New York City Sees Fewer Residents Leave for Other States-NYT
Started by steveF
over 17 years ago
Posts: 2319
Member since: Mar 2008
Discussion about
This article relies solely on data from July 2008. It is therefore as irrelevant to the present as a "pre-9/11 mentality" was to discussions pertaining to nat'l security on Sept 12, 2001.
WV7...okay so let's count everyone who lives in NYC today and present the data tomorrow...
This pertains to the year July 08 to July 09.
Plus, people STILL left for other places, just less than in the years before.
NYC still loses people to other states, but the loss is being offset by foreigners
and immigrants having more babies (seriously, read the article).
I am not saying NYC is not a very desirable place to live, but the article you
referenced does not support that conclusion. Maybe, if you want to be exact, NYC is
less of an undesirable place to live than it used to be, if you accept migration
patterns as surrogates for desirability (which, by the way is pretty subjective).
In any case, I happen to love living here, but I think you need to wait for data
after the sh* hit the fan in the fall, to draw any conclusions for the RE market.
Why don't we look at data AFTER the recession was in full-force and AFTER they raised taxes in the middle of that recession.
Population trends since September have been stagnant. People are not packing up and leaving by en masse to anywhere. No place on earth is prospering right now. There is no magical place that laid off workers can transfer to.
Steve, tell me you aren't THIS dumb...
> ending July 1, 2008
Well, I guess you have been asleep this whole time.
After today's developments, I don't think the financial economy is going to be a source of job growth anytime soon....