Will There be a Foreclosure Crisis?
Started by crescent22
over 17 years ago
Posts: 953
Member since: Apr 2008
Discussion about
Let's discuss - New York real estate in the next 12 months and foreclosures. Manhattan's real estate market started declining later than the rest of the country and even the New York City suburbs. I have thought everything that has developed to the nationwide housing market, specifically foreclosures, prices that won't go up even with higher volumes even with lower mortgage rates, will happen here... [more]
Let's discuss - New York real estate in the next 12 months and foreclosures. Manhattan's real estate market started declining later than the rest of the country and even the New York City suburbs. I have thought everything that has developed to the nationwide housing market, specifically foreclosures, prices that won't go up even with higher volumes even with lower mortgage rates, will happen here as well. You can call my argument simplistically elegant or naively unsophisticated. There have been negative events happening to this market (lower unemployment, lower income, possible secular decline of a major city industry), and there have been positive events (housing stimulus, lower mortgage rates, quick shutdown of forecast new condo supply). Everyone on both sides jumps on events that promulgate their point as if that is the only variable. - Bears: Taxing bonuses eviscerates the market, inventory keeps rising + Bulls/Brokers: Rates are falling, traffic is rising Here is what I read in San Francisco - Feb unit sales were up 51%! Prices were down 48%! The more unit sales were up (outer counties) the more the prices fell. http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2009/03/19/BUNI16JI0A.DTL&tsp=1 So I'm thinking the same thing will happen here. We just need unemployment to continue inching up (or careening up) and more time to pass and many people will exhaust their options and we'll have a bigger forced supply problem. Volume will eventually rise, elastically reacting to lower prices, but they won't entirely offset and prices will keep falling. Now, I guess the co-op stock makes the foreclosure process all hokey- I'm out of my league here. My point is: Foreclosures are not an issue right now at all. Will they become one in New York City? I welcome all viewpoints except those playing the hope game (positive and negative) - there is plenty of real estate on this board to do that elsewhere. [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
17 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
12 Comments
-
1 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
This is a rhetorical question.
Well, let's make sure the counterargument at least gets started.
Manhattan is a pretty unique market for a lot of reasons. Are there elements of this particular real estate market that can result in this downturn being shorter or progressing without a spate of foreclosures?
Crescent - That's an interesting question. I think foreclosures could certainly increase (they have in other boros already). How much of a spike in prime NYC will we see? I would think it should happen less than other areas (like SF) due to: less speculation (condos, I know, but co-ops are still 70%+ of inventory), less sketchy loans (due mostly to co-ops), there is an awful lot of serious/old/family money here that is just not in other cities (although it's a lot less today than 12 months ago) or at least that's few thoughts.
That said, if things continue to deteriorate or congress decides to go crazy yet again, the likelihood of prime NYC having a spike in foreclosures would increase exponentially.
One of the things that I wonder is if technology and communication today would hasten the cycle (up and down) due to the way information is pounded into our heads 24/7 in mediums that are so different than 10, 20 or 30 years ago. People hear negative, negative, negative and it has to prey on their psyche a bit to hasten/exacerbate the downturn. Shouldn't that get you to the bottom quicker? Then, on the upside (things are getting better/don't miss out/etc) wouldn't it help it get a little better a little quicker? Just a thought.
What does anyone else think?
I think yesterday's news added another 10% to the decline.
Comparing the foreclosure process in California to that in New York State is difficult at best. California is a non-recourse state. That means that the ONLY thing backing the mortgage is the underlying asset...the property. The borrower has NO personal responsibility for the loan amount and can hand in the keys and walk at any time. Foreclosure papers are filed and the lender receives the property.
In NY state, the borrower is 'on the hook' for the mortgage amount. The lender can go through the difficult process of getting a 'deficiency judgement' against a borrower in default. The borrower has two choices...1) attempt to segregate other assets and file personal bankruptcy, or 2) work with the lender to come to an agreement.
It is FAR more difficult to walk away from a loan in NY State. Thus, foreclosures will take more time, be less prevalent, and will likely be replaced by short sales (working with the bank to pay some of the mortgage while the bank losses the difference between the mortage and the sale price.)