member since: Jan 2009

i would agree re: trying to pysch this out. some people actually want to sell and are being realistic. doubt that it was about the presentation; more likely their own circumstances and view of the economy, etc. would guess (my opinion only) that we will see this trend increasing significantly in the next few months.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by patient09
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1571
Member since: Nov 2008

Ali: I agree with 81, that is a hugely dangerous game. Many times, I just won't waste my time visiting something if I think the price is too ridiculous. I think a seller has a substantial amount of potential buyers just ignore the listing.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by patient09
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1571
Member since: Nov 2008

also on the cut list. 860 Park Ave #5 Didn't they list it at 13mm or so, eventually drop to 9.5mm then close at 7mm. For a final drop of almost 30%. Back to what they paid in 2004.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by tina24hour
over 17 years ago
Posts: 720
Member since: Jun 2008

Ali - I think we're beginning to see less of the intentional overpricing you mention. I've been watching the East Village 1+ BR market pretty closely, for example; new listings are coming on at lower initial asks than comparable post-bubble units. Here's an example:

Listed in September (two days after Lehman failed?)
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/350003-coop-60-east-9th-street-greenwich-village-new-york
Started at $625K, reduced to $585K in January.

New listing - initial ask $595K
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/398655-coop-60-e-9th-st-greenwich-village-new-york
One floor higher, larger overall, preferable floor plan (in my opinion). Advertising as "Best Price in the Building!"

Think the psychology has changed?

Tina
(Brooklyn broker)

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by front_porch
over 17 years ago
Posts: 5325
Member since: Mar 2008

Tina, I'm not sure it has, partly because the difference between the larger one that you like and the smaller one is nearly $400 a month in maintenance, which is not small. At today's loan rates that should be around $80K off ask to compensate .. .it's not my listing, so I can't predict what seller is thinking, but that's what I'd be thinking.

Just started showing in the East Village (www.99East4.com) and so far traffic is light, and the serious interest is coming from parents buying for kids...their sensitivity is that they want to make sure they have quality first, and they'll talk price later.

ali r.
{downtown broker}

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment