Is the Foreclosures Mess Behind Us???
Started by alpine292
over 17 years ago
Posts: 2771
Member since: Jun 2008
Discussion about
Foreclosures in New Jersey down 40%. Is this the end? http://www.northjersey.com/realestate/NJ_foreclosures_fall_40.html
The very next sentence in your linked article states:
"At the same time, foreclosure filings were up 30 percent nationwide."
I am sorry, but too many people act as if after 8 years of sunshine that these dark clouds are going to disappear after just a couple of months.
The US (and more importantly, the NYC regional economy) needs to go through a very harsh restructuring -on that the government seems to be wanting to put off with these wasteful and politically biased "bailouts" and "stimulus plans". The NYC area has been overly dependant on Wall St. growth which essentially turned out to be a giant ponzi scheme - and one that people who bought a home over the past 10 years are part of - that simply ISN'T coming back.
I know you don't want to hear this, but prices got pushed up to ridiculous levels and need to pull back in line with normal income levels. The contraction we have seen the economy is only starting and will go through various phases as whole industries go through, quickly or slowly, a long over due restructuring.
Unfortunately, the government seems to think that we should just inflate our way out of this mess - so debt holders, people who paid too much for assets (homes) and other completely irresponsible characters don't have to face the consequences of the mess that THEY made!
This country is full of economic cowards who love to push capitalism during "good times" but then resort to state intervention and economic manipulation when things don't work out.
So, no, we aren't anywhere near the end. There will be periods where things appear to be getting better because this process isn't linear in nature. If the government continues to make matters worse by attempting to soften this landing then this economic restructuring could go on for over a decade.
Just look at what happened in Japan.
i posted this 3 weeks ago:
"home prices are still out of line with family incomes. I see at least another 10-15% to go"
- paul krugman
i agree with memito (and krugman). either incomes need to go up fast (NOT happening) or the home prices need to come down.
you can argue all you want about how prices need to come down, but the fundamentals are against you. Inventory (excluding Manhattan) is down. Foreclosures are down. Interest rates are insanely low, etc. I'm sorry, but I just don't think that we are going to see huge price drops. And you can cite all of the CNBC talking heads you want, it does not make a difference.
If someone had told you in 1988 that Manhattan real estate prices will collapse, you may have laughed. If someone had told you in 2007 that S&P 500 would drop 50% in less than 2 years, you may have called that person crazy.
So why wouldn't real estate prices in Manhattan come down more if every other hot locations have taken a beating? Look around like Fl, NV, CA, and MA all have taken a big hit. Countries like UK, Spain, and Hong Kong have dropped way more than Manhattan.
So unless more high paying jobs come back to NYC the next few months, prices will drop more.
Only those with Sub Primes have been foreclosed on.
Now it's time for the Primes.
Obama's housing plan will not help many people, unfortunately...it needed to be large.
Alpine you keep your head in the sand!
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Despite halts on new foreclosures by several major lenders, the number of households threatened with losing their homes rose 30 percent in February from last year's levels, RealtyTrac reported Thursday.
Related Quotes
Symbol Price Change
BAC 5.76 -0.09
Chart for BK OF AMERICA CP
C 1.78 +0.11
Chart for CITIGROUP INC
FNM 0.42 0.00
Chart for FANNIE MAE
FRE 0.42 0.00
Chart for FREDDIE MAC
JPM 23.75 +0.55
Chart for JP MORGAN CHASE CO
{"s" : "bac,c,fnm,fre,jpm","k" : "c10,l10,p20,t10","o" : "","j" : ""}
Nationwide, nearly 291,000 homes received at least one foreclosure-related notice last month, up 6 percent from January, according to the Irvine, Calif-based company. While foreclosures are highly concentrated in the Western states and Florida, the problem is spreading to states like Idaho, Illinois and Oregon as the U.S. economy worsens.
"It doesn't bode well," for the embattled U.S. housing market, said Rick Sharga, vice president for marketing at RealtyTrac, a foreclosure listing firm. "At least for the foreseeable future, it's going to continue to be pretty ugly."
The rise in foreclosure filings came despite temporary halts to foreclosures by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and major banks JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, Citigroup and Bank of America. Those companies pledged to do so in advance of President Barack Obama's plan to stem the foreclosure crisis, which was launched last week.
Two states that contributing to the increase were Florida and New York, where temporary bans on foreclosures ended.
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Foreclosures-up-30-percent-in-apf-14614126.html
Alpine,
You don't even have the slightest clue about the "fundamentals".
Honestly, the only reason you even care about the housing market is because you own one (or several) and are vested. But that just has led people like you to have absolutely biased and, frankly, uneducated and subjective views of what is taking place because your faint heart can't comprehend that you paid too much if you bought over the past 6+ years.
Real estate isn't a lottery or your retirement fund - though the last 8 years has convinced many that is exactly what it is.
Every one that has bought over the past 10 years have been living in a unique real estate bubble that has helped create this global economic crisis - and now we have to live with the consequences.
Buyers over the past 10 years that STILL think that things are going to come back to the inflated levels of 2004-5 even, are dilusional.
Just because a bunch of amateur-hour morons drove up real estate over the past 10 years, doesn't mean that real estate returns and investment works that way. Too many people have looked at this giant bubble as the norm and not the extreme event it was.
I am afraid that you are one of them.
"Honestly, the only reason you even care about the housing market is because you own one (or several) and are vested."
Wow, you finally figured out Street Easy. NEWFLASH: Everyone here is vested in real estate. Othwerwise, they would not be posting here.
And there are so many differences between the hot markets like CA and FL that I have posted dozens of times, so don't comapre NYC to them. Forelcousres, subprime, overbuilding, etc.
yes to alpine292
"NEWFLASH: Everyone here is vested in real estate. Othwerwise, they would not be posting here."
NEWSFLASH: not everyone here is vested in real estate. There's A TON of renters here who are just waiting for prices to come out of the stratosphere before they purchase. Try reading the boards for a while before you start posting, because you will get flamed if you don't.
We haven't even begun the trip down the yellow brick Option ARM lane. Should be showing up shortly, and lasting through 2010. That will do wonders for the economy and for real estate specifically.
evnyc, are you saying we had a phony economy based on asset bubbles like real estate the equity markets.....and that we've been outsourcing good paying American manufacturing and IT jobs the last two decades? But what about derivatives, siv's and cdo's, isn't financial engineering by wall st firms the way to build the US economy you know like a giant ponzi scheme? The permanent loss of at least 70-100K Wall St jobs St really don't matter to new york real estate right? and the broader loss of another 225k jobs in the new york economy don't matter either right
alpine is right on...interest rates are at record lows, banks are turning a profit, inventory will be decreasing due to 2 year old subprime lack of new development. You can feel the Market Timer Buyers anxiety increasing daily. Savvy buyers are scoring deals right now before prices start their inevitable move higher.
i think that now is a good time to buy for the very wealthy. Those sitting on a ton of cash. Not so sure about the first time buyer wanting to get into their first 1 or 2 bedroom.
Rates are low and should stay low for the next year or two. Inventory will start to tighten but not dramatically until 2010. Hopefully 2010 will be a decent time to get into the RE and stock markets but dont expect returns for a few years. Getting in the market in 2010 means you wont be seeing losses realized right away. 2010 is about staying even.
"inventory will be decreasing due to 2 year old subprime lack of new development. You can feel the Market Timer Buyers anxiety increasing daily. Savvy buyers are scoring deals right now before prices start their inevitable move higher."
Steve, do you have any basis in reality to make these claims? I mean, I know you own a bunch of studios (or whatever) and are deathly afraid of losing your shirt on them. But seriously, you just sound plain uneducated - as if your outlandish claims will have any real effect on this board. Instead of trying to be Atlas and prop up the entire Manhattan market with your silliness, I think your time would be better spent selling those apartments before I wind up buying one from you at 35% of your cost in a foreclosure.
http://ny.therealdeal.com/articles/foreclosures-surge-in-manhattan
SteveF, Your "feelings" are not facts and facts are stubborn things.
th eother factor that SteveF did not point to is lack of new development. There has been very little activity in filing new applications and new buildings breaking ground. This void of activity will have an effect on available units on the market. Most likely it wont be realized until 2 years from now. But once the glut of inventory currently on the market is cleared, there is a large void of new units going to be available. Sepcial K you may very likely see your rent increasing in 2 years and the price to get into the market to buy being out of reach for you again. All the while you have spent $150K renting over the past 5 years trying to time the market and have $0 to show for it.
evnyc=modern just fyi
petrfitz, Take a random walk around Manhattan. I've stopped counting the number of empty lots, which is utterly disorienting for someone who has lived on the island since the late 1970s. The rate at which these demolitions continue to occur even with the economic downturn is stunning. Parts of the city look like Berlin after the wall came down-- large residential construction sites enclosed with those cheap plyboard walls, construction equipment and supplies blocking sidewalks and streets, etc. Literally hundreds of developers all over the city rushed to break ground by the end of last June and the expiration of the last round of 421a abatements. You tellingly neglect to mention the shadow inventory of unlisted properties in buildings that are currently on the market. You have every right to talk up the market, but please have enough respect for the other participants on this board to make those arguments reality-based.
cherrywood - i speak directly about the amount of permits that are submitted to the city for approval. It has stoped and hit an all time low. It is true that permits where at an all time high before 421's expired but that inventory is not all being built and the quantity that is being successfully built will not meet demand. Your point about developments that are stopped are exactly my point. Regardless of the current glut, Manhattan needs X many new units to always be hitting the market to meet demand. Currently new permits are not being filed and developments already approved are not being finished. This will create a demand in a few years.
Yes, permits are at an all time low. But the record for completed Manhattan apartments... 2008.
The 2nd biggest year ever is projected to be... 2009.
Sorry, but you try and hit the brakes on the biggest building boom of all time and it takes YEARS to filter out.
We're going to still have MASSIVE inventory increases for a couple of years.
Again, the 87 bust took FOUR YEARS for the RE market to recover.
McHale - nope, I totally agree with you. I was just trying to point out that plenty of people are interested in real estate who aren't invested in it posting on this board (such as myself and a number of other regular posters). We definitely had a fake economy, and the consequences of that have been and will continue to be huge. If prices came down 50% and I still had a job, I'd buy in a heartbeat. But nationally we're only halfway through this mess, and locally it's just started to have an impact.
"evnyc=modern just fyi"
jasmine=feingirl shill.
"We haven't even begun the trip down the yellow brick Option ARM lane."
So your using the old aand tired Option ARM talking point again. Please, give me a break. No seriously, give me a break. 70% of the Option ARMs are in California and Florida, so do some research ebfore you pull the next talking point out of your butt.
McHale:
"
evnyc, are you saying we had a phony economy based on asset bubbles like real estate the equity markets.....and that we've been outsourcing good paying American manufacturing and IT jobs the last two decades? But what about derivatives, siv's and cdo's, isn't financial engineering by wall st firms the way to build the US economy you know like a giant ponzi scheme? The permanent loss of at least 70-100K Wall St jobs St really don't matter to new york real estate right? and the broader loss of another 225k jobs in the new york economy don't matter either right
"
I think that is well put. I still am flabbergasted by solutions to our economic woes that try to prop up "bubble prices" instead of letting prices stabilize at a sustainable (affordable) level.
I mean should the government just have given Madoff more money to keep the fraud alive and subsidize what was ultimately unsustainable?
> i think that now is a good time to buy for the very wealthy. Those sitting on a ton of cash.... Hopefully 2010 will be a decent time to get into the RE and stock markets but dont expect returns for a few years.
How many wealthy are there - most got wealthy with pixie dust asset values going up be it stocks or real estate. A lot of these prospective wealthy buyers are foreigners, too- if they were lucky enough to have a lot of cash, the dollar going up 20-40% eviscerated their buying power.
Also you contradicted yourself- why should one buy in 2010 if they are to expect to be flat in 2013-2014?
Prices will still get cheaper. The slowdown in filings is likely linked to people hoping that the government will SAVE THE HOMEOWNERS who are underwater. Watch is surge.
Oh I forgot the Dot.com, just put a .com on any stupid idea launch an IPO and walla you're rich!!!! When that collapsed we started a real estate bubble Greenspan kept interest rates low and the gov encouraged lending money to anyone even if you couldn't pay and let's not forgot credit cards for all. Now that the Wizard of OZ has been exposed which is the US economy what productive engine of growth do we has? In the 80's we had the IT boom under Clinton then then 10 years later it morphed into the internet boom which again the US companies owned, controlled and exported worldwide.....then Wall STREET REALLY GOT CREATIVE AND TANKED THE WORLD THE WORLD ECONOMY WITH FINANCIAL ENGINEERING OF TOXIC WASTE.
THE EMPEROR HAS NO CLOTHES
Don't you worry, even in this economy, there are still plenty of wealthy people. Warren Buffett lost $25 billion, but guess what: HE IS STILL A BILLIONAIRE! According to the latest issue of Forbes, there is even a drug lord in Mexico worth $1 billion. So if your unemployed and looking for work, now might be a good time to buy an airline ticket to Mexico City...