How would you use this space?
Started by uwsmom
over 17 years ago
Posts: 1945
Member since: Dec 2008
Discussion about 306 West 81st Street #GARDEN
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/rental/455682-rental-306-west-81st-street-upper-west-side-new-york Maybe others are more creative than me. Where would you put the bedrooms? Lovely townhouse, lovely location, but rough floorplan IMO. Too bad the kitchen isn't on the 2nd floor. Maybe you would use the garden level for all living/dining and top floor for sleeping...
that one is tough: Master BR w/a TV in it downstairs in the bay, dining table that doubles as desk downstairs near kitchen, two kids upstairs with the one who gets the window having to walk through the windowless one's room to get to the bathroom (so maybe they switch off once a year?) and that smaller space between the upstairs rooms becomes the kids' den, with a couch and a TV.
uwsmom--A lot depends on how many kids you have and how old they are. I agree that the layout is a bit funky, especially if you have older kids (no one's gonna want a windowless room!). If you only have one kid or your kids are babies, that's a different story. Also, having the bedrooms facing the street on such a low level will be very noisy.
I do have to add, though, that the asking rent is, IMO, exorbitant for this. It really is out of all proportion.
It's charming and the garden is enticing; I agree w/ squid the rent seems out of line. Also it is dark. Great for a couple---I think you would the regret the choice for your children. There has to be something better for the $$$. I fell in love with a brownstone duplex in '93 when I was in the market to buy---got outbid---turned out for the best.
Agree that asking rent is insane. The space is challenging (essentially no closets, and looks like dining room has a weird kitchenette) so I would have a hard time paying anything more than mid/high 4's (maybe 5), though it does have outdoor space, which would bring the price up for some (not us). Right, front garden room is likely dark, so would make a better bedroom than LR. Too bad. She's going to have to drop this significantly unless someone is a sucker for garden space. Thanks for playing :)
And would not want to put kid's bedroom in front of house, which would mean walking thru kid's room to get to the bathroom (or go downstairs). On the other hand, the current LR would make a massive "kid's suite". You could get 3 in there comfortably (though they might kill eachother ;) Right now we have 1 under 1 so she would truly have a play palace!
uwsmom: mom of 3 here---no, they might not kill each other but they would give you a hugh headache. :)
I'm almost certain there are better choices out there. My husband has me trained to look for flaws to capitalize on!