Co-op Fees Go Through the Roof - NYT
Started by crescent22
over 17 years ago
Posts: 953
Member since: Apr 2008
Discussion about
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/05/realestate/05maint.html Notably: “Assessments have gone up based on last year’s market,” said David Kuperberg Because each year’s higher assessment is phased in over a five-year period, Mr. Hoffman’s building faces at least four more years of hefty assessment increases as the increases that were issued when the market was booming continue to kick in. Mr. Hoffman... [more]
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/05/realestate/05maint.html Notably: “Assessments have gone up based on last year’s market,” said David Kuperberg Because each year’s higher assessment is phased in over a five-year period, Mr. Hoffman’s building faces at least four more years of hefty assessment increases as the increases that were issued when the market was booming continue to kick in. Mr. Hoffman said that even though the tentative assessment increase for 2009-10 was only 1 percent, the building may have another tax increase of about $83,000 next year because of the phase-in of previous assessment increases." So add this to the list of questions - Does the building have a multi-year lagged increase of maintenance coming? [less]
Buy now or be priced out forever!
Seriously, maintenance increasing for a few YEARS through a recession is not going to be fun for this market.
sometimes the maintenance is as high as the rent on a rent stab apartment of the same size. location is always better though.
How often are buildings assessed? Let's say a building is assessed in 2007 at a stratospheric price, and based on that its RE tax is increased 60%, phased over 5 years, through 2012. Does that mean the building will be reassessed in 2012 or later? What if the building is reassessed in 2010 and shows to be worth roughly half of the 2007 price? Do they reverse course and start phasing a decrease in RE tax, or continue increasing the tax although they have evidence the tax should go way below? Any experience on this...?
these tax rates are only going up. rapidly inflating maint/tax costs are something that is underappreciated IMHO. in fact, most listings are still using 4Q08 carrying costs, which are misleading at best. in many instances, this offsets historic low interest rates. taxes are only going up for real estate and assessment values are so low relative to market that there won't be much of a downward relief there either. let's hope obama isn't successful with the 28% mort deduction cap on high income individuals, otherwise it's going to be game over for mid to high end.
1) I believe reductions are not phased in... only increases
2) Although folks want to believe the increases are temporary because of bubble prices, this is really not the case. Co-ops are UNDERassessed and undertaxed. They value them as RENTAL buildings, and they allow for comparisons to nearby rental buildings with stabilized tenants. Those obviously aren't fluctuating as much as prices or even free market rentals.
This is primarily co-ops just "catching up" to the rest of the world. I don't think we're going to see decreases in our lifetimes.
"Do they reverse course and start phasing a decrease in RE tax..."
Get real - once politicians get their hands on your tax money, they will NEVER let it go (esp if they are Dems). These rates will go up and stay up permanently.
To the extent that interest payments are a component of monthly charges (is that often the case), are these fixed rate. What happens if sooner or later the USA reverts to real interest rates of a few percent ?...in other words, is rising real interest rates (that might result from printing trillions of dollars) a risk factor for monthly charges?..or not really
Cyclicality from bad to worse. Just in time for income and employment to drop - assessments, property taxes, income taxes and condo supply are rising. So much for the monthly cost savings of lower mortgage rates...that was just eaten by maintenance.
"This is primarily co-ops just "catching up" to the rest of the world."
Give me a break. You want to talk about 'catching up?' How about townhouses and brownstones throughout the City? It is perverse how little they pay in RE taxes compared to apartment dwellers.
I agree... townhouses AND co-ops.
Neither pay their fair share... which is why new construction gets its butt whipped.
> compared to apartment dwellers
Don't lump "apartments" together. Old co-op owners are subsidized by newer owners.
nyc10022, I'm missing something. How subsidized? Old and new pay same $ per share.
Sorry, I don't mean within the same building... I mean newer buildings, particularly condos.
Older co-ops pay ridiculously low taxes because of the antiquated laws protected by them and their friends...
Folks don't notice so much with all the abatements, but scary how much cheaper co-op maintenance - which includes a mortgage - can be.
The owners of newer apartments are paying for these older building owners.