Brooklyn Declines 12% QoQ
Started by nyc10022
over 17 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008
Discussion about
http://www.hmsassociates.net/ Getting an early jump on the first-quarter market reports due out later this week, appraisal firm HMS Associates drops this Brooklyn data in our inbox: "HMS studied 15 neighborhoods between January 1, 2009 and March 15, 2009. The firm found that the average home price fell by eight percent from $641,464 in the first quarter of 2008 to $589,135 in the period between... [more]
http://www.hmsassociates.net/ Getting an early jump on the first-quarter market reports due out later this week, appraisal firm HMS Associates drops this Brooklyn data in our inbox: "HMS studied 15 neighborhoods between January 1, 2009 and March 15, 2009. The firm found that the average home price fell by eight percent from $641,464 in the first quarter of 2008 to $589,135 in the period between January 1, 2009 and March 15, 2009. The total number of sales dropped 65% from 1004 in the first quarter of 2008 to 347 between January 1, 2009 and March 15, 2009 ... On a consecutive quarter basis, the average home price dropped 12% and sales volume fell 34.7% between the fourth quarter of 2008 and the period between January 1, 2009 and March 15, 2009, HMS said. [less]
(crickets).
I'm wondering what the fall of peak is.
I had figured Brooklyn would be behind Manhattan, but it seems to be catching up (or down) now...
I've been looking in Bklyn Hgts. for quite some time and it seems like there's very little inventory and what's available has been sitting for a while. Some sellers are definitely in denial about the drop in the real estate market as well as ignoring the difficulties in getting mortgages and high unemployment rate in nyc. Sellers are still asking for unrealistically high prices.
I actually don't see any of this from the link provided - assume you just nabbed this from Curbed or Brownstoner? Either way, not sure how much there is to discuss here - I'm actually surprised it isn't more than 12%, though I'm waiting to see the actual reports that should be out by next week. I laughed when I saw the first line - "getting an early jump" - that's totally you!
Yes, early access to correct data.
I know that bothers you so, you like outdated useless information!
"Some sellers are definitely in denial about the drop in the real estate market as well as ignoring the difficulties in getting mortgages and high unemployment rate in nyc. Sellers are still asking for unrealistically high prices."
I've been saying for a while Brooklyn is trailing because of a less liquid market (though not in places like WB with all the new construction).
But, rest assured, the die has been cast.
I never said this data "bothers me" - that's ridiculous! If it's good, it's good! The irony is that now you're citing it, even though you harp on and on about how "outdated" and "incorrect" it is.
"(though not in places like WB with all the new construction)."
I follow the WB market quite closely, and that's just not an accurate statement. Yes, the first Northside Piers tower lowered prices on many units by a considerable amount, but it has proven to be an isolated case so far. It has followed the rest of Brooklyn more closely than it has Manhattan.
> I never said this data "bothers me" - that's ridiculous!
Yes, it is ridiculous, which makes it so funny!
You hem and haw and complain and get all sensitive about it and post and post about it. She doth protest too much!
> "The irony is that now you're citing it, even though you harp on and on about how "outdated"
> and "incorrect" it is."
You get that Brooklyn and Manhattan are different places, right?
I know they didn't explain this on the WB, but they are different. They're separate COUNTIES for god sakes.
Don't confuse them.
"Yes, it is ridiculous, which makes it so funny!
You hem and haw and complain and get all sensitive about it and post and post about it. She doth protest too much!"
Again, this data doesn't bother me - it's your suggestion that it does that is ridiculous. You're just a wee bit oversensitive that I hold your feet to the fire when you rampantly post suspect data as fact.
"You get that Brooklyn and Manhattan are different places, right?
I know they didn't explain this on the WB, but they are different. They're separate COUNTIES for god sakes.
Don't confuse them."
What are you talking about? I'm talking about quality of data - the market reports that will now be coming out do present good data. Much of the junk you've been loosely citing hasn't been that great, but you kept insisting that the market report data was "outdated" and "inaccurate," and now you're citing it! That's the irony! It has nothing to do with Brooklyn and Manhattan being different places, and I don't know how you could possibly have inferred that I conflated or confused the two.
> Again, this data doesn't bother me - it's your suggestion that it does that is ridiculous.
Its not a ridiculous suggestion... because its actually true. You post over and over and over again about it. You are CLEARLY sensitive about it....
As for Brooklyn vs. Manhattan data, you still haven't made it clear that you understand they are two different places! You're calling it the same data.
Wow, you're a funny one!
Not only do you like data from wrong time periods, you are comparing data from different PLACES.
Would be so funny if it weren't true....
nyc10022, no, for the last time, quality data on actual, closed sales prices are good. They don't bother me. Don't know why you insist on arguing this.
As for "making it clear that I understand they are two different places" I didn't know I had to prove that to you - I figured it was so obvious I could take it as a given. Frankly, I'm amazed this is what you have to fall back on when you can't argue any longer.
"nyc10022, no, for the last time, quality data on actual, closed sales prices are good. They don't bother me. Don't know why you insist on arguing this."
Oh my lord, ROTFL! THE DATA YOU WERE ARGUING AGAINST WAS ON *ACTUAL*, *CLOSED* SALES PRICES! And you whined about it over and over again!
Oh my god, it would be so funny if it wasn't so sad!
"I'm amazed this is what you have to fall back on when you can't argue any longer."
Only because everything else you said was so moronic it wasn't worth mentioning!
bjw2103,
nyc10022, got you. Whenever, the 2 of you argue its amazing, I look forward for it and she wins all the time. RE in WillyB a sensitive topic for bjw2103 as you know where he holds a mortgage.
nyc10022,
You know bjw2103 don't like data and comps. You know bjw2103 lacks common sense and believes in the tooth fairy.
Famous quotes by bjw2103
1. I don't know if my property gained, lost or maintained value because I have not tried to sell.
2. I'm not concerned about minor fluctuations in the value of my property. (This is the funniest)
3. Dumbo is dead in the water and WillyB is not dead in the water.
Its just a more subtle form of denial...
nyc10022,
Have all or most properties in NYC lost value?
nyc, I don't accuse anyone of this unless I'm quite certain, but you're either just plain old confused or outright lying to serve your own purposes here. You've tried hard to prop up contract prices and preliminary findings as good hard data. Sorry, and writing in teenage acronyms and all-caps doesn't make your story more compelling.
"Only because everything else you said was so moronic it wasn't worth mentioning!"
Sorry, thought I was dealing with an adult here.
"I look forward for it and she wins all the time."
I look forward for it too.
mutombo, you are a funny man.
bjw, keep digging and digging.
The stats you complained about were CLOSING prices.
Lie, spin, do all you want... you complained about the exact kind of data you now suddenly love.
We knew you were a hypocrite, but now you're just silling, too!
> Have all or most properties in NYC lost value?
Anything that wasn't completed to a huge positive, or had some specific factor (like the addition of a train station next door).
"The stats you complained about were CLOSING prices."
Now, its awful clear, bjw.
You complain about data when you don't like what it says... and then you change your "rules" of what kind of data is ok and not to fit your "point". You love closing prices one day, you hate them another.
That is the worst kind of hypocrisy.
nyc10022,
You are very shrewd and must be a partner in a law firm.
I did take the LSAT way back... but, no, never made it to law school. Not enough money in that field...
nyc10022,
You are too funny. LOL.
"You complain about data when you don't like what it says... and then you change your "rules" of what kind of data is ok and not to fit your "point". You love closing prices one day, you hate them another."
Well, by your logic I would "hate" these data. Except I don't, and you claim to think you know what I "want the data to say." I've been really quite explicit about what data I consider up to snuff. So, really, other than being argumentative and nasty, what's your point?
> I've been really quite explicit about what data I consider up to snuff
Yes, which is why it has been so easy to note your contradictions and hypocrisy!
Slam Dunk!
lmbbao.