300k classic 6es here we come!
Started by nyc10023
over 17 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008
Discussion about
This 90% tax thing is really the end of expensive Manhattan real estate. I can't foresee the future, hope the crime doesn't get too bad - I think only the natives or the young & brave will be left.
are you still drunk from St. Patty's?
nyc10023 - nut job. The employees that received the bonuses aren't paying 90% in tax. The bailout firms are taking the hit.
Alpine292: I'm not feeling sorrow or pity for bankers & their families - this is the game after all. But how much discretionary income will people have left if they're effectively capped at 250k? Prices of real estate will drop drastically and it'll be interesting to see what happens to people who can afford their mortgage but are now underwater by a huge fraction (not just luxe condos here). My neighborhood will take a huge hit from this, some would argue for 70s era atmosphere back - I won't be here to see it :)
Whatsup - are you nuts? The employees who make more than 250k will be capped at to bonus by an effective tax rate of 100% (NYC + NY is more than 10%). And this is retroactive to income earned in 2009 for work done in 2008. So people will absolutely have to pay back next April.
don't worry, I am sure the fine D.C. lobbyists will put loopholes into the bill that are large enough to drive a tryck through.
And many of the families who don't make 250k or even work in finance, but who have saved to buy apts in Lincoln Towers, will be devastated by this. I know, I know, they should have rented. Be that as it may, I think the effects will go far beyond cheap apts.
nyc10023: Didn't crime fall long before the real estate bubble inflated? Let's shoot for a happy medium: 1998 crime rates, 1998 apartment prices. Then would you stay? We'd hate to lose you.
West81st: with all due respect, it won't be 1998 apartment prices. I hope crime rates remain low, would hate to not be able to feel safe on a visit. People were definitely already pulling in biggish bonuses then back in 1998. I was there. I really can't see schools like PS199 continuing to pull in enough PTA fundraising to sustain an aide/class and then the families who were already on the fence will move. In 1998, PS199 was the beneficiary of being 1st choice of many families from out of zone. NYC won't be over, by any means, but many of us in our 30s and early 40s with young children will move, echoing the 70s. And the young will flood in, again. It's all cyclical, as I keep saying. Of course, I'm personally sad to move - but I don't want to be left holding the bag.
Was it all that bad, pre-asset-bubble? I guess things were seedier and crime was bad, but it was what we were used to, odds were against being hit by it, so no big deal. The UWS was still more expensive than most parts of town, but the SROs offered more options. In 1977 I was paying $35 a week at 75th & Amsterdam and was quite comfortable.
bummer nyc10023 - is this your final decision? no wait-and-see?
Why are units in my building still going into contract today at prices only 15% below 2008 peak. I'm in a new build condo on the west side. 4 units have gone into contract in the past 6 weeks. Only a few left in the building.
No, I'm not a broker. Yes, I do think that NYC is about to face a post-nuclear holocaust of crime, poverty and unemployment.
Just don't understand who is buying now at these prices still.
Have to protect our ill-gotten gains :)
you think crime rates are going to spike because investment bankers at a handful of companies are earning 250k per year? what, they are going to be robbing old ladies to make up the extra 500k?
I don't think its $300k. I figure $250k max salary, and the x3 rule for what you can afford.
$750k for 3 beds, a little less for 2 beds.
Nope, but you can't deny that people will leave. No, not 100%, not even 50% but a significant fraction of the "breeding" population will go. Most of those people will earn good money (whatever that is). And that means that taxes collected will go down and services will decline. Even people who can afford to live here won't necessarily want to as schools decline, etc. Not that hard to imagine.
Wouldn't our fine federal government be passing some of this tax revenue on to NYC to deal with budgetary problems?
Waverly: you think? I think not. We're running a huge federal deficit. Why on earth would the feds single NYC out for bounty?
"you think crime rates are going to spike because investment bankers at a handful of companies are earning 250k per year? what, they are going to be robbing old ladies to make up the extra 500k?"
No, crime will spike because we can't afford to pay as many cops the same amount anymore... and the unions will not allow salary reductions.
NYS and NYC budgets will be DECIMATED by this reduction in tax revenue.
Wall Street is 30% of city income. Guess what happens when that goes down 90%, and the other revenue goes down with it....
Why oh why can't income be pegged to cost of living. A $250K salary in NYC is equal to $110K in Boise Idaho.
50 percent employer / 50 employee tax split on the table
Yes, but add NYC city & state taxes - you're talking (if this is the 70%), close to 85%.